Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Who knew that having wealth accumulate instead of flow would be bad for an economy that relies on the allocation of capital? Every economist ever.

Billionaires are the economic equivalent of a tumor. I don't know why we're so obsessed with perpetuating them.

This is an interesting position.

high volume, 'flow', of wealth is usually what economists call a hot economy, which usually leads to inflation which then usually leads to problems that a central bank has to mitigate or consumers have to bear the weight of.

I know this is getting into the weeds of economics ...the OP was posting about a pending IPO...just setting something out for consideration....

There is something more though I think in terms of lack of cultural capital.

There isn't enough cultural activities we value in society so we have largely turned our culture into this kind of net worth sporting contest. Billionaire is just round number bias that reflects a goal post in the sport at the highest level.

Late neoliberalism I believe is the right frame but this is still a rather obscure idea.

It's annoying that people all readily acknowledge that billionaires do not have piles of cash, but then they incessantly talk as if they do.

My friend, the billionaires wealth is the economy. It is the thing that is flowing the money.

Jeff Bezos wealth isn't cash redeemable pieces of paper with "Amazon Share" stamped on them.

His wealth is warehouses filled with goods, software running logistics networks, CPU's serving web services, trucks delivering packages, and a workforce of 1.5 million people all aligned on serving paying customers for their needs or wants.

So while you can detest it and hate it, at least recognize that that is what you call "accumulated wealth", not a pile of money where we are one legislative act away from busting open like a pinata.

If you snapped your fingers to distribute his wealth, you'd feel pretty dumb when you end up with 13 aluminum dolly carts as your share.

So how did Jeff Bezos become one of the largest private land-owners in the United States, if he has no wealth?

How did he pay for his wedding, with non-cash-redeemable pieces of paper?

Or how did James Dyson manage to become the biggest agricultural landowner in England?

And who was then buying e.g. Van Gogh's art for 400M USD just this week?

It's equally annoying that people readily acknowledge that billionaires have no cash because they openly operate a tax-avoidance scheme where they lend money against the stock they own, to benefit from its value while it keeps growing and "officially" are poor.

100M USD of stock create instant liquidity of 50-70M USD at low interest, without ever needing to sell the stock.

You understand they need to pay those loans back, right? Those loans just defer taxes, they don't avoid them.

The actual tax dodge is mostly charitable donations being exempt, and the step up basis of inheritance.

However neither of those things have any real bearing on a wealth tax.

Which technically already exists because Amazon pays taxes every year, which is to say, his wealth is paying billions in taxes every year already.

> "Which technically already exists because Amazon pays taxes every year, which is to say, his wealth is paying billions in taxes every year already."

Yes, an effective 1.4% income tax in 2025...

And Jeff Bezos moved his residency to Florida which has no state income tax.

The scheme works, and the audience not only applauds but as I can see rushes to defend it...

Because billionaires and those right below them spend a ton of capital on perpetuating the idea that the average person can be like them. Hell they even have their own podcasts now lol
> "...that the average person can be like them"

...or become a beneficiary of the benevolent billionaire.

My favorite quote comes to mind: "The wood will not vote against the axe, because it has unrealistic expectations to become an axe-handle one day"

It's an absolute state when hackernews from all places has degenerated into braindead leftist "economics" echo-chamber.
I love how the exact same people I describe above (normal people who've be brainwashed to think they can achieve the same level of success that only ~3k billionaires have had), have also been programmed to automatically dismiss anybody that writes a sentence that uses the word billionaire negatively, as "braindead" leftist economics.

They have brainwashed you to the extent that you spend your time reflexively defending them in the comments of online spaces. You become an activated foot soldier, coming to the defense for the very people who seek to enslave you the second anyone says something bad about them.

You proved my point.

Nope, I just understand basic economics and have logical deduction skills instead of buying sentimental bullcrap from demagogues. Please read a book, you will be doing all of us a favour.
What book do you think would change my mind?
For your level even basic economics books from any 101 course in a university (google away) would help you a lot.
I took many economics classes, its partially why I have informed opinions on the matter. You're so confident reading a book would change my mind, surely you have a reccomendation.. Or are you just politicing? Maybe lay off the X algo.
I don't have an X, never did. Was it a Learing Center you got your economics classes from?
Perhaps you should be the one to read that book. None of the things discussed here are in any way controversial, except with the billionaires and their politicians. Many economists are saying the same things we are saying. That's where we got it from.