It's not that governments are underfunded, the K economy is a direct byproduct of government stimulus across all developed economies for the last 15 years.
When you inject the market with QE, the money printer and most importantly; 0% or negative interest rates for 15 years...it massively inflates the value of assets. Rich people own assets.
This is why things in the US with the prospect of generating future cash flows are at historically high valuations relative to GDP: public companies, private companies, real estate, etc.
If you think government is 'underfunded' and the solution is giving it more money to dump into the economy, ironically, you're going to inflate asset values further and make the K economy worse.
The stimulatory tools that are easiest for government to use are monetary policy, not fiscal policy.
But let's say you do manage to pass populist fiscal policy, like, giving first time home buyers $20k to help with a downpayment on a house.
Surprise! Turns out you've simply raised the value of all starter homes by $20K by increasing everyones capacity to pay for a scarce asset, inflating the value of the asset and handing the money to the person selling it.
The solution is to increase the supply of assets (build more real estate and competing businesses), not stimulate demand for existing ones. But that requires a much more rational, long term policy view than dumping blankets of cash on angry populist voters.
And somehow you try to turn it into an anti-tax argument, when taxing the wealth at the top is the only solution, the way to control the money supply, time machines aside. Give out too much you have to take some back if you don't want to devalue.
1. which is why the stock market and housing market went crazy at that point, not a steady 15 years, $5tn was created
This would be true only if the government simply increased taxes on assets (say, doubled capital gains taxes) and then took that money and paid down government debts with it.
However, we all know this won't be the case. The money taken from asset holders will simply be dumped right back into the economy via populist handouts, and that money will ultimately just re-inflate the things that are scarce and valuable (assets).
You're disincentivizing the creation of assets at the individual level (by taking them from people) and stimulating demand for them at the societal level by giving everyone money to chase assets with. A recipe for more runaway prices.
Again, there is only one path: increase the supply of assets (build more real estate and more competing businesses). China has similar/lower tax rates than the US in most areas while their middle class grew massively. This is how. It's not magic.
What's a "populist handout", specifically?
I wouldn't count the endless corporate and agriculture bailouts as populist, personally, but I'm curious if you would. As a salaried middle class American who owns real estate in the range of $500k in assessed value, the only handout I've ever received since becoming an adult half-my-lifetime ago was the Covid stimulus check. Every other "handout" that I've received was a tax break, e.g. the lifting of the SALT deduction limit.
"Populist handouts" (by my definition) are a boogeyman that I've never actually personally experienced in the USA, especially compared to (1) the tax breaks that are handed out left-and-right, (2) corporate and agriculture bailouts, and (3) the military-industrial complex.
My soap box: I think what made the New Deal so aspirational was that, yes, the government was giving people money, but it was also paying them to perform jobs that made the nation a better place to live. We have so much crumbling infrastructure. Instead of handing corporations the money directly, make them bid on infrastructure projects. Then heavily fund a department that roots out fraud and abuse and make it culturally taboo, through legislation, to perform fraud and abuse.
Maybe both sides need to step back.
But if you frame the debate as US-only then I basically agree.
You seem to think that the government can only use its money for more stimulus for the rich, but that assumption is itself part of the problem.
If the government gives more money to the rich, whether through tax cuts, subsidies, handouts, or whatever, the "trickle down" lie has always been that that money will eventually help everybody, but that's only the case if that money ends up in the economy, paying wages, etc. But instead, that money is being used to buy up more assets. That doesn't help the economy in any way, it just skews it.
If instead, that money ends up in the pockets of people who need it, they will immediately spend it, buy food, buy other things they need, pay off debt, and all of that money creates demand, pays wages, and grows the economy in a way that helps everybody, and doesn't just inflate the numbers.
More importantly, taxing the rich based on unrealized wealth means forcing them to sell their assets. Markets would be flooded with new supply and no buyers, tanking prices and putting everything in a much worse position.
You can tax "unrealized" wealth when that wealth is used to actually fund expenditure, currently anytime this wealth exchanges hands as the same asset it is seen not as a realization of wealth, which is what needs to be changed.
You will simply be taking money from the rich, and then giving it right back to them by inflating asset values.
Because the assets are the things that are scarce and valuable, and you're now disincentivizing the creation of them while stimulating demand for them more by dumping cash on everyone.
There is only one path: creating more valuable things (more supply of real estate and businesses offering competing products lowers their price). China, ironically a 'communist' country, figured this out yet we're still struggling to.
The truth is we don't want to face this reality. We'd rather sit at computers, place fantasy expectations on the politician du jour to save us, and repeat smart sounding memes we don't understand for magical internet upvotes ('late stage capitalism' 'K shaped economy') instead of picking up a hammer and building anything.
And those other things the poor will spend it on are also already inflated because of a lack of competition. Corporate profits are at record level across many industries, despite the fact that 60% of Americans are struggling.
Your scarcity argument only really holds for real estate, but that too is exacerbated by rich people buying real estate just because they can, because they need to put their money somewhere. Meanwhile poor people are struggling to buy their first home. Poor people are not going to buy multiple homes, they really just need the one.
You’re assuming that taxing the rich would mean giving the government more money, but that doesn’t have to be the case.
You could, for example, raise taxes on the rich to the point where income tax is dropped entirely for the vast majority of people who currently pay it.
You could calculate how much the federal budget would need to fill the gap created if, say, nobody earning under €100k a year had to pay income tax anymore. That sum would then be offset by raising taxes on the richest people. No extra money gets “dumped” into the government. It’s the same amount as before, except a large share of it is effectively handed back to people who earn their income from work.
Why does your mind equate "taxing wealth to reduce inequality" == dumping that money as hand out to the citizens? Why can't government, that after Thatcher and Reagan threw up their hands saying "we are too dumb to plan anything", just go back to planning long term spending (such as reducing construction regulations or make it more efficient, both requiring capital I assume), which, ironically, is also what you're praising China for.
With respect, it sounds like you're also falling for the criticism you give out to others about "smart sounding memes" ; yours one step further than the one you're criticizing, but stops at the step where more tax== hand outs meme
If asset-based income was taxed similarly or included in the tax base, you wouldn't have stimulus become inflationary in the way it is today.
Let's be concrete (and unpopular): If one of the few assets left to buy for billionaires is land, which creates competition among them for land not to live on but to HOLD and rent out, the solution is not to "increase the supply of land", it's to decrease the amount of billionaires...
We can build more cities. How do you think the current cities we have came to be?
Yes, it requires a longer term view than a 4 year election cycle. China has created hundreds of cities from nothing in the past 30 years. Many failed, many succeeded. This is the risk taking required to create new things.
We could do it too. But we choose to stagnate and inflate the real estate we already own instead.