Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> Anthropic and OpenAI are the AltaVista of the AI era. With first starter advantage but no real moat and very good at spending money.

Disagree. Google's search algorithm / variants were available for people to replicate. But there is only 1 google today. There are many office suites but people are still stuck to Microsoft Office -- many such examples.

While Anthropic and OpenAI have no technology moat people will become habituated to their user/api interfaces and rich features (which will take competitors a long slog to build).

The reason why Google was #1 was they had a product that was ultrafast and without ads, so anybody who saw it switched instantly, there was no reason to look for another option. As for office suites, Microsoft won because of their aggressive tactics regarding format compatibility.

None of these apply to LLMs. I do enjoy cheap subscription to use frontier models, but if tomorrow I need to switch to the so-called open models, I won't regret it that much.

The lock-in you're missing here is that businesses use LLMs in conjunction with collaboration. They're building one-off apps that live inside the Claude GUI and sharing them with teammates.

To move that to an open model, you need to replicate the software surface (collaboration, functionality, permissions, etc.) and then provide a way to migrate the existing artifacts/data/history. Migrating developers is the easy version of the problem, migrating everyone else is potentially more difficult.

And then, it has to be trustworthy. Do I trust the provider with my sensitive business assets? If we are spending (say) $50k/yr on this, is it worth me risking my job by switching the company to a no-name brand to save $25k/yr?

The lock-in effect is stronger because so many engineers don't think it exists at all.

AI is what allows you to create and replicate almost anything digital using very few resources and quickly.

Where is the moat?

It's just crazy what is in people's minds.

The moat is, as it's often been before, brand and trust. "No one ever got fired for choosing IBM" will become "No one ever got fired for choosing Claude Code"
loading story #50561451
The actual moat for now is compute
Google came after AltaVista and Yahoo were already quite established. Google were quite late to the party and won on doing search much better than what came before them.