Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
What do we think the stable state market cap for anthropic is? $200B? 2T? I struggle to believe this is worth like 5% of total US GDP.
comparing a stock (ANT) to a flow (GDP) is a common finance mistake. You shouldn't compare a stock to a flow, they are measuring different things. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stock_and_flow
> However, one may meaningfully take ratios of stocks and flows, or multiply or divide them.

Right out of the section comparing stocks and flows

The OP was clearly comparing the GDP of the US to the market cap of ANT rather than taking a ratio for comparison to other ratios.
Literally Buffet did this, are you a better investor?
I increasingly see this style of responding more and more and wow, it's like it's meant to be as triggering as possible. I'd call it fallacymaxxing.
Interesting, do you mean the parent or my reply?

My reply wasn’t meant to be triggering, more than I don’t see how Buffet doing this consistently, it being a major idea of his, can be the case without their statement being wrong.

Or do you mean them? Sorry, I sometimes find it hard to figure out such things.

(Esp as my comment was downvoted)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffett_indicator

You missed the point entirely. You could have responded LIKE YOU DID NOW but instead went with reductio ad absurdum combined with an arrogant straw man. Hence the downvoting. If you meant to sound sarcastic, it didn't. It sounded like how people discuss politics nowadays, trying to Kafka-trap one other as if cornering someone to the point they find it difficult to respond actually wins the argument, not the merit itself.
SpaceX is still >1T and close to 2T.

Valuations are completely detached from reality, it's pointless to try to make sense of them.

At least SpaceX has something nobody have been able to copy yet for a decade. So it makes sense, they have a moat.
loading story #50559310
loading story #50557712
>I struggle to believe this is worth like 5% of total US GDP.

Actual question: Why? America is mostly a service-based economy, and a lot of service-based jobs seem extremely vulnerable to automation. Do you think that the possibility of massive AI job displacement is overrated, or do you think that competition between AI companies will stop Anthropic from capturing that much of the market share?

Competition. For any service-based jobs, service automated -> service become commodity -> competition on price -> Anthropic cannot capture margin.
They either get RSI and take over the economy (in which case their shares are almost certainly worth nothing) or they don't and their shares go to ~0.

Their 'traditional business' path makes no sense:

1) they can never stop training or they'll be selling a commoditised (or just worse) product, so it looks very difficult to ever turn any kind of profit.

2) they don't have huge consumer awareness penetration and big business already trusts Microsoft, Google, Amazon way more so in a commodity world the big players win.

If revenue grows faster than training costs they’ll be able to amortize training eventually.

The real money here is in b2b. Consumers don’t pay for digital products. Even the software companies whose products are consumer facing mostly make their money by selling ads which is a b2b business.

Their run rate is $85B and they've been growing 1000% year-over-year so even $200B is pretty unlikely. It depends on if you trust their profitability.

What do you think of Apple at $5T, Google and Nvidia at $3.5T, SpaceX at $2T, or Meta at $1.5T?

They have 18B fully diluted shares. That's about $5/share revenue, and the ipo price per share is $83. The math implies a P/S of 17.5. SpaceX is 60, Palantir is 55, Cloudflare is 40, and Snowflake is 18.

The law of large numbers aside, and ignoring the insanity of the rest of the market when using valuation by comparables, the numbers aren't absurd.

Edited post. 200M was a typo brain still cannot fathom the scale of these numbers.
{"deleted":true,"id":50555858,"parent":50555820,"time":1795060264,"type":"comment"}
Referring to the company that is projecting around 0.3% of US GDP in annualized revenue by the end of this year, having started at 0.02% at the beginning of 2026? That seems pretty reasonable factoring in that revenue growth rate.

Adding in that only a quarter of US businesses are using AI right now, that the company has set its sights on fundamental biology research and robotics, the company seems undervalued relative to the upside case.