Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
With physical books, placement is singular (constraining browsing discovery). Even the old card catalogs had subject indexing (though constrained by physical size and costs). Even with a fully three dimensional arrangement (which gravity makes impractical), one cannot cluster every subject pairing much less items with three or more tags. (One could place subject markers as "see also" indicators for common cross-references.)

I suspect with physical books, knowing typical patron categorizations and interest groupings could aid browsing (and accessing all related materials quickly).

Public libraries are also somewhat constrained by desiring a single organizing system so employees can transfer to different branches with less retraining (long term or as substitutes). However, even within a U.S. state's county, patrons' interests can vary.

Also, tagging seems insufficient as different tags have different strengths. Perhaps something more like a word cloud might be useful?

The Melvil (Dewey is proprietary, I think) system is far from perfect, but any weighing of the tradeoffs will disadvantage some use case. Knowing your users helps as does training them and having experts (librarians).

(I am a public library page (shelver), so I regularly encounter the quirks of Melvil/Dewey and what I view as cataloging shortcomings where the subject of secondary significance is used, like a televison show's cookbook being cataloged under television shows, correct but not likely to circulare as well, (and a few errors such as a volcano book cataloged as 551.31 instead of 551.21).)