Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
There is a real scenario, whose probability I cannot accurately assess, in which the first company to build "true" superintelligence will essentially capture the bulk of the entire US economy -- and that it will do so faster than any government can meaningfully intervene. This superintelligence is not a product sold in a chatbot, but rather the internal capability represented by their most advanced unreleased models, mostly without alignment, running on the world's largest GPU clusters, coordinating millions of copies. In this scenario, they don't capture the economy simply by selling tokens, but by owning the internal capability to create (or replicate) any technology, product, or digital business on-demand faster and more cheaply than any other organization on Earth. Selling chatbot tokens would just be the "bootloader" to a future phase in which Anthropic simply enters into and takes over most markets faster than anyone else can do anything about it.

If possible to do, this is a vastly superior strategy to selling tokens, since token consumers can swap out token vendors. But if you simply recreate their entire product and technology lineups from scratch, faster and cheaper, and capture all their customers with superior products and prices (at least at first), then you own the market rather than selling tokens into it amongst other token vendors.

None of this is guaranteed to happen. But I do not see a way to rule it out as a possibility.

This is the myopia of tech people.. they exaggerate the weight of digital. AI could very well be able to replace any digital business. But purely digital businesses are such an unimportant sector of the economy. All of the important sectors use digital infra at some point, but none are purely digital.
Those businesses will simply buy tokens, as they already are. Their strategy will increasingly be steered by AI under the control of Anthropic. Their internal operations will no longer function without Claude. They'll shed staff and optimize their organizations around the extraordinary savings offered by AI. Their physical operations will gradually be automated under the control of robotics powered by Anthropic. Those who don't do this will go bankrupt in the face of competition from those who do. In some cases, perhaps many, to accelerate this they'll simply get bought out, then forced through the above process faster than it would organically occur, either by Anthropic itself or a new breed of private equity firms that specialize precisely in this kind of operation. The process will be slower at first, but not nearly as slow as you think, and nothing you mentioned stops it.
Are the designs for robots digital? If they are, they might become really good, right...?
Or just another instance of liberatrian nerd Dunning-Krueger. "Faster than any government can meaningfully intervene", c'mon - if really it is that kind of force majeure thing, they will just say "screw the free market". As if the government is bound to uphold the sacred rules of neo-liberal economics.

Same as Goedel thinking that a logical loophole in the constitution is something that could turn America into a dictatorship legally. Guess what? In practice, somebody wanting to instate a dictatorship probably won't give a crap about some subtle logical fallacy. Same with the Keynesian economics that Americans perceive as law.

You seem to think I'm invoking some kind of obscure academic theory. I'm not. This is actually the most basic competitive process imaginable playing out, and that's all it is. That's exactly why it's actually plausible.
{"dead":true,"deleted":true,"id":50564313,"parent":50557003,"time":1795113825,"type":"comment"}
The bet is that sooner or later, even the remaining meatspace holdouts will be effectively digital and thus controllable by AI.

A lot of manufacturing is already there - that's a part of why China undercuts Western manufacturers, a lot of cheap land and subsidies means you can be far cheaper than Western companies already, even more if you automate what you can. Farming, at least anything with growing plants, is also barely requiring humans any more - precision farming with RTK is absolutely insane. And what remains is trades (where, again, automation like prefabrication is a threat), parts of healthcare and education.

We will own nothing, rent everything and fight for the scraps Sam Altman hands to us.

Or we go and sabotage a couple of data centres and be done with it.
>Farming, at least anything with growing plants, is also barely requiring humans any more - precision farming with RTK is absolutely insane

In your dreams maybe, but not in actual real life.

And if you want an actual Butlerian jihad to happen in real life, then yeah, please put out of work everyone associated with farming on the planet within a few years. You describe the golden path to full-on civil war in 3/4 of the world's countries, with either AI being destroyed or an automated massacre _à la_ Terminator.

Farming is already at <1% of people in society (Germany is at 875k of 85m population). And that is only due to mechanization and large scale consolidation.

As soon as there is wealth available to finance modern ag equipment, farming employment will only fall because the productivity gains are too big to ignore.

And precision farming will go even further. Much more yield with even less staff than we already have, the only reason why it isn't commonplace is that the required tractors cost north of 500k a piece and agriculture is risk-averse. But mark my words in 10 years it will be the norm in Western countries.

loading story #50572541
The near total wipeout of agriculture jobs was in fact one of the first major labor disruptions in history.
> purely digital businesses are such an unimportant sector of the economy

what? facebook? netflix? google?

selling ads is split between internet and TV + some legacy media (like it or not) + maaaaybe some outdoor

computer games are bigger than movies?

You might have a point with computer games. But if you take facebook on the other hand, it would be worthless without people using it. An AI would just create the website. For most businesses, there are non-digital elements which play an essential role, and that remains true even with AI.
In such a world, do shares in that entity help you out somehow.
Exactly! Also in such a world why would they IPO and sell so many shares (in particular if SI is imminent)? Better keep the company private and capture all the economic value created
Because they need money now and already have just about maxed out their debt load?
No idea, truthfully.
Buf after the phase...

(Stocks held during wW1 and WW2 did well afterwards)

>they don't capture the economy simply by selling tokens, but by owning the internal capability to create (or replicate) any technology, product, or digital business..

No, what that AI will do is that it will create an artificial reality (because people will perceive the world through the words of the AI) that caters to the highest bidder.

Expect this to happen in the next 20 years.

Nah. Farmers markets will just get more crowded and full of homemade items. People will move to using local currencies or Bitcoin.

A good fraction of people are smart when the system breaks. Check out the history of the Fall of the Roman Empire. And if Dan Carlin is right, become buds with your local hells angels.

Collapse of existing currency is a reasonable prediction for what might come next in this scenario, if that is how you intended your comment to function.
Love Hardcore History but haven't caught up on it in a while... What's the Hell's Angels thing?
With the reorganizing of Europe following Rome's decline, Germanic tribe leaders were handlebar-mustached strongmen. Dan Carlin analogizes them as modern Hells Angels members in looks and behavior.
Except Hells Angels are senior citizens. It’s not 1969 anymore.
Outlaw tricycle clubs are still a thing, they're still patching in, dealing drugs, and hiring mercenaries to take out rivals.

eg: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-02-20/david-pye-guilty-orch...

Well it says that guy is 43. That’s also Australia, that’s not how it is in the US.
> Well it says that guy is 43

and not a senior citizen, and in a gang with younger and older members.

> That’s also Australia, that’s not how it is in the US.

Gang intelligence units here in Australia say that these clubs in Australia have affiliations with gangs around the world, including the the United States.

Gangs in the USofA agree:

  There are more than 300 active OMGs within the United States, ranging in size from single chapters with five or six members to hundreds of chapters with thousands of members worldwide.  The Hells Angels, Mongols, Bandidos, Outlaws, and Sons of Silence pose a serious national domestic threat and conduct the majority of criminal activity linked to OMGs, especially activity relating to drug-trafficking and, more specifically, to cross-border drug smuggling. Because of their transnational scope, these OMGs are able to coordinate drug smuggling operations in partnership with major international drug-trafficking organizations (DTOs).
DoJ (USofA chapter, Nov 2023) - https://www.justice.gov/criminal-ocgs/gallery/outlaw-motorcy...
I’ve lived all over the US and I can tell you this is false. The only people riding around on motorcycles here are boomers and burnt out veterans.
Don't tell me, tell your DoJ.

Also, outlaw motorcycle club 1% types don't necessarily ride motorcycles ... it's more about the club and the lawlessness (and burying piles of cash).

Farmers’ markets are for rich people nostalgic for an imagined past, when rosy-cheeked, healthy maidens milked cows barehanded, with the kind of smiles only 21st-century orthodontics can deliver.
>>with the kind of smiles only 21st-century orthodontics can deliver.

love this pat of the sentence :-D

well according to mastication theorists, dental spacing/crowding was naturally in a healthier state due to increased chewing.

The fair, pink cheeked lady image is the one to be more unlikely, disfigured by cow pox scars, parasites and herpes.

In today's environment, sure. They are institutions that can expand to fill a need should it arise.

The Filipino municipal bazaars show what they could turn into when transaction costs go too high, as well as when comms and travel are difficult. They can be the lifeblood of a community.

We in the US/Europe are a little spoiled with accessibility of retail goods.

I think your orthodontics quip is inaccurate.

The dental maladies afflicting us are a product of soft, highly processed sugary food.

Lmao. If that happens, farmers are guarding their crops with their lives and the people with the most guns will be the ones in power. Your hippie fantasy won't happen, sadly.
Chaos would certainly be the first stanza in the chorus of calamity and recovery. But it normalizes -- quicker than you might think, I'll add.

The people with the most guns also sleep, and communities have long memories. There are good reasons "might makes right" doesn't scale or really hold any form of cohesion beyond a band.

> Check out the history of the Fall of the Roman Empire

Hundreds of years without sanitation?

At least they dropped the shared wiping sponge on a stick!
I don't see it working out. Before you could get any real balls rolling in the physical world competitors will be there with their own GAI, assuming we are anywhere near actually building it to start with which I seriously doubt.

And even if they are first, why assume the first is going to be the best? Maybe 6 months later a different AI model will come out that stomps all over the first one. Maybe a competitors isn't any smarter but they can do it with half the power and can scale their intelligence twice as fast, so even being later they still end up in the lead.

{"deleted":true,"id":50555790,"parent":50555759,"time":1795059525,"type":"comment"}
data moat; evidence is that we are not seeing it; and second mover advantage isn't there if they are AI-fying traditional industries.
If someone makes (super) AGI which improves recursively, open AGI will also be a thing shortly after. Not to mention all the commercial competitors (OpenAI, Google, Meta, X, etc.)

Microsoft still dominates the office tooling, and many will thus get their AGI via copilot and similar.

> owning the internal capability to create (or replicate) any technology, product, or digital business on-demand faster and more cheaply than any other organization on Earth

In this scenario, capitalism is by definition over, and market valuation becomes a meaningless concept.

I'm not sure how so many people betting on this scenario don't see that fundamental flaw: if one company can replace the whole economy, then there is no economy. In the "good" outcome the whole economy gets replaced wholesale by some flavour of "luxury space communism", and in pretty much any other outcome we end up with war/famine/etc as the system breaks down

Yeh and in this situation the people with real access to the models, who would basically control the entire world at that point, will definitely cut you in because of the piece of paper you have with a claim to 0.1% of the company /sarcasm. I mean you're talking about a capability bigger than the government, who is gonna enforce your ownership?? If you buy into their IPO you're just helping them get to this point faster.
I actually agree with you. But humans are greedy. Really, this entire situation is simply the purest possible expression of human greed.
how ywould your putative superintelligence come up with the supply chains, raw materials and presumably robots to do all this seemingly overnight? or are you only talking about digital goods and services?

even so, what about network effects? how do they lure users away from TikTok and Instagram? AI-generated clips? or say Anthropic recreates Amazon. that's a software company, right? so how do they get all the warehouses, cloud infrastructure (they will need entirely different kinds of datacenters and hardware), relationships with third-party merchants, etc.? or say SpaceX - is your superintelligence going to be setting up massive autonomous factories and buying thousands of tons of aerospace materials and billions of dollars of machinery to make that happen? where's it get the money?

and even if this somehow does manage to accomplish all that, how politically popular will it be? what prevents the US government, lobbied by.. the majority of corporations, and hounded by constituents, from invoking the Sherman Act and busting this trust like AT&T or Carnegie Steel?

In terms of supply chains, imagine a scenario where Amazon undercuts all retail stores, taking absolute control over every consumer need.

They already have solid control over logistics and inventory management.

It’s not a stretch that they then capture the means to control primary inputs and manufacturing.

Throw in an overly enthusiastic AI to continually optimise the supply chain, continually optimising a country’s supply of food and commodities, and we have all the ingredients for the classic sci-fi dystopia of a computer controlled society.

And the masses in this vision are just brain dead consumers with no agency? Market über alles?
Why do you expect your shares to be worth anything in that scenario? Note that their own timeline prediction involves a “pivotal act” in which their AI seizes the means of production.
I don't really expect anything. If that scenario actually happens, all bets are off.
> entire us economy

> But I do not see a way to rule it out as a possibility.

Your argument is unfalsifiable. Anything can happen by this logic and they could be valued whatever trillion $, like, maybe they’ll invent a way to travel through the multiverse. Maybe they’ll create the star trek replicator thing.

No. While the scenario is speculative in the sense that it is not guaranteed to occur, it is not speculative in the sense of being science fiction. It is a very mundane story of competitive capture of enough existing segments of the economy to gain negotiating leverage that surpasses a threshold. That's really it. It's actually quite boring and doesn't involve anything like what you're suggesting even remotely at all.

It is certainly not unfalsifiable. There are other scenarios in which this does not happen. For instance, the most obvious is that other organizations develop a similar capability at roughly the same point in time. This results in a "multipolar" economy that is mostly controlled by a small set of distinct owners of this kind of capability. The multipolarity prevents total capture and thereby prevents the rest of the scenario. Another obvious scenario is one in which the government acts soon enough to short-circuit this process before one organization gains a sufficiently decisive advantage that government intervention is no longer efficient enough to be effective. Yet another obvious scenario is one where a short-term financial crash deprives Anthropic of enough capital that this strategy is paused or slowed down enough to allow it to be countered. And yet another obvoius scenario is one where the scaling laws simply stop scaling or the amount of compute needed to scale them to this point cannot be physically obtained, thus allowing time for the strategy to be countered.

All of these alternatives would come with clear data points early on which would allow one to distinguish them from the original scenario I described. Right now, though, the data is ambiguous, and some data points lean slightly in favor of what I described, but not nearly enough to make any guarantees whatsoever.

Otherwise known as the "Once we create Skynet, of course it will do what we want it to" business strategy. (For the record, I think the chance of LLMs leading to any such thing is zero.)
Lol, dystopian fiction has such strong roots in our culture.

Why is it that Anthropic gains so much from this perceived image, but then needs to public money to turn it into reality? If they were at all close to any of that, surely their internal AI can figure out how to self-finance the company asap. Or maybe that's exactly what it did and it told it to go public. Company selling shovels adage.

I think markets are way more complicated and capturing them isn't going to happen the way you're suggesting: dollars, and the public, don't really like copypcats. You would need to understand the business, the product, and manipulate people at an unprecedented level. Anthropic selling tokens as their business, means that all the way up to this "super intelligence", means that they've enabled everyone's defenses and raised the threshold for this dystopian hostile taker, i.e., it won't happen.