Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
I'm not sure I've ever worked at a company that was fully like this, but I have worked in teams and sometimes departments where smart people giving a shit meant that work actually felt rewarding and meaningful. Like you say it's rare, but it usually doesn't persist, because it only takes one idiot at a high enough level to start recruiting other idiots or there's a company takeover usually by a big firm of idiots etc. And given the propensity for idiots to rise above their level of competency (Peter Principle [1]) or for sociopaths to start empire building (Gervais Principle [2])...

In game theory terms this would seem to be the problem of bad acting overcoming good [3], arguably because it's better incentivised.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_principle

[2] - https://ribbonfarm.com/series/the-gervais-principle/

[3] - https://ncase.me/trust/

I generally find my happy place are smaller companies where the executive team give a shit, are smart, and not insecure about hiring people who are also smart and/or possibly smarter than them.

(Possibly the Peter principle etc always win at some scale)

loading story #50561144
It never ceases to amaze me how quickly the C suite can fill up with dark triad types. I genuinely do not understand why companies allow this.
The Gervais principle goes into this in some depth, from Part 1 [1]:

"The result is the MacLeod hierarchy. It may be horrible, but like democracy, it is the best you can do. The Sociopath (capitalized) layer comprises the Darwinian/Protestant Ethic will-to-power types who drive an organization to function despite itself."

and

"The Sociopaths enter and exit organizations at will, at any stage, and do whatever it takes to come out on top. The contribute creativity in early stages of a organization's life, neurotic leadership in the middle stages, and cold-bloodedness in the later stages, where they drive decisions like mergers, acquisitions and layoffs that others are too scared or too compassionate to drive. They are also the ones capable of equally impersonally exploiting a young idea for growth in the beginning, killing one good idea to concentrate resources on another at maturity, and milking an end-of-life idea through harvest-and-exit market strategies."

But I think it's also worth remembering that at the end of the day, the "company" is just an ever rotating collection of individuals all operating according to their own psychology and incentives so there is no benevolent dictator overseeing the whole thing and trying to motivate it differently.

I guess from a shareholder point of view they are also the ones most likely to be focussing on the fiduciary duty to maximise shareholder value (whilst it aligns with their own) which in a competitive world probably requires exactly those dark triad manoeuvrings.

[1] - https://ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-or-t...

This is a fascinating perspective on, I think, an under-discussed topic. It might very well be true. What I have seen doesn't quite match this. I have seen this type use the company for their own purposes and then leave when it is convenient. It doesn't even seem possible to me that they are actually helping because they care solely and only about themselves and not about the long term success of the company, let alone the people in it.
loading story #50563868