Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Alternatively you could massively tax the wealth of the very rich and revert the concentration. Then you are not competing with them for the scarce assets.
You could take every dollar of wealth Elon has and give every American $2,500. Is that really going to help?

More importantly, taxing the rich based on unrealized wealth means forcing them to sell their assets. Markets would be flooded with new supply and no buyers, tanking prices and putting everything in a much worse position.

The issue with accepting this status quo of tax policy is that it isn't the same in other countries. The US (uniquely?) does not tax asset wealth when it is distributed which allows for huge accumulation of wealth outside of the tax base, Canada has deemed disposition for example that brings any asset that is distributed from one individual to another into the tax base even if the asset remains the same asset (unsold stock that ahs appreciated).

You can tax "unrealized" wealth when that wealth is used to actually fund expenditure, currently anytime this wealth exchanges hands as the same asset it is seen not as a realization of wealth, which is what needs to be changed.

I'm very much in favor of closing a loophole that allows the wealthy to borrow against their assets and have tax-free income.

I'm very much opposed to a wealth tax that forces a person to have to pay for gains they never realized even if that means having to sell the very asset in question.

I personally don't actually agree with income tax at all, but if we have it then it should standard across the board without said loophole and acting as a tax on income, not paper wealth that can't be spent.

Wait, how would lower prices be bad? Isn't that exactly what we want?
People want groceries and house prices to come down yes, unless you already own a home. People don't want prices to collapse though, and more importantly our government doesn't want prices to come down.

Deflation is a death spiral for debt markets. Our economy is so precariously balanced on top of debts and derivatives that the whole thing would crumble if prices of major asset classes collapse.

I own a home and I'm totally fine with house prices coming down. I don't have my house as an investment, but to have a roof over my head.

> Deflation is a death spiral for debt markets.

People say that a lot, but is it actually true? Are there real life examples of this happening? By far the biggest example of prices coming down over a long period, has been computer components, and that never hurt those markets. It's only the recent rising prices that's killing markets.

loading story #50561657
loading story #50561355
loading story #50561446
Again, giving government more money to dump into the economy will do literally nothing to solve the problem.

You will simply be taking money from the rich, and then giving it right back to them by inflating asset values.

Because the assets are the things that are scarce and valuable, and you're now disincentivizing the creation of them while stimulating demand for them more by dumping cash on everyone.

There is only one path: creating more valuable things (more supply of real estate and businesses offering competing products lowers their price). China, ironically a 'communist' country, figured this out yet we're still struggling to.

The truth is we don't want to face this reality. We'd rather sit at computers, place fantasy expectations on the politician du jour to save us, and repeat smart sounding memes we don't understand for magical internet upvotes ('late stage capitalism' 'K shaped economy') instead of picking up a hammer and building anything.

There is no scarcity of shares. They're entirely artificial. Their absurdly high valuation is really just because the rich have too much money and nothing else to spend it on. Giving that same money to the poor instead will not inflate those same prices, because the poor will spend it on other things.

And those other things the poor will spend it on are also already inflated because of a lack of competition. Corporate profits are at record level across many industries, despite the fact that 60% of Americans are struggling.

Your scarcity argument only really holds for real estate, but that too is exacerbated by rich people buying real estate just because they can, because they need to put their money somewhere. Meanwhile poor people are struggling to buy their first home. Poor people are not going to buy multiple homes, they really just need the one.

> Again, giving government more money to dump into the economy will do literally nothing to solve the problem.

You’re assuming that taxing the rich would mean giving the government more money, but that doesn’t have to be the case.

You could, for example, raise taxes on the rich to the point where income tax is dropped entirely for the vast majority of people who currently pay it.

You could calculate how much the federal budget would need to fill the gap created if, say, nobody earning under €100k a year had to pay income tax anymore. That sum would then be offset by raising taxes on the richest people. No extra money gets “dumped” into the government. It’s the same amount as before, except a large share of it is effectively handed back to people who earn their income from work.

Why not use the extra taxed income to support "picking up the hammer and build things"? Historically, government have been the one to do that for moonshoty projects, a lot of "things built" to kickstart SV was government spending (as much as modern SV propaganda tries to erase that fact)

Why does your mind equate "taxing wealth to reduce inequality" == dumping that money as hand out to the citizens? Why can't government, that after Thatcher and Reagan threw up their hands saying "we are too dumb to plan anything", just go back to planning long term spending (such as reducing construction regulations or make it more efficient, both requiring capital I assume), which, ironically, is also what you're praising China for.

With respect, it sounds like you're also falling for the criticism you give out to others about "smart sounding memes" ; yours one step further than the one you're criticizing, but stops at the step where more tax== hand outs meme

> Why not use the extra taxed income to support "picking up the hammer and build things"?

That would be the ideal scenario, but it just doesn't work reliably in a decentralized system, which I think we can all agree is better than a centralized one (I'll take messy decentralized democracy over brutal authoritarian control every time).

Democratic politicians are just renters. When's the last time you renovated the bathroom during a hotel stay? The one time the US made massive investments in building stuff in the past 100 years was when we had the most dictator-like president (FDR).

But centralized power can just as easily go bad (see the last 2 years) as it can turn out good.

The only solution in a democracy is to let decentralized market forces dictate the price of things, mitigate any anti-competitive flaws (monopolies, cartels, local government vetos against building, etc), and deal with the harshness of reality instead of looking for magic bullets.

The market takes care of itself if left to build unencumbered, just look at the price of housing in Austin and all the new assets being built in AI. The whole pessimist scenario in AI is that competition will cause prices to drop and kill valuations. This is good. Lowering asset prices is what we want!

I think we are broadly in agreement but I can't shake the feeling of "smart sounding meme" feeling from your reply too. Granted it's forum post that is limited form of communication... I probably sound the same.

You give one good(FDR) and one bad (Trump) example why centralization is bad. With your previous example of China and CCP, the tally seems two good example, so as a basis for discarding centralization I feel it's too handwavy.

I rather see the details of how centralization can be implemented.

CCP, for its centralization, have long been factional, localized and meritocratic in certain aspects (you only climb the party ladder if you succeed at local province first), for example.

Another is Japan's centralized zoning law, or centralized train track management, seems to yield better result for affordable building and public transportation: a central/decentral, public/private symbiosis.

I'm in agreement with you that "mitigate anticompetitive flaws" is an direction because it's clear certain domains simply can't be expected to construct competitive markets on its own, or that the markets outcome is beneficial to the society.

"We" is we citizen, government and companies. We can't directly affect the companies (except with our purses but let's be realistic on that), but we can affect our government. That entity completely outsourcing it's power to companies is stupid imo.

Create guardrails so that market competition is aligned to the broader society's wellbeing is a minimum to me, and the interest question is where and how. Being blanket anti tax or anti centralization robs us of being able to discuss that part.

I changed my opinion a little when I got to that discussion, about wealth tax for example (how hard it is and how there are lower hanging fruits such as what Richard Murphy have been claiming: https://youtu.be/Iir0GP40_vw) and it seems like more proactive approach to this discussion

I don't know how centralised you consider the US or western Europe, but they have done exactly this very successfully after WW2. They invested enormously in infrastructure, housing, and economic growth, and it was incredibly successful. It was only after neoliberalism came along that people started to believe this was bad. And that's when the excessive inflation of asset prices and growing inequality started.