Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Turns out...in an economy hollowed out by 15 years of governments inflating asset values via money printing, 0% rates, QE & deficit spending; selling to consumers instead of asset holders (businesses) is a losing strategy.

Anthropic picked the better market at least for the short term. Long term I wouldn't count OpenAI out just yet. The consumer market tends to compound into winner take all eventually given the network effects of advertising marketplaces, even more so than B2B.

If that's true then wouldn't Google will eventually beat both of them?
Yes I think Google will outlast them both because they can just put their product into everything people use and cut the other guys out.
Google is running on search Ads revenue, it will collapse if that stream collapses, because company is too overloaded by bloat (200k employees vs 5k in Anthropic).
I'm convinced Google is a much better investment and would like to hear an opposite argument if anyone here has one.

I don't think there is a lot of difference between the "sota" models long term. Even if we said that say Anthropic is ahead, Google will be able to do the same in months.

But if it turns out that open weight models are the future, OAI and ANT are fucked, but Google has massive infra to host those and make money anyway. It also has the products and business connections to integrate AI into users workflows. And lets not forget, it earns massive amounts of money even without AI, so there is a higher price floor even if an AI bubble pops.

And even if it turns out that Anthropic takes over the world, Google still has a stake in them. (Although so will everyone else though SP500 by that point.)

I don't understand why would you invest in Anthropic IPO instead of GOOG, but as I said, would be interested to hear opposing thoughts.

I guess the opposite argument would be that AI success will undercut their search offering.
Sure, but in that case the Gemini arm of the business (or whatever they rename it to the next time) carries the torch forward. Unless there is no money to be made in AI and everyone loses, but then again it would still be better than investing in Anthropic.
> Sure, but in that case the Gemini arm of the business (or whatever they rename it to the next time) carries the torch forward. Unless there is no money to be made in AI

the question is if its enough money to replace 300B of Ads revenue.

If it isn't, are they in worse position than Anthropic?
Biggest Anthropic risk is that they have those many B hardware commitment.

Otherwise, they have some solid foundation model, which is cheap to post-train and improve, solid market share, they can milk this part for some time and be on the top.

Google is extremely vulnerable against paradigm shift if they lose Search Ads revenue, they have too much bloat of unnecessary people and systems complexity, and easily can collapse.

> I'm convinced Google is a much better investment and would like to hear an opposite argument if anyone here has one.

I have an argument, but it's mostly snark.

Like, Google are definitely in the best position here, but they've messed up so many times when it comes to product management/enterprise adoption that I am confident in their ability to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

> Like, Google are definitely in the best position here, but they've messed up so many times when it comes to product management/enterprise adoption that I am confident in their ability to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

Yeah, but what about Microsoft? They're the real threat here: they can get or train an open-weight model, embed it into Windows at very little cost to the end-user, and then the end-user will have AI in every app that they run, regardless of whether that app has AI connectors already or not.

The entity holding the business relationship already has the most clout, and while Claude takeup was good, it has nowhere near the same numbers as Google enterprise, which in turn is nowhere near Microsoft.

In terms of market-cap, these are all trillion dollar companies. In terms of enterprise agreements, if you were to draw a line-chart for enterprise volume for each of those three companies, MS would be the very top of that chart while Google would be somewhere at the bottom. Anthropic wouldn't even show up; their line would be fractions of a pixel tall, at its peak.

I 100% agree with that snark and think Google could be so much better were it not for internal politics, perverse incentives and inability to focus and follow through with products.

Still that being said, I bet on them rather than against them.

We spend 30k a month on Google services and just suffered an 18 hour outage for what our rep said to be an abuse "false positive".

So no. We will be leaving Google, and Google will not catch up.

While I sympathize with what happened to you, the argument "X happened to us therefore we will leave Google and Google will stay behind" is hardly sound. I haven't seen much better support from Anthropic or OpenAI.
The problem is Google has been famous for this for most of their services and this is their reputation. Many people have sworn they won't depend on GCP or other things.
loading story #50557348
Google treats both its enterprise customers and retail customers with equal contempt.
You also need to have a working product. Google seems to do anything except creating one.
Heavy AI usage seems to be starting with work. And my usage of Claude for work has had two effects.

1. I use Claude for personal

2. I recommend Claude to others who are slower adopters

I’m not sure how your post relates to the comment your replying to?
loading story #50556984
> Anthropic picked the better market at least for the short term.

What market is that? How is it distinguished from OpenAI or any other LLM company?

I think the implication was Anthropic has gone after the B2B market (with Claude Code and Cowork), where as OpenAI has gone after the consumer market (with ChatGPT). I'm not sure I totally agree to be honest; Claude Code was a happy (and fantastic) accident if the stories are to be believed.
loading story #50558944
Anthropic is much more focused on B2B while OpenAI feels more B2C. Both sell to both markets, but the focus feels different and I believe the resulting customer base is quite different.
Capital is more worthless than ever and the society is relatively poorest at the same time. Interesting times.