Anthropic and OpenAI are the AltaVista of the AI era. With first starter advantage but no real moat and very good at spending money.
I am still waiting for the Google of this era to show its face.
Edit: every time I question these crazy valuations I get down voted really quickly.
Compaq sold "83% of its AltaVista Internet search engine to CMGI Inc" for $2.3bn [1]. Four months later, ahead of its planned IPO, it disclosed $54mm in revenues [2]. 43x.
Pets.com IPO'd with $5.2mm of sales [3] and a $290mm valuation [4]. 56x.
Anthropic is going public at 40x trailing revenue (AltaVista territory) and 22x Q3 annualized revenue (not comparable).
> every time I question these crazy valuations I get down voted really quickly
You're the top comment. And this is against the guidelines: "Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading" [5].
[1] https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1999-jun-30-fi-51508...
[2] https://www.cnet.com/tech/services-and-software/altavista-fi...
[3] https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/pets-com-raises-82-5...
[4] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1100683/0000891618-0...
Pets.com was 15 months old at IPO, shutdown 9 months later
AltaVista was around 4yrs old when aquired and then CMGI IPO delayed and canceled
eToys.com was 18 months old, bankrupt 2yrs after IPO
Webvan was 3 years old, bankrupt 2yrs after IPO
Anthropic is about 6 years old
OpenAI is about 11 years old
But maybe the comparison assumes we have learned something from dotcom bubble . . . and the bubble will not be as big this time.
What is biggest reasonable bubble right now? Yea, Musk companies, the prime example of not-bubble. Anything else?
Maybe this is the new dotcom bubble, just better than the last time, because we are not that stupid.
What's your reasoning for why these two are AltaVista and not Google [of the AI era]? How would you differentiate without hindsight?
I was there. Google had a better product, and then - some time later, mind - they discovered that ads work really well for them.
OpenAI and Anthropic have a good product and they (especially Anthropic) are increasingly good at generating revenue from it.
What's missing, in your opinion?
Me too.
> Google had a better product, and then - some time later, mind - they discovered that ads work really well for them.
> OpenAI and Anthropic have a good product and they (especially Anthropic) are increasingly good at generating revenue from it.
> What's missing, in your opinion?
Google had a product that was miles better. If you were using Altavista or Yahoo to find something, chances were you'd never find it even though it existed. With google, you almost certainly found it, sometimes even on the first go ("I'm feeling lucky").
Altavista and Yahoo tried to curate the web for users. The wanted to be the internet for users, they had guardrails! (Sound familiar?)
Google went in the opposite direction - they tried to get you what you wanted and ignored things like guardrails (Still sounding familiar to me).
I see the analogy, with ANT and OAI wanting to curate the AI experience for users, and preventing their users from doing anything that goes against the companies' opinions. The open-weight models are roughly similar to year-1 Google: curate nothing, don't get involved, and don't push your opinion on your users.
Maybe ANT and AOI will change their tune before either of them manage to lock up AI into a monopoly, but I doubt it. They aspire to be like Google: get the monopoly and then abuse the fuck out of your users for profit. Then abuse the fuck out of your paying customers for profit.
It's entirely speculative.
I'm not saying it's bad just people have valid reasons to be skeptical.
But yes your point on 2026 revenue is a valid one, although the forward looking trend changes quite dramatically looking at their monthly ARR that they've been reporting.
And then the revenue multiple starts to look a little bit insane.
Anthropic already turned an operating profit in Q2 2026, and it has the potential to be insanely profitable in the coming years. Calling it "entirely speculative" just isn't accurate.
Yes Q2 operating profit is great, but you cannot ignore speculative capital expenditure which is significantly larger than you'd traditionally expect even for growth stocks.
don't forget it was text ads too. Prior to that all ads were "punch the monkey" giant banners, images, and flashing text. Google put unobtrusive text ads on the right hand side of the search results page and users didn't mind. IMO that was the breakthrough that turned on the money hose, Google found a way to get ads in front of users in a least annoying way.
The same day I got an offer to work at Genentech in their IT support and chose that as it was a real job at a real company.
2 years later I had to move on because corporate politics suck and my friend was now working at Google via the acquisition. He's been retired for many years and I'm still grinding away. At least I get to grind...
> OpenAI and Anthropic have a good product
> What's missing, in your opinion?
I love that the answer is in your writeup.
As others have mentioned, it's hard to see how Ant and Oai are much better than the competition.
Also, it steals IP.
to really extracting more money, they have to be good at creating drugs and weapons, and monopoly the way of doing it. ant founders understand it, I think it won't take them too long to get there.
The newer Chinese models get somewhat close, but OpenAI & Claude got better at stopping them from copying the model so the Chinese models will not make such big jumps anymore. And most Western companies will not use Chinese models if they are not open weight.
If they keep going like this huge parts knowledge work sector (legal, marketing, software, ads, health) economy is AI driven in 2-4 years and OpenAI & Claude will own it. Another huge shift of wealth from the Western World to Silicon Valey.
Things have gone very very fast. Two years ago, you couldn't reliably have AI write you a medium sized code project. It would spin in circles and apologize. Now, an old model can write it with only a little direction, and the programmer can have a reasonable preference against the newer model.
It seems to me open-weight models will put a floor on the pricing. They're slightly behind, but slightly behind last year meant nothing worked, now it means "just as good".
Many of my coworkers liked Opus 4.8, it was the moment they could actually use the models more reliably.
We're there, and moving forward doesn't really get us anything better. Most people are using them to format documents, spit out spreadsheets, pul together data points, and ask the models search questions.
We can already do that, it's only a matter of time before we realize we're paying 200/Mo for Jane in accounting to handle some of her work, when 5$ / Month would render the same benefit.
MOST people simply do not need frontier level intelligence.
Maybe bigger models will always just get progressively better at writing out bigger and bigger programs to the point that we're one-shotting fully functioning operating systems with wide driver support in the future, but again these features just don't matter if that's not what you want to do.
ceiling
But "they" here is Anthropic and OAI together, and you probably need to add Google onto that list too, now that they appear to have got themselves back on track.
If it was just Anthropic, sure, this would be valid. But with 2-3 companies, we've got constant price competition bringing token costs down (as we are currently seeing) and no guarantee that Anthropic will ever come out with a clear advantage. If it's a three-way split, then that list price seems hard to justify.
And this is all assuming that the Chinese models don't work out how to get back to near-parity, which is also a massive gamble.
What they have right now is enough money to to work through that. But they don't have enough revenue to keep this up forever and they can't stop either.
Claude is a known brand and installed product for a decent fraction of the economy. To avoid churn, Anthropic doesn't need to stay way ahead of everyone else. They just can't fall behind. The latter is much easier than the former.
Note: I don't have a strong view on this IPO. Don't trade on it based on my comments.
Google and Microsoft just released competitive models within the last month. Opus 4.8 was just released in May, and there’s probably 4+ non-Open AI/Anthropic models that have overtaken it. You can’t build a moat around a six month technical lead.
I have my own little app / ui that I work with and have all models, also round robin to test models, but GLM and Qwen just make weird mistakes & misunderstand the repo like Opus did last year when it first came out.
Where Fable 5.2 and Opus 5.5 are just always spot on. I dont need context, I write garbled prompts and it just gets me always. And it knows better and better, where it should push back & go into more detail and when it should just only do what I ask.
If Open weight models can reach Opus 5.5 level of consistency, I agree with you. If they can't I don't.
Yep. Actually, I do most of my coding work with GPT Luna. It's cheap and good enough.
because remember good enough is better than "better".
my take Microsoft will be the bigger win, followed by Palantir due to Microsoft understanding how businesses small, medium & large enterprises use software. Microsoft now has its own dedicated FDE org - & for "a.i" to pay off you need a lot of FDEs - since the gains are all on the application layer. the models have become largely undifferentiated
so whether microsoft uses their own models or openai's - if their own models are good enough it doesn't matter they suck by a few percentage points against the frontier they will win.
For many use case the models that already exist are more than good enough, if not entirely overkill to be replaced by cheaper alternatives like Jev.
The companies that win are those that workout what keeps users/orgs that spend money and want to keep spending (or integrate so it is hard to get out)
Exactly. If you haven't embedded AI in your workflows yet then it's just a matter of time or you're going to crash hard.
It's clear that it can do the work of several people, faster, cheaper and better and that will never not be the case.
They could triple the price (please don't) and I wouldn't flinch.
> They could triple the price ... and I wouldn't flinch.
> (please don't)
If you wouldn't flinch, why do you care if they take more of the froth? It's all worth it to you at 3x what it currently is, why object that they take what the market will bear?
I missed that, do you mind giving more details about how it is harder now for Chinese model? What was put in place but more importantly which proof we have it actually is effective?
Cheaper open weight models have a potential to undercut them especially when people realise what they can do with these models
This leaves OpenAI and Anthropic to always be chasing the frontier which is going to be increasingly expensive and they’ll never get to stop
A "huge moat" is not being incrementally better than one's current competition, not in tech. Anthropic's moat could be eliminated by one great model from any number of competitors, which means it isn't much of a moat. A proper "huge moat" would be a bundle of patents meaning nobody else was allowed to compete (apple/android) or a decades-old network to lock in users (windows). Anthropic has fanboys but most users would drop it in a hot second if a slightly better model appeared at a similar price.
Not really though... OpenAI and Claude will own the US economy in less than 5 years is crazy talk.
On the one hand this will help the ai companies reduce their tech spending but on the other hand smaller specific models is all the customers need.
It was enough months that per Portuguese labour law, I was able to leave the company without notice.
VA Linux Systems went public on December 9, 1999, under the ticker LNUX, pricing at $30 per share and surging roughly 700% on its first day of Nasdaq trading.
They were fine machines but they were just another PC builder and got their stock fell way down and turned into Sourceforge and then got bought by Gamestop.
Racing toward an IPO is more likely an indication of a liquidity crisis than about having superior product, prospects and roadmap. If things are going so well, why would you bring this amount of disruption to the company?
And in the end he will almost certainly be richer than Sam because he was out first.
In my opinion I think Google and/or Microsoft with Amazon and X to a lesser extent will be winners of the AI race.
All except Amazon have enterprise money flowing in.
Google owns the search and is the default landing to look for information.
Microsoft gives away Copilot with its already embedded Office suite.
Google and X own and collect their data and lease it out to the pure AI only models like OpenAi and Anthropic.
Plus money, all of these companies have alternative money streams to keep a money losing technology like AI going.
I'd personally neither bet on or bet against Anthropic or OpenAI, as they both have the potential to be the next Amazon or the next AltaVista.
Honestly, I think there's no realistic chance that they'll be the next AltaVista. What I can't discount is the chance that they'll be the next Shockley or Fairchild, with their best and brightest moving on to make a lasting impact on the industry elsewhere.
Do you remember canals? Do you remember steam engines? Railroads? Bicycles? Electricity? Telephones?
This has been going on for centuries:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_Revolutions_and_...
Airlines are a particularly interesting case since they enable so much economic value, but capture very little of it for themselves. On the AI side, the lack of moats and open models feels like this is the direction we may be trending as things settle out.
It already is changing the world quite a bit, just not for the net better.
It’s not that you questioned the valuations, it’s that your comparison doesn’t make sense. Google won because it built a better product, not because of a fundamental difference in search or business concept. There was no real moat until they acquired DoubleClick, long after they beat out AltaVista.
It's a bit more nuanced: Google won because it was printing cash from day one, and the amount of cash they were printing kept increasing at a phenomenal pace. Neither OpenAI nor Anthropic are like that.
At this point, it's like saying that Microsoft has no moat because anyone can write an OS or a word processor. The moat is the friction of switching to a different platform. That alone won't guarantee success in the long term, but they won't be going anywhere any time soon. Even WordPerfect managed to stick around a for a few years after Office came along.
But I also remember the clear "leaders" at that time: Amazon, eBay, Yahoo!, Cisco, Akamai.
The rest felt like coat-tail riders. Obviously, they didn't all deliver stellar returns, but, in aggregate, these 'blue-chip' dot coms did quite well (I'd say 3/5 did well).
I also remember wanting to invest in Amazon, but once they finally went public, I thought, "well, too rich for my blood!"
Anthropic "feels" like one of those.
Mind you, I'm not investing in ANT, except through my mutual funds, but drawing a parallel between Anthropic and pets.com is ridiculous.
edits: You can kind of throw Google in there, too, but they were a little bit later, but it was also clear in the early 2000s that they were a force to be reckoned with.
Google IPO'ed at 7.4x P/S and was already technically profitable. It would be more similar if they initial stock cost the same as in 2012+. Also Google grew by over 100x since then. If Antrhopic grew by 100x it's market cap would be 20% higher than the entire global GDP.
...Amazon was still only selling books in y2k. eBay was still small taters as well. Yahoo! hadn't been bought by Apollo yet so they were still smallish but had a good search engine and sturdy webmail
ecommerce did not take off until after 2009 and certainly got magnitudes bigger over the past 8 years
you probably are being hyperbolic about these choices as leaders back then. Cisco, AKAM: legit and still around. Think also HP/Compaq, Motorola, VZ, Sprint (RIP), ATT. Fiber build out was the infrastructure side. Servers and switching equip as well. Consumers increasingly wanted gaming computers, wherein NVIDIA began as a IDE & PCI video card developer, which eventually became ...well...
i.ytimg.com/vi/ulXPlXXppBc/maxresdefault.jpg
If there is such a durable technical advantage out there, it remains to be seen. Open weight models are catching up to where the frontier models where just six months ago. Contrast that to how shitty Bing search results were compared to Google even years later.
Disagree. Google's search algorithm / variants were available for people to replicate. But there is only 1 google today. There are many office suites but people are still stuck to Microsoft Office -- many such examples.
While Anthropic and OpenAI have no technology moat people will become habituated to their user/api interfaces and rich features (which will take competitors a long slog to build).
None of these apply to LLMs. I do enjoy cheap subscription to use frontier models, but if tomorrow I need to switch to the so-called open models, I won't regret it that much.
Where is the moat?
It's just crazy what is in people's minds.
I believe Google is the Google of this era.
Going back a decade to when the hype around self-driving cars was peaking, you had several investor driven companies like Uber, GM's Cruise, and Uber all behaving like cowboys. They were burning through massive cash piles but under unrealistic amounts of pressure to deliver results to nervous and impatient investors, and so they were heavily incentivized to make it appear as though they were further ahead than they were, they behaved recklessly, and they lost.
Waymo on the other hand was effectively patronized by it's parent. They kept their heads down. They played by the rules. They didn't go out of their way to draw unnecessary scrutiny. Waymo won, it does not have any real domestic competitors. All this serves as a model, or a microcosm of what is happening at a much larger scale with the AI race.
It's tortoise vs. Hare. I'm betting on the tortoise and the tortoise is Google. They don't need to win or get way out in front. They merely need to quietly answer every move their competitors make, which they've so far been doing. And of course, they do not rely on Nvidia for anything.
Likely however I would say only one of these two is the AltaVista of search. The question is which
There is a potentially boring outcome that Google turns out to be the Google of this era.
Could work out with a change in management.
Are you doing that? Do you believe what you're saying strongly enough to put some money on it?
Do you believe this strongly enough to sell everything you have got, take a loan and convert everything into call options?
Do you realize how ridiculous these arguments are?
A useful analogy would be the IPO of the European unicorn World Online in 2000. It was oversubscribed by 20 times, didn't rise on the first day and only fell afterwards.
Later it turned out that insiders like Brink had sold their shares before the IPO. Soon after the bubble burst completely.
Anthropic is only six times oversubscribed. A we see this does not at all mean that the price is going to rise above the IPO price. My guess is that the Anthropic IPO is the new World Online, full of scams and the precursor to the bubble bursting completely (which is why they rushed the IPO).
But alas, no downvotes this time!
On the "echoes of dotcom" I think there is no way that Anthropic is worth $1.5T, same for SpaceX. Same for OpenAI. I agree that there will definitely be a Dotcom sized reckoning.
These Cloud AI are just itching for regulatory capture and I think it's too late, the open weights are catch up faster than they can get regulations to happen.
Whatever bubble pop happens, will be interesting. Dot con caused a lot more people to get jobs.
This was the opposite, so will the burst cause hiring sprees? Or will the burst crumble the economy?
The bubble is similar to dotcom, but the bursting consequence to me seems potentially drastically different fallouts.
Hundreds of outages, many of them critical infrastructure in the past week. Also Nvidia
I can't tell if the game is get the money for share holders and pop. Or, make some announcement about how only anthropic can be trusted and some new bills drop regulating away it's competitors. Either way I think it's bad news for the average person.
I should probably pull my 401k from the market just in case...
No, it doesn't matter that whatever the revenues are. Bubble because pets dot com. That's all the logic.
I don't think these companies are as bad as some dot-com companies, but I personally struggle with coming up with an investment thesis at the current price given it assumes they'll retain pricing power for models. And another problem is that this isn't like Amazon or Facebook where you build a decent product and with a few tweaks every couple of years people will continue to use them for decades – these companies need to develop and release new competitive models every month or two just to retain their market position.
I think the only thesis that makes sense is that the singularity happens, the private companies that owns the models which are produced as a result retain legal ownership of them, and that humans retain control over the models. In my mind I'd give this outcome a sub 1% probability.
AMA!
You've gotta understand there's a lot of people on HN with their wealth tied to the success of AI at this point. Every downvote on a post like this is just a lowly engineer that wants to keep having steak dinners.
This is a problem of hackernews. I also made critical comments in another thread and got insta-downvoted. This may even come from bots, it is quite strange. That has not happened on old.reddit.com, for instance. Something is not working well on hackernews in general here. See also the speed limitation, after 5 comments I can not comment for some hours. That's just tedious ...
They do have moat. Every single company is pushing their private data into these models. Do you really believe that data isn't making into the training data one way or another?
To be clear, I'm not bullish on the AI companies themselves. I think Chinese companies will continue to distill these models and once they achieve RSI (which is imminent), intelligence will be abundant and cheap. The real profit will be in the other layers of the AI ecosystem: electricity generation, chip fabrication (memory, storage, CPU/GPU), infrastructure (datacentres), and probably most notably, the people and companies which produce compelling software and services using this technology.
Also, please ask Anthropic why their sec-1 filling is missing financial data after that quarter they made "profit". Most analysts belive that their profit was financial juggling and things went downhill really quickly after June.
So is Anthropic at their current valuation; they are gambling that they will become a multi trillion dollar company soon. That is speculation, as they are not profitable yet and everyone just hope that they will succeed.
Profit statement would sound nicer. But ofc, "Amazon was unprofitable when it IPOd too" and $28M losses on IPO year is comparable (not) after you adjust from inflation.
Imminent according to which sources which are not financially involved with AI companies?
Nuclear fusion is also imminent.