Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
I would argue that humans are generally pretty bad at it. That's why people need to be taxed (coerced) to pay for public infrastructure, and we need workers paid by the tax revenue to actually do the maintenance work. Societies succeed at this to the extent that they have enough resources and growth to support a taxation and maintenance bureaucracy.
Coercion doesn't carry you very far. What you need is consent. If the taxation feels fair to me, because I feel that the benefit to me and my fellow citizens works out to a good deal, we can have something resembling a society, a civilization even. Of course that's a 2-way street, citizens can't be selfish little pricks like the prevailing cultural vibes tell them to be either.
loading story #50578944
This is not true. People can definitely build infrastructure on their own. Taxation and government monopoly is the reason why they don't/can't. Think about the AI infrastructure, which is far more capital intensive than anything right now is being build without a single taxpayer money. But when governments get involved in building puplic infrastructure, they severely botch it like Comcast who were payed billions of taxpayer money to be a monopoly. Remove government (and by it's extension like monopoly and regulatory capture that it enables) and human will build anything far cheaper and efficient.
loading story #50577087
loading story #50573485
>we need workers paid by the tax revenue to actually do the maintenance work

Of course we do. That's not the distinction made, that of voluntary vs paid workers doing the maintenance.

It was about societies being able to do the maintenance vs those that aren't. Our late stage ones spend many times the resources, and collect many time the taxes, but can't maintain shit.

loading story #50578693
loading story #50583230