Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
NIN and Foo Fighters: both produced their first album as nearly completely solo projects, writing the music and lyrics, playing every instrument, singing, all of it. Reznor and Grohl are just astonishingly good musicians.
Pretty Hate Machine was one of the first albums completely recorded on Pro Tools v.1 but it wasn't close to being a solo project. It had four producers, including Adrian Sherwood who worked with a ton of bands including Ministry, Skinny Puppy, Pop Will Eat Itself, KMFDM, Depeche Mode...
While Trent is more industrial adjacent than industrial proper, if you ever get the chance to stop into the Industrial & Post-Punk museum in Chicago, one of the things Martin can play for you are tracks off of his original demo tape. It was cool to hear.
Wow, I'm not like a hardcore industrial fan (but I do listen sometimes), but I love in Chicago and have never heard of this (I guess I should read the Reader more ..). This museum looks totally awesome.
loading story #50592810
loading story #50592647
The Mike Oldfield model.

I'm not a fan of Foo Fighters music in general, which is an unpopular opinion in most of my social circles, but I respect Dave Grohl's talent as a musician.

There's a dude, Adam Page, from Adelaide who's been performing improvised 'solo' shows for, gee, getting on for twenty years now, using looping pedals to build songs one layer at a time into these beautiful constructions:

https://youtu.be/mOqbSvbTw2o

https://youtu.be/7vcZGYuFgVE

I even named one of his songs, pity it got spelt incorrectly: https://adampage.bandcamp.com/track/preventing-a-future-disa...

Long time fan here. Felt pretty groundbreaking to me way back when. Pre-cursor-ish to Angine de Poitrine... maybe.

Not my style of music, much as Foo Fighters isn’t yours, but that’s amazing talent.
> I'm not a fan of Foo Fighters music in general

There are dozens of us! Dozens!

Foo Fighters are such a weird one because I can kind of feel why people love them, and I have mad respect for Dave Grohl's talent, but their music has always just landed in a weird zone for me. At this point I've accepted I'll usually be the lone "FF are overrated" guy in the room, but it's nice to know I'm not the only one!

loading story #50590776
Amusingly, NIN and Foo Fighters swapped drummers last year: https://www.moderndrummer.com/2025/07/foo-fighters-and-nine-...

(And I've heard both Reznor and Grohl declare individually, from the stage, that they're "the best fuckin' drummer in the world")

Grohl was the main drummer on With Teeth as well and they both covered Gary Numan's "Down in the Park" which is a fun example of them each doing their own take on the same source material
Not the Foo Fighters drummer you were referring to, but reminds me of something I often think about.

I think Taylor Hawkins was an amazing drummer, but when Grohl said on stage that "he's the best drummer in the world" - I always wondered whether he was even the best drummer in the band!

I'll be first to acknowledge that I don't know enough to judge, but Grohl's drumming has blown me away on so many songs.

loading story #50588209
Neil Peart is dead, and so is Buddy Rich, so plausibly true.