Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> Anthropic and OpenAI are the AltaVista of the AI era. I am still waiting for the Google of this era to show its face.

What's your reasoning for why these two are AltaVista and not Google [of the AI era]? How would you differentiate without hindsight?

I was there. Google had a better product, and then - some time later, mind - they discovered that ads work really well for them.

OpenAI and Anthropic have a good product and they (especially Anthropic) are increasingly good at generating revenue from it.

What's missing, in your opinion?

Google IPOed after the custom from dot.com had mostly settled. At a massively more reasonable valuation as well. Antrophic is priced as if its guaranteed to grow at considerable rate and massively improve it's profitability in the near future. So it's not obvious there is much value remaining if you buy at the IPO price (Google was complete opposite in that sense)
Why is IPOing at a lower price better for the company? They could have fleeced a bunch of initial investors at the height of the bubble and had a huge mountain of cash to weather the downturn. Isn't that better?
loading story #50571707
> I was there.

Me too.

> Google had a better product, and then - some time later, mind - they discovered that ads work really well for them.

> OpenAI and Anthropic have a good product and they (especially Anthropic) are increasingly good at generating revenue from it.

> What's missing, in your opinion?

Google had a product that was miles better. If you were using Altavista or Yahoo to find something, chances were you'd never find it even though it existed. With google, you almost certainly found it, sometimes even on the first go ("I'm feeling lucky").

Altavista and Yahoo tried to curate the web for users. The wanted to be the internet for users, they had guardrails! (Sound familiar?)

Google went in the opposite direction - they tried to get you what you wanted and ignored things like guardrails (Still sounding familiar to me).

I see the analogy, with ANT and OAI wanting to curate the AI experience for users, and preventing their users from doing anything that goes against the companies' opinions. The open-weight models are roughly similar to year-1 Google: curate nothing, don't get involved, and don't push your opinion on your users.

Maybe ANT and AOI will change their tune before either of them manage to lock up AI into a monopoly, but I doubt it. They aspire to be like Google: get the monopoly and then abuse the fuck out of your users for profit. Then abuse the fuck out of your paying customers for profit.

I just had a weird epiphany: The world where Google was born was much more technology-clueless. In theory ~anybody could have copied what Google did, the research was public (I know about the patent, but still). The reason nobody did was that they didn't see the market value. With AI, everybody sees the value.
Anthropics last year's revenue $4 billion revenue and $42billion net loss.

It's entirely speculative.

I'm not saying it's bad just people have valid reasons to be skeptical.

These are 2025 numbers, which doesn’t take into account the ridiculous growth in revenue this year. Their net loss in 2026 was around 100B but subtract 80B from that because of the convertible notes “loss” (gaap accounting says that bc they sold shares to Google et. al. via convertible notes, and bc they rose in value, that counts as a loss to the books, even though it’s not actually money out of their accounts), and the fact they posted a 900M operating profit (!!) in q2 this year, and these numbers seem pretty reasonable? I mean why base your viewpoint on 2025 numbers when everything changed in 2026?
loading story #50565651
loading story #50562248
Their actual operating loss was ~$8B on $4.6B in revenue. Being skeptical of the valuation is totally fair, but throwing around the $42B/$102B headline figure without understanding the convertible debt accounting is disingenuous. It's the same story in 2026: ~90% ($94B) of their $104B nine-month net loss came from convertible financing charges, while revenue jumped to $33.2B.

Anthropic already turned an operating profit in Q2 2026, and it has the potential to be insanely profitable in the coming years. Calling it "entirely speculative" just isn't accurate.

loading story #50559530
loading story #50560254
having a claude sub is like having netflix today, everyone and their aunts have a pro plan at least
loading story #50562744
loading story #50562367
> Google had a better product, and then - some time later, mind - they discovered that ads work really well for them.

don't forget it was text ads too. Prior to that all ads were "punch the monkey" giant banners, images, and flashing text. Google put unobtrusive text ads on the right hand side of the search results page and users didn't mind. IMO that was the breakthrough that turned on the money hose, Google found a way to get ads in front of users in a least annoying way.

I was laid off for a horribly long time and was finally contacted by a friend at DoubleClick to come work for them -- at the time all those horrible ads you mentioned were their bread and butter and I wanted no part of it.

The same day I got an offer to work at Genentech in their IT support and chose that as it was a real job at a real company.

2 years later I had to move on because corporate politics suck and my friend was now working at Google via the acquisition. He's been retired for many years and I'm still grinding away. At least I get to grind...

> Google had a better product

> OpenAI and Anthropic have a good product

> What's missing, in your opinion?

I love that the answer is in your writeup.

As others have mentioned, it's hard to see how Ant and Oai are much better than the competition.

Because Google was clearly a growth stock. Anthropic has one product in a saturated market and is priced so high that only early investors can profit.

Also, it steals IP.

ai it self is like search, good digital tool empowering bullshit jobs.

to really extracting more money, they have to be good at creating drugs and weapons, and monopoly the way of doing it. ant founders understand it, I think it won't take them too long to get there.