Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> a book about the history of gardening in England could be filed under gardening or the history of England.

Actually there are more possibilities: N elements can be ordered N! ways, and all make sense here:

  Gardening > England > History
  Gardening > History > England
  England > History > Gardening
  England > Gardening > History
  History > Gardening > England
  History > England > Gardening
And of course the three elements are not roots of the Dewey tree, except maybe History, so they could be in multiple places.

The idea that there is category tree that uniquely classifies all human knowledge is impossible, as anyone who has tried to classify even a small set of knowledge has discovered.

What you are showing there would be a "faceted system" if you made a decision of order, e.g.

   Activity > Aspect > Place
there are bits of faceting in both modern Dewey and LC.
loading story #50581203
A keyword system could, but it has to be a curated set. E.g. there are consolidated indices into collections of articles of some periodic publications; their scope is smaller, but diverse enough.