Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Sculpting teacher here. Ceramic and oil clay--marble is scary.

On the one hand, there is something special about an artist made sculpture. But on the other, in north america we have almost no cool sculpture around us day to day. So few people can make them and there is seemingly limited demand due to costs

If companies start producing millions of sculptures and selling them at walmart or dollarama in bulk, will they still be cool? Or will we make them in our garages in 2036 with robot arms and ai generated designs informed by amazon ring camera footage of our neighbourhoods?

As an artist, what does your role become? Does anything remains scarce in art? Would love to hear some speculation

I'm not an artist, so maybe I'm missing the mark, but I feel like the hard part of making art should be learning how to express or project your artistic vision or complex emotion or some other aspect of human experience into physical space. I'm not sure I subscribe to the idea that the difficulty of the medium you choose is necessary. Sometimes it's the point of the work, but I don't think you're getting the most out of the Pietà if your take home is "wow, that must have been difficult" (although that's just my opinion).

We can look at other art forms that are pretty accessible w.r.t. barrier to entry. Most folks learn creative writing as school children and master the fundamentals quite quickly. Sure, there's reams of bad (and good, don't come at me) fanfic at ao3 as well as middling pulp at the gas station, but I don't think that stops great works from appearing or being any less special.

Similarly, we see pretty terrible statues in public places quite frequently (I'm thinking the derpy Ronaldo statue or the Lucille Ball statue in Celeron).

So all that to say, I'm optimistic that if something like this meant statues were easy to make and you can design one in your underwear in a few hours and hit "print", sure the volume of shite statues would explode, but I think that just raises the floor on quality a bit and leaves the ceiling in tact.

The Walmart effect doesn't worry me because we can already have that with prints of the masters and few do it.

Instead, I'm inspired. Could we democratize and evangelize culture this way?

The American city I live in has 300,000 people. Why can't it have a large building that has full replicas of the great works of art? The Mona Lisa, Whistler's Mother (or Falling Rocket), Van Gogh's Sunflowers or self-portraits (with impasto). Marble sculpture replicas of Canovo, Bernini, Rodin. A small, one-stop shop of some of the world's great works, for people who will never see it otherwise.

loading story #50562301
{"deleted":true,"id":50561732,"parent":50561487,"time":1795103677,"type":"comment"}
>> As an artist, what does your role become? A prompter like most of the jobs that will transform into promoter jobs. Different skills will become more valuable.
When cameras outcompeted human painters, the humans started doing "modern" non figurative art. Cameras can't compete with Dali's imagination.

This had some success, but mostly painters had to find other jobs. Some became photographers.

Our appreciation of art is usually a mix of liking the art itself and admiring the artist. Machines can make technically better art, but I think humans will always be more admired.

I rented a house in Hawaii (outside Hilo) that had two 6 foot horse sculptures by the pool. They were expensive marble, but ugly, and included realistic penises for some reason.

Scarcity due to expense means catering to the taste of those with money, no matter how bad their taste is.