Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Not true - the long proof is the verifiable one (because we have it in Lean), the short human solution is the one that can't be verified without a lot of extra work.
To verify, yes. To understand and push mathematics forward, no.
> To understand and push mathematics forward, no.

The Alpoge proof, if true, will certainly push mathematics forward a great deal. In the announcement, he lays out the general approach and says that he had 10+ "WOW" moments of insights while working with the AI on it. I have no doubt that there will be tons of follow-on papers clarifying and expanding many of the ideas that the AI explored. This will likely be the case even if the proof is wrong.

Well maybe.

You can start trying to compress the formal result into something understandable.

Mathematics is already pushed forward by knowing if the hypothesis is true.
Not as much as understanding the process. With these complex proofs, mathematicians often come up with new techniques or entirely new areas of math (see: Poincarè conjecture). If only AI is able to understand AI output, we may as well give up now.
loading story #50582533
Without a formal, verifiable result, what exactly would be understood?
It will likely be ready to formalize it with AI
> Not true - the long proof is the verifiable one (because we have it in Lean)

Please read this article: https://xenaproject.wordpress.com/2026/11/12/and-the-proof-i...

Just because it's in Lean, doesn't mean it's correct, or that the proof actually proves what you think it does

Sure but in this particular case the formal statement in lean predates the proof so we know it is proving what we want.

Multiple people have now compiled the proof with different compilers so we can be reasonably certain it does in fact prove what it says.

The points about auditing all the dependencies and making sure it's not exploiting the lean runtime are valid, and people are doing that now, but we can say with a lot of confidence that this proof is valid given the automated systems in place.

That's a general argument but doesn't apply Anthropic's Lean formalization. There is already a well established Lean statement of the RH in Mathlib that has been pretty rigorously verified, so a proof of that statement is indeed a proof of RH. The only opportunity for failure is that there is a soundness bug in Lean itself which this formalization leverages. The answer to that is that there isn't one single Lean, there are multiple implementations of Lean and each of them have their own opportunities for bugs, so it's possible one bug is common to all of them and that this proof makes use of it, but that's incredibly unlikely.
> Please read this article

This article concludes with

> “It’s true because it’s checked in Lean” can be made to make sense. But one has to do some work beyond “the Lean code compiles”.

And of the four concerns raised in the article, two are explicitly answered by the lean statement and the other two are pretty easy to verify (and likely already have been).

In fact it goes even further:

> ...one has to do some work beyond “the Lean code compiles”. Your frontier AI model can do all of this work. [em. mine] But it needs to be done, and (depending on the amount of Lean code in the proof) it may be computationally costly.

Thank you! I really detest this simplification that I've seen here a lot: "Its in lean so it must be true". Similar to its "rust so its bug free" or its "c++ so it must have a buffer overflow".
You may detest it, but it is likely to be correct and was generated by AI before a human could produce something similar (proof verified in Lean).
"It compiles so the program must be correct"
AI has been great at finding loopholes. And who's going to find out what loophole they used in 250k pages?
The AIs might find the loophole. Even finding a loophole might be a good discovery.

If the true goal is to advance human knowledge, the binary answer to rh is just a starting point. Some of the arguments used here might be true and helpful even if others fall apart. If there's an error in lean or the fundamental axioms, finding that might also be a fundamental contribution.

I await a soundness bug