Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
It doesn't say much about the company itself, but about the state of the economy, where all the money has been concentrated at the top, in the hands of people who have nothing else to spend it on than on more financial assets. So there's enormous amounts of money available for more stocks.

It's why stock markets and corporate profits are at an all time high, while most people struggle to make ends meet and governments are woefully underfunded.

That $1.5 trillion IPO is the result of a completely lopsided economy.

The K shaped economy trope is directionally correct, but you have the cause backwards.

It's not that governments are underfunded, the K economy is a direct byproduct of government stimulus across all developed economies for the last 15 years.

When you inject the market with QE, the money printer and most importantly; 0% or negative interest rates for 15 years...it massively inflates the value of assets. Rich people own assets.

This is why things in the US with the prospect of generating future cash flows are at historically high valuations relative to GDP: public companies, private companies, real estate, etc.

If you think government is 'underfunded' and the solution is giving it more money to dump into the economy, ironically, you're going to inflate asset values further and make the K economy worse.

The stimulatory tools that are easiest for government to use are monetary policy, not fiscal policy.

But let's say you do manage to pass populist fiscal policy, like, giving first time home buyers $20k to help with a downpayment on a house.

Surprise! Turns out you've simply raised the value of all starter homes by $20K by increasing everyones capacity to pay for a scarce asset, inflating the value of the asset and handing the money to the person selling it.

The solution is to increase the supply of assets (build more real estate and competing businesses), not stimulate demand for existing ones. But that requires a much more rational, long term policy view than dumping blankets of cash on angry populist voters.

You are describing, almost fairly well, issues of accumulated wealth at the top -- particularly the effects of covid handouts[1], where all the money ended up with landlords that were not allowed out to spend it all, significantly increasing inequality and asset prices.

And somehow you try to turn it into an anti-tax argument, when taxing the wealth at the top is the only solution, the way to control the money supply, time machines aside. Give out too much you have to take some back if you don't want to devalue.

1. which is why the stock market and housing market went crazy at that point, not a steady 15 years, $5tn was created

loading story #50559058
It doesn't matter how all of the money ends up at the top. Yes, government handouts to the rich are a big part of the problem, but so are a lack of taxation on the rich and on corporations, a lack of competition, the fact that both corporate profits and inflation are high, and the lack of stimulus for the poor.

You seem to think that the government can only use its money for more stimulus for the rich, but that assumption is itself part of the problem.

If the government gives more money to the rich, whether through tax cuts, subsidies, handouts, or whatever, the "trickle down" lie has always been that that money will eventually help everybody, but that's only the case if that money ends up in the economy, paying wages, etc. But instead, that money is being used to buy up more assets. That doesn't help the economy in any way, it just skews it.

If instead, that money ends up in the pockets of people who need it, they will immediately spend it, buy food, buy other things they need, pay off debt, and all of that money creates demand, pays wages, and grows the economy in a way that helps everybody, and doesn't just inflate the numbers.

Alternatively you could massively tax the wealth of the very rich and revert the concentration. Then you are not competing with them for the scarce assets.
loading story #50559015
loading story #50558835
Further its because income generated by assets are tax-efficient in the western world (well at least North America) in a way that non-asset generated income (i.e labour income) is not. Naturally the inclination is to not just accumulate assets for their own worth but for more tax efficient income as well.

If asset-based income was taxed similarly or included in the tax base, you wouldn't have stimulus become inflationary in the way it is today.

> "The solution is to increase the supply of assets..."

Let's be concrete (and unpopular): If one of the few assets left to buy for billionaires is land, which creates competition among them for land not to live on but to HOLD and rent out, the solution is not to "increase the supply of land", it's to decrease the amount of billionaires...

loading story #50558790
> It doesn't say much about the company itself, but about the state of the economy, where all the money has been concentrated at the top, in the hands of people who have nothing else to spend it on than on more financial assets.

Huh, what?

> So there's enormous amounts of money available for more stocks.

Money (nor stocks) don't have to change hands for stocks to become more valuable. All that's required is that the likes of Citadel and Jane Street quote higher prices, no trading necessary. (Of course, they can and will only quote higher prices, if that's justified by supply and demand.)

> It's why stock markets and corporate profits are at an all time high, while most people struggle to make ends meet and governments are woefully underfunded.

Government expenditures have grown like crazy in much of the world, haven't they?

That's not how supply and demand works. There has to be trade in order to establish a price.

And governments in much of the world have actually been cutting expenditures, leading to serious shortages in many places. Increased poverty, reduced quality of education, crumbling infrastructure. Governments were better at this from the post-war period to roughly the 1990s, until neoliberalism and austerity became the law of the land.

loading story #50562763
Would upvote twice if I could.

Another channel for the wealthy to place the money they don't know where to spend anymore. And the audience applauds

Also, it's a valuation for selling to asset holders, no such profit has been achieved yet with the actual portfolio.

It's like an IPO for a beloved artist who claims he will sell a painting to every household in the world.

> "It's like an IPO for a beloved artist who claims he will sell a painting to every household in the world."

So not that far away from the usual "let's all buy from this artist and push his works to a billion dollar" scheme the wealthy usually follow.

But now with tech...

loading story #50557984
Who knew that having wealth accumulate instead of flow would be bad for an economy that relies on the allocation of capital? Every economist ever.

Billionaires are the economic equivalent of a tumor. I don't know why we're so obsessed with perpetuating them.

loading story #50558724
loading story #50559216
loading story #50561845
Because billionaires and those right below them spend a ton of capital on perpetuating the idea that the average person can be like them. Hell they even have their own podcasts now lol
loading story #50558316
It's an absolute state when hackernews from all places has degenerated into braindead leftist "economics" echo-chamber.
I love how the exact same people I describe above (normal people who've be brainwashed to think they can achieve the same level of success that only ~3k billionaires have had), have also been programmed to automatically dismiss anybody that writes a sentence that uses the word billionaire negatively, as "braindead" leftist economics.

They have brainwashed you to the extent that you spend your time reflexively defending them in the comments of online spaces. You become an activated foot soldier, coming to the defense for the very people who seek to enslave you the second anyone says something bad about them.

You proved my point.

Nope, I just understand basic economics and have logical deduction skills instead of buying sentimental bullcrap from demagogues. Please read a book, you will be doing all of us a favour.
What book do you think would change my mind?
For your level even basic economics books from any 101 course in a university (google away) would help you a lot.
I took many economics classes, its partially why I have informed opinions on the matter. You're so confident reading a book would change my mind, surely you have a reccomendation.. Or are you just politicing? Maybe lay off the X algo.
I don't have an X, never did. Was it a Learing Center you got your economics classes from?
loading story #50559214
The K shaped economy is developing serifs.
It's K shaped economy with the upper arm extended with additional /
We're going to need an additional Unicode character for that.
Well, yes. But also the company is projecting to sell pretty much every white collar worker a $200/mo Claude subscription, which is an absurd amount of revenue compared to said Apple, which promises to sell a new phone to 20% of people every few years.
But will it be Claude? Probably it goes through Microsoft through copilot. In which case it becomes a race to the bottom. I never need Fable even today: Opus suffices on 99%. So why do I need anthropic? Opus will be replicated in half a year by every lab.

In that sense I am super bullish on Microsoft as they have the vendor lock.

For anyone who has used the various tools, the harness still matters and copilot is pretty bad. While Anthropics models lose on cost compared to OpenAI, there is still something that works really well in Opus paired with the Claude desktop app when it comes to tool use and solving tasks.
I see what youre saying, but there is no way a TUI or GUI is anthropics 1.5T moat
Why are you pivoting the argument? You said why use Anthropic because copilot can use the models. For anyone who has used copilot and Claude, they are worlds apart and MSFT has been working on copilot for more than a year and they are light years behind and are not answering simple business use cases. I am not here defending the value of their moat but simply the harness still matters.
"compared to said Apple, which promises to sell a new phone to 20% of people every few years."

- around 50% in the US market

- they offer way more products, than phones, are the leader with laptops for instance

- take a big cut of every store purchase

The US is just ~350 million out of the ~8000 million people on the planet.
It's hard to put a percentage on it, but I'd wager for 90% of the earth's population, paying $200 a month for a personal LLM subscription isn't viable or simply not worth it.
When something like 60% of the world’s population lives on less than $200 a month, it’s a preposterous suggestion.
What % of those 8B people can afford an iPhone? How many of those people are located in the US?
Uh, yeah of course a person is super rich for having $1000 or $100 invested in the stock market.

No, of course a person is not super rich for owning their own home which is worth hundreds of thousands.

God damned young yuppies with their stock portfolios worth $20 000 or more! In the meanwhile grandpa is suffering in his house which is only worth $1,3 million.

If only we could take the money out of investment into businesses and put them into investing in real estate! That's where all the jobs are made who pays people's salaries. Can somebody call the EU to have them regulate?