Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
If one day, AI becomes provably good at all programming tasks, at working at mathematics better than all mathematicians, and at solving problems in almost all domains with maximal efficiency, I think it'd be a dystopia.

What I simply don't get is why people want to push the boundaries of efficiency and knowledge. I used to think as a teenager that all knowledge was good but how good is knowledge when we can't acquire wisdom with a comparable speed?

The greatest thing about the early internet and earlier science was that people shared and communicated with each other. Now they just share what they produce wihouth much humanity at all.

It seems to me that the creation of all these models has just become a race where no one really cares about the finish line and no one really understands why we're doing it, except for the short-term trail of dollar bills on the race course.

For me, each new model release is a sad day for humanity.

Because hundreds of millions of people live in abject poverty, and if we divvied our economic production up evenly today there'd only be ~$5,000 to ~$15,000 per capita at a US cost of living i.e. the global economy is far too small for everyone to have good lives.

The growth mindset isn't really for you, if you're already rich, and don't want to be richer. It's coming from the vast majority of the world, which is poor, and the minority that is rich but wants to get richer.

> at a US cost of living

We don't want a US cost of living, we want something like a Western European quality of living, and we want to figure out how to get that across the world even for places that have much higher populations than Western Europe, and at a low environmental impact.

Comparing how much a decent quality of life currently costs in the most expensive countries isn't useful.

Also, we need to focus on the basics rather than just trying to give people tons of money: good food, decent housing, free healthcare and free education.

I think most people here know what the price levels in the USA is like, so it's clearest for communicating what our economy is currently able to produce.

Do you think "~$4,000 to ~$12,000 at a German cost of living" would have made it clearer how much we actually have to go around today? Or maybe just saying "the global economy isn't even close to the size where we produce enough for everyone to have decent food, housing, healthcare and education"? To me that seems likely to interpreted as vague and easily dismissed.

> If one day, AI becomes provably good at all programming tasks, at working at mathematics better than all mathematicians, and at solving problems in almost all domains with maximal efficiency, I think it'd be a dystopia.

Which of these are missing in your opinion? I'd argue we are there already. At least very very close, as "with maximal efficiency" is quite an arbitrary term.

True. We're getting close, though AI-assisted programming still needs human direction for complex projects and AI-assisted mathematics has trouble creating totally novel ideas. But yes, it's close and a miserable situation to be in.
Don't worry - AI regulations are coming soon.

A major point will be complete training-data transparency with independent expert review. In EU a statutory ban on collecting/storing/using users' data for training (including the "de-identified data" loophole), except voluntary explicit opt-in.

I wonder if a mandatory disclosure of training recipes paragraph will be included, likely in EU only (e.g. with tiered-access design to counter trade-secret objections) ?

We are already there, and yes, it often feels inhumane.