Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
The soviets did regularly carry a gun. For survival purposes, as they were landing in Siberia which has wolves and pretty big bears.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TP-82

Salyut 3 also had a "self-defence gun" derived from an aircraft autocannon mounted to the station, enabling them to shoot at approaching enemy spacecraft

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salyut_3#On-board_gun

> The gun was fixed to the station in such a way that the only way to aim would have been to change the orientation of the entire station.

Are these stations easier to maneuver than I imagine? Sounds like someone was imagining age of sail type of combat.

loading story #50512245
I would guess having any sort of teeth would be meaningful to dissuade whatever type of manned craft might have been able to approach them at the time.
I'm guessing that pivoting the gun and firing would impart spin to the station, is the greater concern. And then pivoting the gun to stay on target would impart even more spin on subsequent shots.
What if you pivoted in the opposite direction?
In a modern system you'd just have the RCS thrusters fire based on the positioning of the gun, to counteract the force.

OTOH, if all piloting was manual back then, you'd have to have one guy aiming and another guy piloting to cancel out the angular momentum, so you might as well make the gun point away from the center of mass and let the pilot do the aiming.

tbf, docking attempts would not be that fast either
Russian paranoia at its finest
Inteestingly, a lot of military aircraft at the time carried similar guns. They were meant for use by the pilot in case the landed in the wilderness after bailing out of the plane, for hunting and defending from stuff like bears.
loading story #50511850
I believe people involved in the program have since admitted that this was mostly to commit suicide in case they got stuck with no way home
They already had a makarov pistol with them from the start. They made this custom short barrel double shotgun with a third rifle barrel.

This was to fend off wild life and maybe hunting while waiting for the recovery team to get to them if they came down far from the designated recovery zone.

Source?

Over the years at least 7 soviet missions landed off-target including Yuri Gagarin.

And not like 100-500 meters off target, but 200-600 kilometers. Having a gun in such cases make perfect sense.

feels like you just invented this lie on the spot
It may be invented, but not by him. It is at least as old as the 1997 film Contact.

https://vimeo.com/188517388

The description blurb reads:

  "Since Apollo 13 many people have asked me, 'Did you have suicide pills on board?' We didn't, and I never heard of such a thing in the eleven years I spent as an astronaut and NASA executive," - Jim Lovell, commander of the ill-fated Apollo 13 mission.

  For this scene, from the movie "Contact", based off his book, I guess Carl Sagan got inspiration from the Soviet Voskhod 2 mission. Cosmonaut Alexey Leonov said he was given a suicide pill by the authorities, in the event that he might get stuck outside of the Voskhod spacecraft while attempting the very first "spacewalk" or EVA (extra-vehicular activity).

  For NASA's options, Gerry Griffin, a former director of the Johnson Space Center in Houston, Texas, corroborated Lovell's statement, bluntly adding that if an astronaut truly wished to end his or her life, space provides plenty of opportunities. Outer space is just as effective a suicide agent as a cyanide capsule, perhaps even more so. Exposure to its empty vacuum often results in a blissful loss of consciousness in a matter of seconds. Death by asphyxiation usually follows within two minutes. (from http://www.realclearscience.com/blog/2013/10/astronauts-and-suicide-pills.html)

  Uploaded on Oct 23, 2016 at 5:36 am
As for the 2013 link, it reads that although the Americans weren't issued suicide capsules, at least one Soviet had one (although he didn't say if it was issued by the space program vs him just carrying it with him of his own accord).
loading story #50510635
loading story #50509068
Surely a chemical/biological solution would have been easier, cheaper, lighter, and less likely to fail.
It would but that would have gone against the image that the soviets were trying to convey internally and externally
The solution is you need no solution, air is gonna run out, they will fall unconscious and die.
loading story #50508505
> chemical/biological solution

both massively unpleasant

Cyanide pill I get. Tried and tested.

But a biological solution?! I imagine a little jar full of extremely venomous spiders, one for each cosmonaut. Perhaps they'd give them names.

loading story #50508716
loading story #50509937
Who said what's in the gun :)
I imagine you can't take turns easily once there's a hole in the ship.

On the other hand, there are legitimate predators that will hunt and eat humans in Siberia. One team encountered wolves that they had trouble fending off, so they upgraded the pistol to a more formidable shotgun/rifle combo.

Unlikely that a handgun bullet passing through a skull will still have enough velocity to breach the hull? Even if it did, they'd just need to be deliberate with their aim vis-a-vis a steel plate.
loading story #50509087
> I imagine you can't take turns easily

Seems like a problem they could solve if they just put their heads together. /s

Yeah thats why you invent small 2 barrel shotgun with big ammo and carry it all the way into space, while even small makarov pistol would fulfill that role
Feels a bit excessive. Wolves and brown bears generally avoid humans. Polar bears see us as food but brown bears do not.
26 fatalities due to bear attacks this year: https://tass.ru/obschestvo/28211259 https://eia.media/ru/article/society/6aa937759a7947f75201876... https://www.rbc.ru/society/15/09/2026/6aa937759a7947f7520187... This year bear encounters made headlines in Russia, but the number of fatalities isn't unusual. Records is 80/year in 1985, 1986 and 1996. Brown bears don't see us as food as long as there is some other food available. If food is scarce this year (some random dude on the internet says that there were an early thaw followed by freeze in 2024 that cause pine cone yield in 2026 to fail) they might attack. Either out of desperation or when encountered over a food source (i. e. garbage dump) and mistakes a human for a competitor.
You might be underestimating how remote some Soviet capsules landed. If they overshot their landing site they might be alone in the wilderness for days until rescue teams arrived

"Kosmonaut survives space mission, gets mauled by bear protecting her cub" is not a great headline. Bringing gun was relatively cheap insurance

Might need something to eat if you have to wait a few days for the rescue team to reach you.
Want, not need. A few days without food is quite survivable for a healthy human. And if you get selected for a space flight, you are healthy.
That works if you have absolute trust the rescue team will reach you on schedule. If you are unsure whether few days won't turn into few weeks, or whether there will be a rescue team at all, it's best to secure food and shelter while you still have the energy to do it.
Gun and bear solves that problem too.
"So the bad news is we're responsible for our next meal, but the good news is Ivan's space food farts will lead the meal right to us"
A gun helps with that, too.
> "Kosmonaut survives space mission, gets mauled by bear protecting her cub" is not a great headline.

Let's be honest here: the Soviets were never going to print that anyways.

It would certainly be printed for KPSS Politburo and someone would end up far away in Siberia.
Brown bears attack people in Russia quite frequently [1].

[1] https://meduza.io/en/feature/2026/09/11/russia-has-a-bear-pr...

I think it's important not to overgeneralize with something that might potentially kill you. The brown bears in Japan can be deadly. A 380 kg and 2.7-m-tall brown bear, which twice attacked the village of Tomamae, killing 7 people.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ussuri_brown_bear#Interactions...

There was a brown (North American Grizzly) predation attack on Nov 2. It’s rare, but not unheard of.

Wolf predation attacks on humans are rare, but far more common than brown bear attacks.

Landing in remote part of Siberia is not a typical situation and many typical assumptions do not apply.
If you’re a pilot or cosmonaut in Siberia, you might not have come down as planned and might be there for a while. An injured, possibly bleeding human could be easy prey. They also have tigers…
"Generally" implies there are exceptions. Would hate to be unprepared.
Of course there are exceptions but ticks kill more people than bears and wasps kill way more people.
Ticks and wasps are much, much more common than bears.
What about lunar bears or Saturn bears? Those seem to be heavily armed.

https://youtu.be/pvjgIxuVdo4?is=7sF64RM0qTNqJguw

"generally". A hungry bear or wolf might be tempted to mess with an injured cosmonaut.
It's never excessive to carry a gun.
TSA says no.
Sky marshals have weapons and the TSA allows them.

Being an astronaut means you are trusted with extreme responsibilities and it also means extreme oversight. That's part of why the selection process is so thorough and stress response is so well evaluated before NASA will put a person in space.

Reading the parent's comment pedantically is useless and against this site's guidelines. Reading it more charitably + less literally makes more sense.

There also might be some unfriendly people. Like escaped convicts living in the woods, in the middle of nowhere.
>> wolves and pretty big bears.

So the pistol was presumably for the astronaut to use on himself?

They most certainly have a shank stashed on ISS somewhere