Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit

Anthropic prices initial public offering

https://www.anthropic.com/news/anthropic-prices-initial-public-offering
Remember the dotcom? Do you remember companies like AltaVista or maybe pets.com?

Anthropic and OpenAI are the AltaVista of the AI era. With first starter advantage but no real moat and very good at spending money.

I am still waiting for the Google of this era to show its face.

Edit: every time I question these crazy valuations I get down voted really quickly.

loading story #50558471
> Anthropic and OpenAI are the AltaVista of the AI era. I am still waiting for the Google of this era to show its face.

What's your reasoning for why these two are AltaVista and not Google [of the AI era]? How would you differentiate without hindsight?

I was there. Google had a better product, and then - some time later, mind - they discovered that ads work really well for them.

OpenAI and Anthropic have a good product and they (especially Anthropic) are increasingly good at generating revenue from it.

What's missing, in your opinion?

loading story #50558848
loading story #50563254
loading story #50558653
loading story #50561799
loading story #50559851
Because Google was clearly a growth stock. Anthropic has one product in a saturated market and is priced so high that only early investors can profit.

Also, it steals IP.

loading story #50560466
They have a huge moat, unfortunately. The last models are steps above any other company out there.

The newer Chinese models get somewhat close, but OpenAI & Claude got better at stopping them from copying the model so the Chinese models will not make such big jumps anymore. And most Western companies will not use Chinese models if they are not open weight.

If they keep going like this huge parts knowledge work sector (legal, marketing, software, ads, health) economy is AI driven in 2-4 years and OpenAI & Claude will own it. Another huge shift of wealth from the Western World to Silicon Valey.

loading story #50558996
loading story #50559245
A moat would be something that would allow them to slow down. They can't do that. A moat is something that can't be replicated. The performance of their current models will be replicated at some point and sooner rather than later. They can't stop because I don't think they even know how long it will take them to get some better model.

What they have right now is enough money to to work through that. But they don't have enough revenue to keep this up forever and they can't stop either.

loading story #50558486
loading story #50560585
loading story #50558463
loading story #50559819
loading story #50559856
loading story #50558445
loading story #50559133
loading story #50561152
loading story #50560770
loading story #50558967
loading story #50559035
loading story #50563812
loading story #50558898
loading story #50557985
loading story #50559521
loading story #50557732
loading story #50560396
loading story #50570163
loading story #50561260
loading story #50561489
loading story #50561464
loading story #50557926
loading story #50561441
loading story #50559853
loading story #50558744
loading story #50560489
loading story #50561164
loading story #50558994
loading story #50559934
loading story #50558205
loading story #50565404
loading story #50559743
loading story #50557510
loading story #50562190
loading story #50559546
loading story #50559211
loading story #50559321
loading story #50558288
loading story #50559734
loading story #50558187
loading story #50557697
loading story #50559808
loading story #50558895
loading story #50559049
loading story #50558676
I tend to agree that there's no moat in models, which is basically the entire business model for OAI and Ant today, but I do think there is still some money to be made there and it's likely they'll create some useful products around their models.

I don't think these companies are as bad as some dot-com companies, but I personally struggle with coming up with an investment thesis at the current price given it assumes they'll retain pricing power for models. And another problem is that this isn't like Amazon or Facebook where you build a decent product and with a few tweaks every couple of years people will continue to use them for decades – these companies need to develop and release new competitive models every month or two just to retain their market position.

I think the only thesis that makes sense is that the singularity happens, the private companies that owns the models which are produced as a result retain legal ownership of them, and that humans retain control over the models. In my mind I'd give this outcome a sub 1% probability.

The Google of this era is a seedling in my care, but I'm just busy digging my technical moat deeper and deeper while i wait for the clowns to be sent packing.

AMA!

> Edit: every time I question these crazy valuations I get down voted really quickly.

You've gotta understand there's a lot of people on HN with their wealth tied to the success of AI at this point. Every downvote on a post like this is just a lowly engineer that wants to keep having steak dinners.

> Edit: every time I question these crazy valuations I get down voted really quickly.

This is a problem of hackernews. I also made critical comments in another thread and got insta-downvoted. This may even come from bots, it is quite strange. That has not happened on old.reddit.com, for instance. Something is not working well on hackernews in general here. See also the speed limitation, after 5 comments I can not comment for some hours. That's just tedious ...

given the trend you cite, i am surprised the critical content on this thread has held up as well as it has. pets.com comes up and there's a lot of mega-reverse false equivocation. like the analogy is deemed wrong because it is judged on the terms of Borges' On Exactitude in Science, but someone brings up something very wrong in defense, and time is spend arguing over that. the original point is lost in paper millions at stake, and my children need wine!
> With first starter advantage but no real moat and very good at spending money.

They do have moat. Every single company is pushing their private data into these models. Do you really believe that data isn't making into the training data one way or another?

loading story #50557739
loading story #50561449
[flagged]
loading story #50558303
People are saying that Anthropic has no moat which sounds right but at the same time they have left everyone behind: Google is trying lately but seemed very lost over the last years despite inventing the thing; OpenAI cannot match Opus 5.5 and Fable atm; and it seems like anti-distillation efforts really did put a dent in the speed of Chinese model development.

Meanwhile Claude is getting really good. It's a decent harness now, even the remote control over a couple servers is quite OK. They're adding artifacts left and right, new features. And all without making the product seem bloated, they stay focused.

The prediction markets don't show anything on the horizon either: https://releaseoracle.xyz/

I am not a big AGI believer but business- and product-wise it seems like ANT has something that others are missing.

> OpenAI cannot match Opus 5.5 and Fable atm

OpenAI is absolutely crushing Anthropic regarding cost of running models.

A lot of real world scenarios have already been completely solved with models released months ago. My clients don't need more powerful models anymore. They need faster and more affordable models.

OpenAI has been aggressively pushing on both fronts. Where is Anthropic's 750T/s wafer-scale compute offering? Where is this on their roadmap?

It seems like everyone I know outside of tech uses ChatGPT “Chat” on the free tier.

Of the people I know in tech, other than those who don’t use either, everyone is paying for Claude.

It's pretty obvious that OpenAI is dieselgating* the benchmarks. Even 6.2 Astra is nowhere near as good as Claude models for coding. Any software engineer can do a side-by-side comparison (as many of us do) and figure it out.

*Also consider the possibility that Anthropic may be dieselgating it down ("benchminning"?) instead of OpenAI doing benchmaxxing. It might make sense from some game theory standpoint - If you are significantly better than your enemy, it might be in your interest to lull them into believing that you are only slightly better.

I do coding evals every time a new model comes out (that I have access to) and Opus 5.5 is a touch better than Sol 6.2 right now but that’s a recent development. Prior to the 5.5 release open ai outperformed at every tier.

Sol is half the price of Opus and Luna outperforms haiku at every eval I throw at it. Haiku wasn’t even able to complete several of my evals until the newest release.

The idea that Anthropic is miles ahead of OpenAI doesn’t pass the smell test in my usage.

And that’s before the Claude vs Codex comparison (which I’ll grant is more personal preference but I find Claude to be wretched).

loading story #50559031
loading story #50562344
loading story #50561755
loading story #50564393
loading story #50560950
Pretty much. I keep urging my non-tech friends to pay for Claude and they keep using free tier "Chat" like a fancy search engine and copywriter
Well, why would they do that? What use could they get from paying for a somewhat better search engine and copywriter?
Running claude on your personal computer as a non-technical user is reckless bordering on insane. You have absolutely no idea what it's doing!
I’m curious, what’s your arguments?
Do you own shares in Anthropic or is there any reason why you urge people to buy something they don't need?
Anecdata: on my personal projects I vastly prefer to use Opus, and even reach for it to realign Sol once it's started to drift on specific projects instead of bumping up to Astra.

On the other hand, at work, where I have to justify paying API prices, I almost exclusively use Sol, while occasionally bringing in Luna (though I've also been playing with the MS models since yesterday; not impressive, but very cheap).

If they do manage to catch ANT in ability while keeping costs this much lower, they could still leapfrog again. I'm not sure I'd bet on it being soon after seeing Astra 6.2, but I don't think the race is over.

Not going to speculate on how they'll do vs. OpenAI, but to your point on a lot of problems now effectively being "solved", I tend to agree.

I have one recent use case now where using Claude to review it, it first wanted to use Fable, got all excited about possible savings from lower defect rates, had to backtrack and admit that Fable provided no benefit whatsoever to justify the extra cost over Opus after it ran evals (in fact, arguably the quality was worse, but that part was a subjective measurement).

There's a mounting number of tasks like this where the value is going to be falling costs whether by switching providers, or moving down their model ladder as the one below gets good enough.

Given Opus 5.5 is now good enough for the task in my example, it means we have every incentive to start evaluating cheaper models now and again, instead of waiting eagerly for new, smarter models.

I agree, I'm on 6.2 Sol and it feels blazingly fast and it leads to a better UX. It seems to be capable enough to handle 99,5% of stuff that will be thrown at it.
>My clients don't need more powerful models anymore. They need faster and more affordable models.

Honestly this sounds like it calls more for Deepseek v4.1 flash than OpenAI's models, although those charts from earlier this week did look impressive. Trying to compete on price efficiency sounds much more daunting than competing at frontier capabilities tbh.

> My clients don't need more powerful models anymore.

who are your clients and what do they do with ai?

{"deleted":true,"id":50557790,"parent":50557684,"time":1795079762,"type":"comment"}
Lets assume the best Chinese AI lab is an entire year behind. These companies are valued below 20B, while Anthropic is valued above 1T.

Assume nobody ever catches up to Anthropic and everyone will always be 1 year behind. Is the 50x valuation still reasonable? Is the money really in doing PhD level math, or simpler stuff like summerizing coporate emails?

And lets be honest, some US and Chineese labs are only months behind and the only reason they have not fully caught up is limited compute. For China this could change quickly (e.g. Huawei gets their yield issues under control and suddenly Chinese labs have cheaper compute than west). People who invested in Anthropic at 50x valuation must belive this scenario is impossible in the next 5-10 years, but that is a huge bet.

My view is that Anthropic will be the Microsoft of the AI era. The only moat Microsoft has is that it's the default for many enterprise companies. AI needs access to a lot of confidential data to be useful in a large business. If Anthropic convinces enough customers to use Claude Meet, Claude Docs and Claude Sheets they win. Not because their models are so much better, but because all your business data is with them.
Do we have any numbers on who's actually using those ancillary products? All the non-tech folks I know don't touch them. If they want Claude in their docs, they'll just use the plugin for Google Docs or Word.
that's today. they might get used to it when their workplaces start pushing claude sheets/docs/etc on them
I think Google Sheets,etc is just too entrenched, I'm at a small shop of heavy Claude Code users but I haven't heard a whisper of even trying those other products.
Why is this more likely than firms "choosing" Microsoft's equivalent to Claude Code, once they inevitably improve the harness around copilot?

This is not a trick question or anything, I'm genuinely wondering whether stickiness (MS) or product quality/iteration speed (Ant\) would succeed.

loading story #50557796
loading story #50565817
loading story #50561661
We're moving into a world where the model's intelligence is one checkbox among many in the product. As you point out, many companies are able to provide competent models. But that's not sufficient anymore. Buyers want features around collaboration, sharing, permissions, etc.

My analogues for this market are OSes, office software, and CRMs. Windows + Office remain revenue juggernauts 20+ years after fully free and open alternatives got good enough. Salesforce is worth over $100B, even though there have been good FOSS CRMs for literally decades.

IMHO it's difficult to predict how the AI market will evolve without understanding why people continue to choose relatively expensive alternatives that functionally check the same boxes.

Many American companies will preferentially select American providers, so I expect them to have very high retention and also high net revenue retention

Even if new customer growth falls apart, if they can hold 30% growth while public it will be a good buy today.

Why would a more competitive frontier necessarily mean a significantly lower Anthropic market share and not just higher market share for Deepseek etc?

Super intelligence threatens the marketshare of nearly all other companies.

Where is the compute to mass serve these Chinese models going to come from?
> Is the 50x valuation still reasonable? Is the money really in doing PhD level math, or simpler stuff like summerizing coporate emails?

No, and obviously not. Much more going on with this IPO than common sense investing.

loading story #50557698
loading story #50557636
loading story #50558630
loading story #50562049
loading story #50561971
loading story #50562516
loading story #50557671
loading story #50558310
loading story #50557614
loading story #50557759
loading story #50558027
loading story #50558094
loading story #50557657
loading story #50557868
I am totally blown away that a company that was formed in 2021 will have a 1.5 trillion market cap on the public market... to put into context, a valuation not achieved by Apple until 2020
It doesn't say much about the company itself, but about the state of the economy, where all the money has been concentrated at the top, in the hands of people who have nothing else to spend it on than on more financial assets. So there's enormous amounts of money available for more stocks.

It's why stock markets and corporate profits are at an all time high, while most people struggle to make ends meet and governments are woefully underfunded.

That $1.5 trillion IPO is the result of a completely lopsided economy.

loading story #50558202
loading story #50557767
loading story #50557600
The K shaped economy is developing serifs.
It's K shaped economy with the upper arm extended with additional /
We're going to need an additional Unicode character for that.
Well, yes. But also the company is projecting to sell pretty much every white collar worker a $200/mo Claude subscription, which is an absurd amount of revenue compared to said Apple, which promises to sell a new phone to 20% of people every few years.
But will it be Claude? Probably it goes through Microsoft through copilot. In which case it becomes a race to the bottom. I never need Fable even today: Opus suffices on 99%. So why do I need anthropic? Opus will be replicated in half a year by every lab.

In that sense I am super bullish on Microsoft as they have the vendor lock.

For anyone who has used the various tools, the harness still matters and copilot is pretty bad. While Anthropics models lose on cost compared to OpenAI, there is still something that works really well in Opus paired with the Claude desktop app when it comes to tool use and solving tasks.
loading story #50571001
"compared to said Apple, which promises to sell a new phone to 20% of people every few years."

- around 50% in the US market

- they offer way more products, than phones, are the leader with laptops for instance

- take a big cut of every store purchase

The US is just ~350 million out of the ~8000 million people on the planet.
It's hard to put a percentage on it, but I'd wager for 90% of the earth's population, paying $200 a month for a personal LLM subscription isn't viable or simply not worth it.
loading story #50558756
What % of those 8B people can afford an iPhone? How many of those people are located in the US?
loading story #50558976
I am totally blown away that a company who does not turn a profit, whose revenue is slowing down, and has hard financial commitments 25x times, the money they just raised, over the next four years, was able to get 81 billion from investors.

As predictions are only worth anything, if they are made ahead of time...I predict their share price will lose 25% of its value,over the next 3 months. Drop to 40 to 45% of IPO price, after their first public quarter release.

  and has hard financial commitments 25x times, the money they just raised, over the next four years,
They have about $1 trillion commitment in compute over the next 5 - 15 years. I'm not sure where you got the 25x$81b from.
loading story #50557459
$1t notional / contractual but the negotiable terms are unique
loading story #50557535
loading story #50558799
They’ll pop and maybe drop, but Anthropic is the Microsoft of the AI age. This is a generational company that will define the future in so many ways.
let's hope not and instead root for a more evenly distributed AI future with open weight and fully open models, running on local hardware with privacy.
I think there's a future for open weight models. To continue a half-assed analogy, Linux has thrived whilst Microsoft has captured the value. They're co-existed.

Fully open models will be more hobbyist, I expect. Open weights will continue as a strategy but probably not as prominently as today.

loading story #50557887
> but Anthropic is the Microsoft of the AI age

Possible, as long as everything goes well for them. Their debt deals don't care how much of a transformational company they are. If they get less demand than they expect, or slower demand than they expect, they could end up bankrupt.

loading story #50557462
How can charge a premium over competition if they catch up? Branding, smoke and mirrors won’t last long in llm industry. Big corporation switch AI at the blink of an eye. And are already looking more into self hosting.
Well, was anyone else capable of building an operating system other than Microsoft?

The answer is that business is not just technology.

On the technical side, it's also important to see beyond the current market, what's currently possible, and broaden to - ok, many innovations are coming in AI, who is most well-positioned to be the centre of that?

loading story #50559135
Notionally.

The faith/hype vs objective data doesn’t support the valuation.

It is entirely dependent on having faith that this will work as expected.

Or it could be Netscape...

Google could "Internet Explorer" Anthropic to death with a superintelligent ad stuffed free Gemini. shivers

> Or it could be Netscape...

> Google could "Internet Explorer" Anthropic to death with a superintelligent ad stuffed free Gemini. shivers

Hell, Microsoft could do the same with a cheap inferencing model; if people simply use copilot because it's already embedded into all of their applications because it's embedded into the OS (Office, Windows, anything that runs on Windows), only a few dedicated people will continue using the expensive paid-for options.

>This is a generational company that will define the future in so many ways.

You can say the same about the Company of Scotland.

If their business case is true, it has withing itself the seeds of their own death. I can ask a super smart self improving model to create a ...super smart self improving model ,-)

If their bussiness case is not true, we will be paying for this bubble in higher interest rates, for the next 25 years.

Now tell me: Which scenario do you think is more likely until 2030?

A - We cure cancer, create self improving models of hyper intelligence, that will solve Fusion and bring us to the stars, create a CPU, an OS and a 3D printed Car and deliver it to you within the same afternoon, solve Earth warming issues...

OR

B - This biggest credit bubble in history, will put the sovereign debit of the US and 30 year Treasury to 8%, force the US government to default, cut spending, increase taxes and bring about a recession that will take 25 years to recover from?

loading story #50561345
> This is a generational company that will define the future in so many ways.

Maybe. Or maybe not.

It’s already a generational company - $1T at year 5 is no joke.

It has already defined the future in some ways. Claude code has already part determined the future of software engineering, for example.

loading story #50557442
loading story #50557512
good chance those financial commitments will be worth more then they cost as the hardware crunch continues
Well... I guess tackling technological innovation that has a potential to transform human civilization on the most basic level does that for you. It's not acompany that releases 15th overpriced gadget to the increasingly poor populace.
but company that releases 15th overpriced gadget already transformed human civilization. Im pretty sure anthropic will have it's time and become a company releasing 15th overpriced model to the increasingly poor populace. Capitalism is cyclic: expansion, peak, contraction, trough
loading story #50557184
I am blown away that a company spun off from OpenAI is now worth more than OpenAI and is going IPO before OpenAI.
Turns out...in an economy hollowed out by 15 years of governments inflating asset values via money printing, 0% rates, QE & deficit spending; selling to consumers instead of asset holders (businesses) is a losing strategy.

Anthropic picked the better market at least for the short term. Long term I wouldn't count OpenAI out just yet. The consumer market tends to compound into winner take all eventually given the network effects of advertising marketplaces, even more so than B2B.

If that's true then wouldn't Google will eventually beat both of them?
Yes I think Google will outlast them both because they can just put their product into everything people use and cut the other guys out.
Google is running on search Ads revenue, it will collapse if that stream collapses, because company is too overloaded by bloat (200k employees vs 5k in Anthropic).
I'm convinced Google is a much better investment and would like to hear an opposite argument if anyone here has one.

I don't think there is a lot of difference between the "sota" models long term. Even if we said that say Anthropic is ahead, Google will be able to do the same in months.

But if it turns out that open weight models are the future, OAI and ANT are fucked, but Google has massive infra to host those and make money anyway. It also has the products and business connections to integrate AI into users workflows. And lets not forget, it earns massive amounts of money even without AI, so there is a higher price floor even if an AI bubble pops.

And even if it turns out that Anthropic takes over the world, Google still has a stake in them. (Although so will everyone else though SP500 by that point.)

I don't understand why would you invest in Anthropic IPO instead of GOOG, but as I said, would be interested to hear opposing thoughts.

I guess the opposite argument would be that AI success will undercut their search offering.
loading story #50558429
> I'm convinced Google is a much better investment and would like to hear an opposite argument if anyone here has one.

I have an argument, but it's mostly snark.

Like, Google are definitely in the best position here, but they've messed up so many times when it comes to product management/enterprise adoption that I am confident in their ability to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

loading story #50559428
loading story #50558455
loading story #50557012
Google treats both its enterprise customers and retail customers with equal contempt.
loading story #50557064
loading story #50556171
loading story #50556960
loading story #50557337
This post makes me realize that, despite being an enthusiastic Anthropic customer for near 2 years now, I actually don't know any of this historical context.

Down the rabbithole we go. Oh clauuuuude! :D

Helps not being commanded by, even by SV CEO standards, a psychopath.
loading story #50555629
loading story #50561208
loading story #50557375
loading story #50557328
loading story #50557245
And people buying it, expecting it to go up from there, heh.
There is a real scenario, whose probability I cannot accurately assess, in which the first company to build "true" superintelligence will essentially capture the bulk of the entire US economy -- and that it will do so faster than any government can meaningfully intervene. This superintelligence is not a product sold in a chatbot, but rather the internal capability represented by their most advanced unreleased models, mostly without alignment, running on the world's largest GPU clusters, coordinating millions of copies. In this scenario, they don't capture the economy simply by selling tokens, but by owning the internal capability to create (or replicate) any technology, product, or digital business on-demand faster and more cheaply than any other organization on Earth. Selling chatbot tokens would just be the "bootloader" to a future phase in which Anthropic simply enters into and takes over most markets faster than anyone else can do anything about it.

If possible to do, this is a vastly superior strategy to selling tokens, since token consumers can swap out token vendors. But if you simply recreate their entire product and technology lineups from scratch, faster and cheaper, and capture all their customers with superior products and prices (at least at first), then you own the market rather than selling tokens into it amongst other token vendors.

None of this is guaranteed to happen. But I do not see a way to rule it out as a possibility.

loading story #50556605
loading story #50555646
loading story #50556205
Nah. Farmers markets will just get more crowded and full of homemade items. People will move to using local currencies or Bitcoin.

A good fraction of people are smart when the system breaks. Check out the history of the Fall of the Roman Empire. And if Dan Carlin is right, become buds with your local hells angels.

loading story #50555828
Love Hardcore History but haven't caught up on it in a while... What's the Hell's Angels thing?
With the reorganizing of Europe following Rome's decline, Germanic tribe leaders were handlebar-mustached strongmen. Dan Carlin analogizes them as modern Hells Angels members in looks and behavior.
loading story #50556968
loading story #50556997
loading story #50557061
loading story #50557680
loading story #50555759
loading story #50557967
loading story #50557379
Yeh and in this situation the people with real access to the models, who would basically control the entire world at that point, will definitely cut you in because of the piece of paper you have with a claim to 0.1% of the company /sarcasm. I mean you're talking about a capability bigger than the government, who is gonna enforce your ownership?? If you buy into their IPO you're just helping them get to this point faster.
I actually agree with you. But humans are greedy. Really, this entire situation is simply the purest possible expression of human greed.
how ywould your putative superintelligence come up with the supply chains, raw materials and presumably robots to do all this seemingly overnight? or are you only talking about digital goods and services?

even so, what about network effects? how do they lure users away from TikTok and Instagram? AI-generated clips? or say Anthropic recreates Amazon. that's a software company, right? so how do they get all the warehouses, cloud infrastructure (they will need entirely different kinds of datacenters and hardware), relationships with third-party merchants, etc.? or say SpaceX - is your superintelligence going to be setting up massive autonomous factories and buying thousands of tons of aerospace materials and billions of dollars of machinery to make that happen? where's it get the money?

and even if this somehow does manage to accomplish all that, how politically popular will it be? what prevents the US government, lobbied by.. the majority of corporations, and hounded by constituents, from invoking the Sherman Act and busting this trust like AT&T or Carnegie Steel?

In terms of supply chains, imagine a scenario where Amazon undercuts all retail stores, taking absolute control over every consumer need.

They already have solid control over logistics and inventory management.

It’s not a stretch that they then capture the means to control primary inputs and manufacturing.

Throw in an overly enthusiastic AI to continually optimise the supply chain, continually optimising a country’s supply of food and commodities, and we have all the ingredients for the classic sci-fi dystopia of a computer controlled society.

And the masses in this vision are just brain dead consumers with no agency? Market über alles?
loading story #50555643
> entire us economy

> But I do not see a way to rule it out as a possibility.

Your argument is unfalsifiable. Anything can happen by this logic and they could be valued whatever trillion $, like, maybe they’ll invent a way to travel through the multiverse. Maybe they’ll create the star trek replicator thing.

No. While the scenario is speculative in the sense that it is not guaranteed to occur, it is not speculative in the sense of being science fiction. It is a very mundane story of competitive capture of enough existing segments of the economy to gain negotiating leverage that surpasses a threshold. That's really it. It's actually quite boring and doesn't involve anything like what you're suggesting even remotely at all.

It is certainly not unfalsifiable. There are other scenarios in which this does not happen. For instance, the most obvious is that other organizations develop a similar capability at roughly the same point in time. This results in a "multipolar" economy that is mostly controlled by a small set of distinct owners of this kind of capability. The multipolarity prevents total capture and thereby prevents the rest of the scenario. Another obvious scenario is one in which the government acts soon enough to short-circuit this process before one organization gains a sufficiently decisive advantage that government intervention is no longer efficient enough to be effective. Yet another obvious scenario is one where a short-term financial crash deprives Anthropic of enough capital that this strategy is paused or slowed down enough to allow it to be countered. And yet another obvoius scenario is one where the scaling laws simply stop scaling or the amount of compute needed to scale them to this point cannot be physically obtained, thus allowing time for the strategy to be countered.

All of these alternatives would come with clear data points early on which would allow one to distinguish them from the original scenario I described. Right now, though, the data is ambiguous, and some data points lean slightly in favor of what I described, but not nearly enough to make any guarantees whatsoever.

Otherwise known as the "Once we create Skynet, of course it will do what we want it to" business strategy. (For the record, I think the chance of LLMs leading to any such thing is zero.)
Lol, dystopian fiction has such strong roots in our culture.

Why is it that Anthropic gains so much from this perceived image, but then needs to public money to turn it into reality? If they were at all close to any of that, surely their internal AI can figure out how to self-finance the company asap. Or maybe that's exactly what it did and it told it to go public. Company selling shovels adage.

I think markets are way more complicated and capturing them isn't going to happen the way you're suggesting: dollars, and the public, don't really like copypcats. You would need to understand the business, the product, and manipulate people at an unprecedented level. Anthropic selling tokens as their business, means that all the way up to this "super intelligence", means that they've enabled everyone's defenses and raised the threshold for this dystopian hostile taker, i.e., it won't happen.

And it will go up, until the AI hype cycle starts evaluating returns. Which could be 2027 or 2028 or 2030.
The picks and shovels are down 40% in the last two months. You can buy them at a forward P/E of less than 3 if you think earnings hold through 2029. Which is another way of saying that the market doesn't expect them to. There is a staggering amount of money being bet on "it falls apart soon and it falls apart hard."

https://seekingalpha.com/symbol/SNDK/valuation/price-earning...

That's a temporary political blip. Democrats won against data centres but in the next election the money will win over both parties.
It has nothing to do with democrats, that’s just the vacuous meme fed to retail investors. The credit market is tightening and it’s getting harder to borrow money for AI. Coreweave’s unsecured bonds trade at around 15% interest rates. Nvidia’s new CEO doesn’t believe in borrowing money to the customers. The music has stopped.
Yeah, people wanting the bubble to pop haven't been paying attention. It's been popping with the weakest entrants first - the neoclouds. ANT originally wanted to go out at a 2T valuation and had to pull back to where it is now.
loading story #50555270
Isn't it more companies buying it rather than people?

I could imagine a company owning a substantial share could do it for other reasons other than expecting Anthropic valuation to go up.

loading story #50555634
The smart money was already in Anthropic at the series A, B, C stages in the private markets. (Which is where the quick money is made)

Are you (the IPO buyers) really expecting this company to do another 100x from its inflated valuation even after the lock up period expires?

AGI will be achieved in 15 hours and you will become their exit liquidity during the IPO fan fare.

Exactly. This is for suckers so the smart money can cash out.
They are only cashing out like $2B. Non-founder directors, employees etc can also sell 10% of their shares immediately, but most of the rest is locked up for 180 days.
At these valuations, 10% is enough for most of them to retire quite comfortably.
The employees are also the suckers in this scenario.
These lockout periods are such a joke. It sounds like we're talking about meme coins.
loading story #50561034
The suckers are going to be pension funds just like with SpaceX. The sheer size will mean OAI and Anthropic are fast tracked into indices and thus tracking ETFs that are among the most popular investment vehicles as they are low-fee, which means an immediate influx in capital followed by a permanent money spigot from pension savings.

And when it all crashes down, there will be fire sales and the vultures that are flush with cash from the exit will buy up what remains at ridiculous discounts.

We shall own nothing and rent everything, and Big Tech is obviously colluding with Big Finance to usher in neo-feudalism.

Don’t underestimate just how many suckers we’re talking here, won’t be surprised if Anthropic 10xs. Anthropic will use bitcoin style valuations.

And if they dont, then we’re all screwed

10x is unlikely, but the IPO is only ~5% of shares, and then they will release twice that fairly soon after. So it's VERY likely to see some rise early on, but not likely to be a sustained rise in pricing as the amount of shares available continues to increase significantly.
Who's "we"? IMO, if Anthropomorphic does 10x, then knowledge workers are screwed.
If it doesn't raise enough for the smart money to cash out, it stops looking so smart.
Something something Tesla will be a 30T company.
loading story #50563187
loading story #50557302
loading story #50557612
loading story #50555826
loading story #50564027

  The offering consists of 980,000,000 shares of Class A common stock

That 980M is more than they had previously offered (825M), so they did expand the IPO.

And they're taking around ~105B in cash.

81.34B from the 980M shares at $83 and 26B from Google/Nvidia/etc, minus 1.9B the existing holders selling 23.6M shares.

Perhaps they were expecting to be more oversubscribed? Like they increased the number of shares offered to keep a target amount of money. Likely they see the rough few months ahead. Ramp.com AI index shows spend on Anthropic AI was in decline/flat July 31 - Oct 31

Likely they're best bet is to weather the continued devaluation of tokens and cheaper models until they hit on a better business model, which honestly is probably not that hard.

Here's the index mentioned, if anyone else was wondering like me: https://ramp.com/data/ai-index#adoption#models
loading story #50555219
That's pretty biased. Ramp is used by tech companies and tech companies are heavy AI users. Small businesses don't use Ramp
I wonder if early adopters are overrepresented in Ramp's customer base, so if they start learning how to get the best bang for buck in their AI spending at the same time the laggards are starting to spend real bucks in AI, Ramp's data may be bearish while the reality is bullish.
Anecdotally I’ve seen small businesses using ramp
Oversubscription was kind of a self fulfilling prophecy. Large investors and institutions placed larger orders knowing the IPO would oversubscribe and they wouldn’t get their stated allocation.
It's a common pattern for IPOs, regardless of demand. Companies gauge the price range during the roadshow, make an initial announcement at a low price, then raise the target at the last minute going into the IPO to make it look like a hot offering.
The previous range was 70-78 and it priced above the target range, at $83.

So they are selling 20% more shares and selling them for 15% more than the midpoint of what they were targeting, because the demand is overwhelmingly high. They are going to make $20B more from the IPO than planned.

The rumor is they were oversubscribed by more than 6 times over. SPCX was reportedly only 3.5-4.

loading story #50562185
Cashing in as much as they can, while they still can!
Markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.

Be careful out there.

Allowing employees to sell immediately, I don’t think that is a good sign.
Why is that a bad sign? I think it's weirder to restrict employee selling, makes it look more like you need to hide something.

Just allowing them to sell if they want doesn't seem problematic to me, unless they all (or a large number of them) actually sell immediately. Then obviously something's wrong.

Note that this is an actual question, I'm not even close to an expert with these things.

If everyone working there could cash out everything immediately, and be set for life (eight figures), I seriously think many would hand in their resignation and the company would face some operational crisis.
loading story #50558457
It's a bad sign because it indicates that they're hoping to sell themselves.
Insider selling coincides with lowered stock price pretty much universally. Lock in signals trust. It says to investors, we're in this together and you can be assured we're equally interested to take the stock price up.
Because they’re dumping their shares immediately. If you genuinely believed in AGI, why would you sell? :)
Is that a given (or has this happened in this case?)? Why wouldn't at least some employees who think there's a future for the company hold on to it?
> why would you sell?

To diversify.

loading story #50561413
loading story #50562502
If you believe in agi you’d sell and live life now. Not hope for more cash later
loading story #50559978
If AGI becomes a thing, competitors will also achieve it. Open models, too.

At which point any model moat will vanish. Might as well cash out, and put your money into the compute providers.

Wont the AGI kill competing AGIs and humans too?

source: Terminator 2 movie

No, it's the opposite. If you truly believe in AGI the more reason to sell, asap ;) Money, at least, is likely to be worthless. Assets maybe not. Who knows what the future will hold, but all things considered it makes slightly more sense to hold tangible assets than 0 and 1s.
Because after AGI money will be worthless
loading story #50558317
Maybe they genuinely believe in ASI.
The exact opposite. Companies restrict employee sale on IPO because they're worried that it will hurt post-IPO price if employees sell on the bell. This is a highly unusual show of confidence from Anthropic. Note that the IPO is already oversubscribed, so demand is well ahead of supply.
loading story #50559417
loading story #50555351
loading story #50559867
loading story #50555857
loading story #50554863
What do we think the stable state market cap for anthropic is? $200B? 2T? I struggle to believe this is worth like 5% of total US GDP.
comparing a stock (ANT) to a flow (GDP) is a common finance mistake. You shouldn't compare a stock to a flow, they are measuring different things. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stock_and_flow
> However, one may meaningfully take ratios of stocks and flows, or multiply or divide them.

Right out of the section comparing stocks and flows

The OP was clearly comparing the GDP of the US to the market cap of ANT rather than taking a ratio for comparison to other ratios.
Literally Buffet did this, are you a better investor?
loading story #50558489
loading story #50555833
loading story #50556085
loading story #50557410
loading story #50555820
loading story #50555870
I am very curious how a publicly traded AI lab will use model releases as stock pumps. For example, if you are in the lead, do you sit on a new model until the stock price falters, and then release?
Not if the stock has priced in a certain cadence of model releases. Same as the expectation of a new iPhone each year.

Stock price will be directly linked to having the best model (which could give OAI an advantage as they aren't competing with shareholder interests - yet)

Why would this be different than any other publicly traded company?
Possibly not that directly. Because training is expensive and that affects your quarterly profits and that affects your stock price. If you can reduce how often you need to train a new model you lower your costs.
loading story #50555575
loading story #50558478
I stopped buying IPOs a while back, and have had zero regrets. I don’t think I’ve seen a single one stay above the IPO price during the first year. Nearly all, especially for companies in growth stages, hit a wall where they’re still growing and burning cash… it causes the market to turn on them, and the stock drops to anywhere from 40-90%.

That’s not to say there aren’t a lot of winners even 1-2 years later but I’ll happily be sitting this one out (and wait for a drop or two). The market gives some pretty sweet deals for those who are patient.

Uber stock gained 65% since its IPO. Airbnb stock gained 29% since its IPO. Snowflake is up 16% since its IPO.

That's quite non-impressive when you remind yourself that these IPOs happened a lot of time (6+ years) ago, and that their stocks are highly volatile.

It seems to me the VC system got quite efficient to accurately compute the total addressable market well enough and inject their money to grow until that whole TAM is covered enough.

Then the VCs release the now horizontal stock to the public markets.

That being said, there are also counter examples, like Datadog (up 362%) or Crowdstrike (up 1377%), both in the same IPO class as Airbnb and Uber.

loading story #50555793
You’re missing my point, Uber is a great example of what I’m trying to say… after IPO it shed 50% of its value within six months and it wasn’t until 18 months later that it was back to IPO pricing and 24 months before it was above it. Buying it at IPO, you’d still be up, but you’d be up a lot more if you just waited six months or a year.

The same with Datadog, Robinhood, Facebook, Coinbase, Crowdstrike, and I’m sure I could go on. Even ARM was generally flat for six months after IPO… the only real winner I’ve seen recently was Reddit (which dropped a bit but was briefly flat before going up).

My point is buying the IPO instead of waiting will probably have you overpaying for it in the short term (1-2 years), long term it doesn’t matter (if the stock/company is making money). Most big tech IPOs have a sell-off, sometime within the first year or so, and it has been nothing but beneficial for me to wait.

I absolutely want to buy Anthropic’s stock, I’m just willing to wager I’ll get it at a hefty discount sometime in the next year or so… from what I’ve seen their revenue is nowhere near their valuation and we’ll probably see the market recognize that (even briefly).

You are absolutely right.

IPOs statisticly do mostly bad within first 12 - 18 month of trading; this is mainly due to institutionals & insiders selling their stuff.

loading story #50558642
loading story #50555754
loading story #50558747
This could cause an overall correction in the market I think. It's likely people will take money out of NVDA and other AI stocks to buy Anthropic's IPO. This could send NVDA and other AI stocks further downward and maybe even cause more panic selling. So the market caps of those companies decrease. Then that value is lost when Anthropic's IPO share price falls from insider selling, lack of interest, etc. In fact, if OpenAI has an IPO, Anthropic shares could be dumped to buy OpenAI. It could cause an overall decline in the market.
They are only floating about 70b for public trading. This is very small figure compared to nvidia's market cap and really minuscule smaller compared to the overall market size. People are moving money out of nvidia for other reasons, but it's most certainly not because of this ipo.
loading story #50556297
loading story #50560352
loading story #50559437
loading story #50554811
loading story #50556956
loading story #50561710
loading story #50561640
loading story #50557909
loading story #50562755
loading story #50560869
loading story #50560662
loading story #50558305
loading story #50561379
loading story #50557672
There's no voting rights, and no foreseeable profit sharing. As with most tech stocks, you're speculating on Pokémon cards with more liquidity.
It is not quite as bad as Meta. Meta concentrates shareholder and board-election control with one guy (Zuckerberg), whereas Anthropic divides power between its founders and a trust intended to protect its long-term AI mission.

Neither structure gives ordinary public shareholders control proportional to the money they invest. This should probably be made illegal.

> Neither structure gives ordinary public shareholders control proportional to the money they invest. This should probably be made illegal.

I would prefer it if people were still allowed to invest in such companies in the public markets, but perhaps we can make it so that inclusion into an index requires "1 share = 1 vote". That way, at least retirement funds are protected.

I would prefer the exact opposite: non-voting shares in indexes protected only by law. I don't want my index manager to act on my behalf. That's the exact opposite of why I buy index funds.
Meta is up 1,522% since IPO. The reality is founders care way more about the long-term health of the company than the typical outside board member that is just farming prestige and owns minimal equity. Do you really think the former president of Taco Bell International knows more about how to run Nvidia than Jensen Huang?
Meta would be even higher had Zuckerberg not wasted time, money and talent on that Metaverse nonsense.
loading story #50560617
Yes he probably does because he knows not to commit treason and fuck spies. When’s the last time you heard the president of Taco Bell being black bagged at the airport? When’s the last time you heard of them getting fired for spying?
loading story #50564267
They used their most advanced models and it replied "in 2026, the best way to make money is a good old fashioned scam!"
For a moment I thought you're talking about the crypto market. :)
I just hope this doesn't end in my retirement fund
I'd love to know how exposed we are in Europe to a potential crash.

I'm getting 2008 vibes.

loading story #50557864
I'm getting 2000 vibes and not even joking. It's almost the same. I'm pulling out of any and all market investments except maybe BRK.B
Technically it’s not as bad. We don’t have the same AI industry so fewer companies to go bang, and traditional “legacy” companies will be havens for investors.

However… when America sneezes, europe catches a cold.

The biggest problem is that poor economic management (in the UK, austerity under Osborne and the Covid response) has eaten our margin. We are not starting from a position of strength.

loading story #50555546
loading story #50555363
> I just hope this doesn't end in my retirement fund

Don’t worry. It will.

Models are popping from left and right. Is that couple months of lead trillion dollars more valuable?
They sell trust, and they sell "the best one".

The specific models and capabilities are a sideshow.

And hence, the money flows all to the top despite viable alternatives...

(a separate market of workloads is contracted out to Fireworks, Baseten et al. and a third segment DIY it with rented or owned GPUs. But those customers are different buyer archetypes little overlap with those buying trust.)

Well then they have failed miserably. They cannot be trusted, with all that anti-user behavior, fearmongering and all that stuff.
Why trust them though? They're a cult.
Models are useless if you don't have the infrastructure deals to run them at scale. I know people that use cheap Chinese models and get good results from them. But they are paying a lot for self hosting those models. The models are cheap but the infrastructure isn't.

The reason I think Anthropic's position isn't that strong is that most of the money they raised will go into making other companies very rich. Because they don't actually own a lot of the infrastructure they need. OpenAI has similar issues. The companies that actually provide the data centers (i.e. hyperscalers), chips, gas turbines, etc. Will be on the receiving end. And of course some of those hyperscalers have their own ambitions on tapping into the same markets. The SpaceX pivot to data centers in recent years is particularly interesting. Anthropic is already paying them a lot.

The reason I'm fairly optimistic overall about the economy is all the spending that will result from these investments in all that physical stuff represents an enormous cash injection in the economy. The investment bubble may or may not burst but it won't wipe out the infrastructure. If Anthropic collapses, that infrastructure will just be gobbled up by whomever takes over.

I wonder if China will get their head out of their asses and start manufacturing chips to construct electronics and infrastructure to run AI.

Oh, you mean they have already started on it??

They also has the most energy production. They will go past anyone else at this rate.
Are you willing to bet they can't stay ahead?
For actual science done by scientists they're far behind open models now.

The people I know using this model are perpetually hamstrung by slowness, pedantry, misplaced assumptions and appeals to authority. You can't move forward if you're just trying to norm your training data.

They've created this extremely slow, overwrought system with lots of guardrails and token limits designed only to create addiction. Why would you use that when you can have a marginally less "smart" system that's 50x faster and 100x cheaper? Who cares if the model one shots something. It needs to be checked anyway, by test in a machine or a lab.

What models are scientists using that they gain so much more marginal value from than Claude-class models?

Who are the pedantic, authority-appealing users who are using this model?

What makes you believe they’re norming their training data to that group?

Cloud models have zero value if the findings of scientist are absorbed by these same cloud models and "by coincidence" then published before them. It is impossible to get ZDR as individual that you can trust.
Statistically how many companies that were first to any market the eventual dominating leader of that industry? To me it would still be like picking a single number off a roulette wheel because it is a very slightly larger slot to bet on. Maybe it will pay off, it might even be statistically the best choice, but it is still a slim chance overall that it will be the winner.
loading story #50557360
loading story #50558099
loading story #50559583
loading story #50556285
loading story #50557109
loading story #50560991
loading story #50562201
loading story #50562903
loading story #50567587
Will this have SPCX price action? Or will it just drill to the center of the Earth like CBRS?
loading story #50555238
The extinction train continues to gain momentum.
loading story #50557030
loading story #50554726
loading story #50561713
loading story #50561760
loading story #50555034
loading story #50561763
loading story #50561751
loading story #50565083
loading story #50556219
loading story #50561704
loading story #50555015
loading story #50555173
loading story #50556999