Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
You could take every dollar of wealth Elon has and give every American $2,500. Is that really going to help?

More importantly, taxing the rich based on unrealized wealth means forcing them to sell their assets. Markets would be flooded with new supply and no buyers, tanking prices and putting everything in a much worse position.

The issue with accepting this status quo of tax policy is that it isn't the same in other countries. The US (uniquely?) does not tax asset wealth when it is distributed which allows for huge accumulation of wealth outside of the tax base, Canada has deemed disposition for example that brings any asset that is distributed from one individual to another into the tax base even if the asset remains the same asset (unsold stock that ahs appreciated).

You can tax "unrealized" wealth when that wealth is used to actually fund expenditure, currently anytime this wealth exchanges hands as the same asset it is seen not as a realization of wealth, which is what needs to be changed.

I'm very much in favor of closing a loophole that allows the wealthy to borrow against their assets and have tax-free income.

I'm very much opposed to a wealth tax that forces a person to have to pay for gains they never realized even if that means having to sell the very asset in question.

I personally don't actually agree with income tax at all, but if we have it then it should standard across the board without said loophole and acting as a tax on income, not paper wealth that can't be spent.

Wait, how would lower prices be bad? Isn't that exactly what we want?
People want groceries and house prices to come down yes, unless you already own a home. People don't want prices to collapse though, and more importantly our government doesn't want prices to come down.

Deflation is a death spiral for debt markets. Our economy is so precariously balanced on top of debts and derivatives that the whole thing would crumble if prices of major asset classes collapse.

loading story #50560201