Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
This is the myopia of tech people.. they exaggerate the weight of digital. AI could very well be able to replace any digital business. But purely digital businesses are such an unimportant sector of the economy. All of the important sectors use digital infra at some point, but none are purely digital.
Those businesses will simply buy tokens, as they already are. Their strategy will increasingly be steered by AI under the control of Anthropic. Their internal operations will no longer function without Claude. They'll shed staff and optimize their organizations around the extraordinary savings offered by AI. Their physical operations will gradually be automated under the control of robotics powered by Anthropic. Those who don't do this will go bankrupt in the face of competition from those who do. In some cases, perhaps many, to accelerate this they'll simply get bought out, then forced through the above process faster than it would organically occur, either by Anthropic itself or a new breed of private equity firms that specialize precisely in this kind of operation. The process will be slower at first, but not nearly as slow as you think, and nothing you mentioned stops it.
Are the designs for robots digital? If they are, they might become really good, right...?
Or just another instance of liberatrian nerd Dunning-Krueger. "Faster than any government can meaningfully intervene", c'mon - if really it is that kind of force majeure thing, they will just say "screw the free market". As if the government is bound to uphold the sacred rules of neo-liberal economics.

Same as Goedel thinking that a logical loophole in the constitution is something that could turn America into a dictatorship legally. Guess what? In practice, somebody wanting to instate a dictatorship probably won't give a crap about some subtle logical fallacy. Same with the Keynesian economics that Americans perceive as law.

You seem to think I'm invoking some kind of obscure academic theory. I'm not. This is actually the most basic competitive process imaginable playing out, and that's all it is. That's exactly why it's actually plausible.
{"dead":true,"deleted":true,"id":50564313,"parent":50557003,"time":1795113825,"type":"comment"}
The bet is that sooner or later, even the remaining meatspace holdouts will be effectively digital and thus controllable by AI.

A lot of manufacturing is already there - that's a part of why China undercuts Western manufacturers, a lot of cheap land and subsidies means you can be far cheaper than Western companies already, even more if you automate what you can. Farming, at least anything with growing plants, is also barely requiring humans any more - precision farming with RTK is absolutely insane. And what remains is trades (where, again, automation like prefabrication is a threat), parts of healthcare and education.

We will own nothing, rent everything and fight for the scraps Sam Altman hands to us.

Or we go and sabotage a couple of data centres and be done with it.
>Farming, at least anything with growing plants, is also barely requiring humans any more - precision farming with RTK is absolutely insane

In your dreams maybe, but not in actual real life.

And if you want an actual Butlerian jihad to happen in real life, then yeah, please put out of work everyone associated with farming on the planet within a few years. You describe the golden path to full-on civil war in 3/4 of the world's countries, with either AI being destroyed or an automated massacre _à la_ Terminator.

Farming is already at <1% of people in society (Germany is at 875k of 85m population). And that is only due to mechanization and large scale consolidation.

As soon as there is wealth available to finance modern ag equipment, farming employment will only fall because the productivity gains are too big to ignore.

And precision farming will go even further. Much more yield with even less staff than we already have, the only reason why it isn't commonplace is that the required tractors cost north of 500k a piece and agriculture is risk-averse. But mark my words in 10 years it will be the norm in Western countries.

The world isn't only western countries.
The near total wipeout of agriculture jobs was in fact one of the first major labor disruptions in history.
> purely digital businesses are such an unimportant sector of the economy

what? facebook? netflix? google?

selling ads is split between internet and TV + some legacy media (like it or not) + maaaaybe some outdoor

computer games are bigger than movies?

You might have a point with computer games. But if you take facebook on the other hand, it would be worthless without people using it. An AI would just create the website. For most businesses, there are non-digital elements which play an essential role, and that remains true even with AI.