They are definitely a liability for run-of-the-mill idiots. Luckily there are some rare companies that have non-idiots in the right places to allow small bubbles of giving-a-shit. It's certainly something that doesn't scale.
What are some companies like this?
Its everywhere, it just takes 1 good manager with a good working relationship with a Director/VP above them. Of course, it only takes 1 action from above them to undo all that goodwill too.
Cloudflare
I'm not sure I've ever worked at a company that was fully like this, but I have worked in teams and sometimes departments where smart people giving a shit meant that work actually felt rewarding and meaningful. Like you say it's rare, but it usually doesn't persist, because it only takes one idiot at a high enough level to start recruiting other idiots or there's a company takeover usually by a big firm of idiots etc. And given the propensity for idiots to rise above their level of competency (Peter Principle [1]) or for sociopaths to start empire building (Gervais Principle [2])...
In game theory terms this would seem to be the problem of bad acting overcoming good [3], arguably because it's better incentivised.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_principle
[2] - https://ribbonfarm.com/series/the-gervais-principle/
[3] - https://ncase.me/trust/
loading story #50558836
It never ceases to amaze me how quickly the C suite can fill up with dark triad types. I genuinely do not understand why companies allow this.
loading story #50558891