Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
I am fine with the idea of the singer who wrote "I want to fuck you like an animal" evolving into writing Disney music and winning Oscars for it. But I am not fine with him putting the costume back on after writing Disney music and pretending he's the same person from the 90s or that he can sing those songs with even a modicum of authenticity, unless the entire NIN thing was an act. So I can't listen to the music anymore without significant disappointment.
Reznor does a very good job of not pretending to be the same guy from the 90s, his live performances are always reworking the old songs in creative ways (Closer with a gospel style backing choir for example).

I think it's honestly a good case study on how to age gracefully, it still feels he authentically inhabits his older work but obviously we shouldn't want him to continue LARPing as his mid-20s self that was writing from the brink of suicide and heroin OD

I was a huge NIN fan back in the day. I even had a DOS device driver that turned my “n” backwards like their logo. I know everything about the band that a fan from the 90s could know. The idea that Trent Reznor of the 90s would sell out and write Disney songs and then turn around and start singing his NIN songs at the same time would probably make the 90s version of him attempt suicide. At least whoever Trent Reznor was portraying to be in the 90s would have claimed that.

Like I said, if he has evolved, which all people are allowed to do, and he found God then great. But who he was in the 90s, the songs he wrote, the society he rejected and fought against versus who he is now are diametrically opposed. You can’t pick up your old songs and “evolve” them and pretend everything is okay. It’s a slap in the face to the fans who believed in his message of “Fuck this fake society”. If he left his songs in the past then I would be okay with it but to pick up his old songs and sing them nowadays makes me about as sad as I could ever be about a hero who may never have been who he claimed he was.

Yeah in some ways he's a figure who in an alternative universe was destined to end up like Cobain or Layne Staley and probably would have been more celebrated than either had he died after Downward Spiral

I think he's cooler for riding it out though, to me it doesn't devalue any of his other work to see the Disney stuff for example. I like that someone whose art has always been rooted in transgression has been able to permeate the mainstream and win Oscars for it instead of just being relegated to 90s industrial fandom like Ministry for example

There's a lot of things he's done in his later career like open sourcing Ghosts, championing smaller acts like Saul Williams, giving The Slip and other music away for free and using Year Zero to push a politically critical ARG I think is creatively transgressive in the context of the industry without being self-destructive.

I just think there's no universe where he could have stayed "true" to the original work without it feeling sad and weird for a 61 year old man or him just being a 27 club member who tragically passed too soon, a story which is common enough that it's probably the least interesting or imaginative outcome

That said a lot of his newest work with Atticus is wack and I'd rather just hear more "return to form" content than ambient modular synth jams and jazz infused take on industrial rock for example

I'm not sure the original version of Reznor that you're idolizing was as authentic as you seem to believe.

By most accounts of his peers, he was always a little bit fake in his earliest days. Then he went off the deep end of drug abuse and ego (as so many of them did), bought into his own buillshit for a bit there, and then later became a somewhat normal person.

> The idea that Trent Reznor of the 90s would sell out and write Disney songs and then turn around and start singing his NIN songs at the same time would probably make the 90s version of him attempt suicide. At least whoever Trent Reznor was portraying to be in the 90s would have claimed that.

Agreed.

> You can’t pick up your old songs and “evolve” them and pretend everything is okay.

Don't see why not. It's his song. They're all deeply personal. Especially the songs from his earliest works.

> It’s a slap in the face to the fans who believed in his message of “Fuck this fake society”.

I'm not sure I'd ever label Trent as a sellout. For better or worse, he's chosen his own direction based on his artistic whims (ok maybe his wife too). But... He still accepted record deals and sold his stuff. He wasn't playing free punk shows in old warehouses or whatever. He may not have liked society, but he sure as hell participated in it.

> If he left his songs in the past then I would be okay with it but to pick up his old songs and sing them nowadays makes me about as sad as I could ever be about a hero who may never have been who he claimed he was.

He's covered and remixed and re-re-mixed his songs from the very start. Almost obnoxiously so. I've never faulted him for that, even if some did seen to be money grabs to me.

But I'm reasonably sure both his past self and current self would slap the shit out of you for calling him a hero figure.

>But I am not fine with him putting the costume back on after writing Disney music and pretending he's the same person from the 90s or that he can sing those songs with even a modicum of authenticity

Have you considered that musicians do that because its what the fans demand of them? I can imagine just about every artist reaches a point where that hit song that written with meaning to them hits a level of semantic satiation from having to play that song night after night. Reznor basically wrote a song about it, but fans would likely be pissed if they went to a show and just NIN did faithful folk and bluegrass song covers all night (meaning not Industrial interpretations, which could slap, BTW).

“Putting the costume back on”

That’s a bit over the top, NIN today is very different to NIN back then, Trent has naturally changed as a person, so of course his long standing project has as well.

I’ve never got the impression he is pretending to be the same person as he was in the 90s