Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> The money taken from asset holders will simply be dumped right back into the economy via populist handouts, and that money will ultimately just re-inflate the things that are scarce and valuable (assets).

What's a "populist handout", specifically?

I wouldn't count the endless corporate and agriculture bailouts as populist, personally, but I'm curious if you would. As a salaried middle class American who owns real estate in the range of $500k in assessed value, the only handout I've ever received since becoming an adult half-my-lifetime ago was the Covid stimulus check. Every other "handout" that I've received was a tax break, e.g. the lifting of the SALT deduction limit.

"Populist handouts" (by my definition) are a boogeyman that I've never actually personally experienced in the USA, especially compared to (1) the tax breaks that are handed out left-and-right, (2) corporate and agriculture bailouts, and (3) the military-industrial complex.

My soap box: I think what made the New Deal so aspirational was that, yes, the government was giving people money, but it was also paying them to perform jobs that made the nation a better place to live. We have so much crumbling infrastructure. Instead of handing corporations the money directly, make them bid on infrastructure projects. Then heavily fund a department that roots out fraud and abuse and make it culturally taboo, through legislation, to perform fraud and abuse.

"populist handout" is a extreme, but you have to admit that French going nuts over raising retirement age when they have deficit 5% of GDP is also a bit extreme.

Maybe both sides need to step back.

But if you frame the debate as US-only then I basically agree.

All those things you listed are populist handouts to specific congressional districts to please the extremely narrow interests of the people in that area at the expense of the greater nation.

This is my point. Any money that comes in will be spent on handouts at a factor of 2X the amount that actually came in, further inflating the deficit and entering the money supply to ultimately inflate things that are scarce and valuable (assets).

Also, I'm in full agreement that it would be great to invest in building infrastructure and rooting out fraud, but we just can't do it any more now that so many people's incomes are dependent on making sure nothing ever happens.

In the congressional districts where I've lived, I don't remember any getting elected due to populist politics as much as the much bigger factors: (1) receiving party endorsements which leads to (2) receiving campaign funding. Those party endorsements and campaign funding are often tied to moneyed interests, which is basically the opposite of populist interests these days. Can't help but feel that the definition of "populist" is being stretched real thin here.