Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
I would like to see this claim justified:

   In the Dewey Decimal System, a book on gardening could potentially be in 
   any of the four places in the system that contained gardening content. 
   With Wayfinder, it’s all in the same place.
I think there is always a question of where to file something, like a book about the history of gardening in England could be filed under gardening or the history of England. You could do better than old systems but you're not getting it right always.

I think the greatest embarrassment in Dewey and Library of Congress (LC) is how they handled computers. Dewey has a trash section at the beginning and computers wind up right after UFOs and bigfoot but oddly most occult subjects end up in the 130's except for a tiny bit in the 398.4 but my witchy friends would be happy to know The Spiral Dance is filed at 299.

LC on the other hand puts almost everything about computers in QA76 except for some clusters in the TK area and some oddly general things in QA75. (In LC The Spiral Dance is filed along with more lurid books on witchcraft that Dewey files at 133.4) Instead of "generic" and "math" and in some alternate universe it would have been reasonable to put computers under electronics in 621.3 and in fact you might find a few books there about how gates are constructed in CMOS there if you're lucky.

The trouble is that computers expanded to embrace everything so books like "How to process your photographs in Adobe Lightroom" ends up in the 0's that really ought to be filed in the 600's (photography as technology) or the 770s (photography as art.) Stuff like that ends up in 0's in Dewey but in LC usually gets filed in the TRs, though if it was like Dewey they'd file photography under the NDs.

The advantage a "bookstore-like" system has is that if it isn't set in stone you can change it.

> I would like to see this claim justified:

Perhaps:

    580 – Botany and plant science (scientific study rather than growing)
    631 – Soil, techniques, tools, and equipment
    632 – Plant injuries, diseases, and pests
    634 – Orchards, fruits, and forestry
    635 – Garden crops (Horticulture) and general gardening
    712 / 716 – Landscape design and herbaceous plants in landscape architecture 
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Dewey_Decimal_classes

630 is Agriculture, so there's some clustering there.

I don't think anyone's disputing that Dewey Decimal can place "related" books in different places. The question is whether this new proprietary system improves on it.

Like, consider the parent post's example of "a book about the history of gardening in England". That covers at least two topics, gardening and English history. If you choose to group all the gardening books together in one place, then you force the English history books to be scattered instead. This is just an inherent limitation of reducing a multi-dimensional "topic" space to a linear ordering.

The meaningful question is whether on average, this system is a more useful grouping than alternatives, based on how well it captures the "related-ness" that people actually care about, and how difficult it is for them to find what they're looking for. You can't answer that question by looking at the classification hierarchy alone. It's an empirical question about how users interact with the system.

The solution is classify a book with multiple tags, like imdb.com does with movies.
Indeed, although unless we abstract shelving away with some kind of automated retrieval from an indexed, “unordered” store in the stacks, the books will still be linear on the shelves at some level!

On another note, D is a very cool language. Thanks for your work there.

loading story #50566759
loading story #50570188
loading story #50567167
With physical books, placement is singular (constraining browsing discovery). Even the old card catalogs had subject indexing (though constrained by physical size and costs). Even with a fully three dimensional arrangement (which gravity makes impractical), one cannot cluster every subject pairing much less items with three or more tags. (One could place subject markers as "see also" indicators for common cross-references.)

I suspect with physical books, knowing typical patron categorizations and interest groupings could aid browsing (and accessing all related materials quickly).

Public libraries are also somewhat constrained by desiring a single organizing system so employees can transfer to different branches with less retraining (long term or as substitutes). However, even within a U.S. state's county, patrons' interests can vary.

Also, tagging seems insufficient as different tags have different strengths. Perhaps something more like a word cloud might be useful?

The Melvil (Dewey is proprietary, I think) system is far from perfect, but any weighing of the tradeoffs will disadvantage some use case. Knowing your users helps as does training them and having experts (librarians).

(I am a public library page (shelver), so I regularly encounter the quirks of Melvil/Dewey and what I view as cataloging shortcomings where the subject of secondary significance is used, like a televison show's cookbook being cataloged under television shows, correct but not likely to circulare as well, (and a few errors such as a volcano book cataloged as 551.31 instead of 551.21).)

If I need a specific book or topic I'll have to look up where it is no matter what system is used. So using one that's better for casual browsing is fine for me.
A library here did this, replaced the Dewey ordering with who-knows-what ordering. As far as I could tell the thinking was "here is a library. there are many books. the one you want might be somewhere in here". It was completely nuts, unless you happened to think exactly like whoever it was that dreamed up the system, if there was one, you couldn't find anything. I can't find any mention of this any more beyond a single LinkedIn reference so they must have abandoned it again once common sense returned.
loading story #50562107
Yeah from reading the article, it seems like the main driver in the uptick is a more intuitive taxonomy and categorization, and gaining the ability to reorder and reconfigure sections as they see fit rather than being limited to the strict ordering that the dewey decimal system implies.
> a book about the history of gardening in England could be filed under gardening or the history of England.

Actually there are more possibilities: N elements can be ordered N! ways, and all make sense here:

  Gardening > England > History
  Gardening > History > England
  England > History > Gardening
  England > Gardening > History
  History > Gardening > England
  History > England > Gardening
And of course the three elements are not roots of the Dewey tree, except maybe History, so they could be in multiple places.

The idea that there is category tree that uniquely classifies all human knowledge is impossible, as anyone who has tried to classify even a small set of knowledge has discovered.

loading story #50579713
loading story #50570247
> I think there is always a question of where to file something, like a book about the history of gardening in England could be filed under gardening or the history of England.

i understand the pain point, but:

1. modern libraries usually have an information system that precisely tell you a) if they have the book you're looking for at all and b) where it is in that specific library

(the two city libraries i go to have a computer for that, or you can ask the librarians)

2. every time i search for a specific book i serendipitously run into other interesting books, and that's nice (so i've got that going for me).

side note: i recently was looking for "simulacra and simulation" by baudrillard and asked chatgpt under which section to look for it. scanned for a while, did not find it, noticed some interesting other titles, then finally went and checked the information system and that specific library did not have it at all. so lesson learned is: don't bother much with the classification, just use the digital information system

The problem is that it completely discards the other, also important, use of a library: discovering books that you did not know about which are slightly related to what you went looking for.

If you go look for Metamagical Themas by Hofstadter, you already know to search for Hofstadter, but maybe you hadn't heard of Martin Gardner or Raymond Smullyan or Persi Diaconis, all of which you could conceivably find on the same shelf.

This sort of serendipity is lost in catalog systems, even keyword systems -- but it is one of the best features of Wikipedia, and one which the Wikimedia Foundation seems determined to stamp out.

> This sort of serendipity is lost in catalog systems, even keyword systems

I kinda see your point and that’s why i think information systems should be deployed alongside catalogue systems.

Also, what about recommendation services?