Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
I wasn't really a fan of the song Terrible Lie, it was a bit basic and lifeless (subjectively, for me) since it was very early NIN. But the live performance of it for 'And All That Could Have Been' made it absolutely dynamic, and turned it into one of my favorite NIN songs:

https://youtu.be/0QbiwDD9Bt8

Which is the very appeal of live performance.

NIN and Foo Fighters: both produced their first album as nearly completely solo projects, writing the music and lyrics, playing every instrument, singing, all of it. Reznor and Grohl are just astonishingly good musicians.
Pretty Hate Machine was one of the first albums completely recorded on Pro Tools v.1 but it wasn't close to being a solo project. It had four producers, including Adrian Sherwood who worked with a ton of bands including Ministry, Skinny Puppy, Pop Will Eat Itself, KMFDM, Depeche Mode...
While Trent is more industrial adjacent than industrial proper, if you ever get the chance to stop into the Industrial & Post-Punk museum in Chicago, one of the things Martin can play for you are tracks off of his original demo tape. It was cool to hear.
loading story #50592190
The Mike Oldfield model.

I'm not a fan of Foo Fighters music in general, which is an unpopular opinion in most of my social circles, but I respect Dave Grohl's talent as a musician.

There's a dude, Adam Page, from Adelaide who's been performing improvised 'solo' shows for, gee, getting on for twenty years now, using looping pedals to build songs one layer at a time into these beautiful constructions:

https://youtu.be/mOqbSvbTw2o

https://youtu.be/7vcZGYuFgVE

I even named one of his songs, pity it got spelt incorrectly: https://adampage.bandcamp.com/track/preventing-a-future-disa...

Long time fan here. Felt pretty groundbreaking to me way back when. Pre-cursor-ish to Angine de Poitrine... maybe.

loading story #50584449
loading story #50589402
Amusingly, NIN and Foo Fighters swapped drummers last year: https://www.moderndrummer.com/2025/07/foo-fighters-and-nine-...

(And I've heard both Reznor and Grohl declare individually, from the stage, that they're "the best fuckin' drummer in the world")

loading story #50587373
loading story #50586183
loading story #50585742
Terrible Lie is the song that created Nine Inch Nails. It was written after he got dumped by his fiancee and then he went on to write the rest of the song from Pretty Hate Machine.
Terrible Lie from "And All That Could Have Been" was a holy shit moment when I heard it. It didn't hurt that it was on a stereo that could be heard clearly from the outside of the house it was in. Just massive impact.
loading story #50592482