Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
I own a home and I'm totally fine with house prices coming down. I don't have my house as an investment, but to have a roof over my head.

> Deflation is a death spiral for debt markets.

People say that a lot, but is it actually true? Are there real life examples of this happening? By far the biggest example of prices coming down over a long period, has been computer components, and that never hurt those markets. It's only the recent rising prices that's killing markets.

>I own a home and I'm totally fine with house prices coming down. I don't have my house as an investment, but to have a roof over my head.

It's an easy counter point to make because you don't have to show anything for it. But when we ask people to put their money where their mouth is, they reliably protect their home values.

To put another way, say you needed to move for whatever reason, and in the new location you found a home you loved for $100k under the value of your current home. Would you sell your current home for $100k less because all you care about is having a roof you like over your head?

Again you can easily say yes to this, but in reality, everyone pockets the $100k.

What do you mean by "the current value of your home"? In the end, that value is whatever the market pays. Whatever it sells for, that is the value.

But my point is: if all house prices are coming down, they're all coming down. The value of your home only really matters in relation to other houses. If all house prices come down, and I move, I get less for my current home, but I also pay less for the next one. If they all go up, same thing. The only situation where the absolute value of my home matters, is after I die and my kids sell it. Or if I were to move abroad or to a rental.

I expect we will be seeing a similar scenario play out with Anthropic's IPO. Its all well and good to call oneself an altruist, but once that check comes in I don't expect them to give it all away.

I will be quite impressed if the EAs at Anthropic do precisely that though.

> People say that a lot, but is it actually true?

Price deflation for any particular product isn't a big deal, the risk is broad deflation across markets and industries.

Our financial system is heavily leveraged, when prices fall leveraged bets begin unwinding as forced sales, pushing the spiral further and further.

You generally don't see price deflation hurt triggering a debt crisis as the starting point, but that's only because our system is structurally designed for persistent price inflation. You do see it in the middle of a crisis though, debt is the dry brush that burns everything down after the fire is lit.

The great Depression was mostly a deflation death cycle. Japan between 1990 and 2010 ish was a less dramatic example.