Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
I'd hate to be OpenAI and Anthropic. They are better than the rest of the available models currently, but only by a few months.

That is a very tenuous lead and doesn't speak to much of a sustainable competitive moat for either company. The have to keep sprinting as fast as possible on the hamster wheel to just stay ahead.

Claude has pushed hard on productization. Day to day I use codex for everything, I went to watch my wife use Claude and the way it works is so different. I was shocked when she was modifying an artifact through the Claude website and it was able to make changes to a local file on her desktop.

Microsoft didn't win spreadsheets by having the most advanced or releasing the most often. They made a really good, easy to use product, and got it in front of everyone. (Though Office's p-code was a huge advantage to portability)

loading story #50539821
loading story #50540543
loading story #50541874
loading story #50537607
loading story #50539271
loading story #50539265
The worst thing for them would be if someone made reasonably priced hardware that could run the ‘near enough’ models like kimi or glm 5.3 or whatever the equivalent is in the future that the home user could buy.

I think it’s inevitable. Hardware manufacturing will ramp up to meet a demand and the demand from consumers is there. The big providers can’t monopolize a commodity forever.

The biggest hope is HBF (high bandwidth flash) which has the bandwidth of HBM with the density of flash. It has much more latency but when you’re repeatedly pumping weights through a compute unit it’s not a blocker.

loading story #50540431
> I'd hate to be OpenAI and Anthropic. They are better than the rest of the available models currently, but only by a few months.

I sort of agree with you on Claude, but I've recently started using gpt-sol 6.1 and it took me a lot more iteration to get what I want than with Claude.Admittedly I was using Claude code and gpt with pi, but if the difference is the agent, then the situation is even more dire for open ai and anthropic. Today I looked at some code that got generated and it's an absolute Horrorshow. It's just some quick prototyping, but the code structure is a horrible mess.

I ended up pointing my local Qwen 3.8 FN (Halogen on Ryzen 395) to the code and it was solving a bunch of basic issues that gpt introduced to the code. And I feel it's running faster as well.

All that to say, I now feel that openai (sol at least), is worse at coding tasks then a local 180B parameter model (while Claude seems still ahead, but I'm unsure how much of that is the framework). They really are falling behind.

I had similar issues with verbosity when comparing astra + pi with claude + claude code.
I think Google and Microsoft have the benefit of time as you say, and already being profitable without AI.

Honestly, this line up is impressive, I wanted to try MAI since v1 came out, but Microsoft locked down Copilot subscriptions. If they gave me a comparable plan to Claude Max I'd consider it.

loading story #50539296
I would counter argue with "But chinese models use distillation of Frontiermodels..." which is different than being a Frontierlab or not clear how different it is.

But Microsoft coming from the side like this might be very different if it holds up.

loading story #50537174
loading story #50539259
Even if OpenAI/Anthropic remain "a few months" ahead of open weight models indefinitely that still is not great news for them.
loading story #50537791
loading story #50537854
loading story #50548791
loading story #50548545
Openai and Anthropic are better at making models easily available too. Both Google and Microsoft are using promotional pricing to push their models and that should tell you how far they are from actually competing.

Also model availability is not easy. Google newest models are unavailable on some pro accounts and perform best only with Antigravity. Trying to plug it in some other harness and its terrible. If you try to connect your subscription with Hermes etc you might get banned.

Microsoft models are hidden away in Azure.

So every time I read Google/MS announcements I just shrug. If I want to use models like these I might as well get DeepSeek on Openrouter instead.

I disagree, I think distillation hides the true technical advantage since you can always get within X% of Claude by ex: training on newly created code on Github, but the underlying intelligence is harder to replicate.
based on the behavior of the chinese labs it seems like training on chain-of-thought is extremely important for distillation, and you can't get that by training on llm generated text.
{"deleted":true,"id":50539031,"parent":50536908,"time":1794953789,"type":"comment"}
They’ve been ahead of the pack by 3-6 months for years now. I doubt that’s sustainable in the long term, but it’s apparently sustainable on the order of a few years.
> They are better than the rest of the available models currently, but only by a few months.

I think only google is catching up, and others plateaued.

Are they ahead in any way that matters? I've never run into something DeepSeek can't do
the gap is bigger than you think and widens on niche tasks
Why would you hate and why would anybody care?

Time and time again it's been clear that LLMs are commodities with no winners. You'll jump where wallet and performance in your applications will bring you.

Not when new models substantially increase productivity.
brand trust is real, infra is real - moat.
Anti distillation efforts have greatly increased the difference between open and closed models
If these benchmarks can hold up in real life, we are seeing again and again an intelligence explosion in front of our eyes and devaluation of intelligence.

Anyone has more background how they were able to catch up that fast? Distillation of GPT due to their OpenAI acess to the model might make most sense but they probably are not allowed to do that.

It seems they trained from scratch: https://microsoft.ai/news/frontier-pre-training-at-microsoft...
Owning the iron has got to be a massive advantage. It's interesting that the advantage has so far been pretty theoretical, but based on these benchmarks, it may be starting to pay off. It has to be hard to hire in the talent to train these models (even if you're Microsoft) when you're competing with established labs.
Holiday season is going to be a little bit crazy.
TBH, DeepSWE 1.1 has been busted for a while (is anyone out there arguing Gemini 3.8 Flash is as good as Astra lol?), and TB2.1 as a top line when they are currently at 4 (which is substantially harder) and FrontierCode at 1.1 when it's currently at 2.0 does not bring a lot of confidence.

Of course I always want to see more competition in this space, though!

{"deleted":true,"id":50539027,"parent":50538426,"time":1794953775,"type":"comment"}
[flagged]
The phrase was coined in 1965 by Irving John Good, in his essay "Speculations Concerning the First Ultraintelligent Machine":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I._J._Good#Research_and_public...

You should take a trip to the Bay Area dude. You’d hear that phrase as a taco stand.
Would I hear it as a human?
loading story #50540776
Intelligence is a commodity now dood, ai revolution in the ai age
People who need more readily available, low cost intelligence.

AKA anyone building software and getting paid to do so.

what is your problem with this?

LLMs are AI, getting better and cheaper models gives us more AI so its an explosion of intelligence.

Google it and you see i'm not the only one calling it.

Here have a research paper if it helps your ego?! https://arxiv.org/html/2603.20639v1

Not about ego friendo, this is about humans forgetting how to talk like humans.
Dude i'm not your 'friendo' and you are disrespectful.

Geoffrey Hinton, the father of AI literlay co-authored this paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.36054 "What if automating AI R&D triggers an intelligence explosion?"

loading story #50537600
> this is about humans forgetting how to talk like humans.

Most people would prefer talking to an LLM than one who says "friendo".

Just saying.

Github Copilot offered MAI Code 2 at 50% today.

I switched it to that model and it was able to resolve tricky python build issues within Windows WSL/ubuntu and also generated a good number of test cases and ensured all of them pass.

It resolved all the Azure deploy (bicep) issues as well. Didn't feel the difference from Claude Opus.

> MAI Code 2 delivers 98% of GPT-6.1 Sol’s performance at 40% of the cost, and 96% of Claude Opus 5.5’s at 5%

Interesting. Does this imply it's a smaller model specialized for coding?

I remember OpenAI was experimenting with that back in the day but they ditched it for the One Model to Rule Them All strategy before long.

---

On a related note, how is Sol ten times cheaper than Opus in these graphs? I know MS has a share in OpenAI, are they cherry picking those numbers?

Edit: It's about the same ratio on AA. That's nuts.

The per-token price difference is exactly 2x (on all fronts incl. caching, though I'm assuming the caching mechanisms differ). I guess Sol uses way fewer tokens then. (About 4x according to AA. Math checks out.)

Does anyone use both Claude and Codex and can compare what that's like in practice?

loading story #50540620
loading story #50542115
loading story #50539168
We just cancelled our Github Copilot subscription.

It was hard to even justify the 19,- dollar tier. All it gave us was some credits (at API prices) which most people burned through in days, some in hours, code reviews (that we couldn't customize) and another service to manage. Having AI integrated in Github is a decent idea but just like Microsoft Copilot, it's just not good enough at the moment.

These two models might help, I will definitely give it a try but while they're cheap they still do not compare to what feels like nearly unlimited usage offered by Claude Code and Codex (if you stick to the lower tier models).

I think they won't help if they're billed at the announced rate on your Copilot quota. Microsoft would need to do something like Devin does and offer its own models with separate limits.
loading story #50538684
There's zero reason why these must be tied to a proprietary model & api. It should just be a matter of adding an openapi compatible endpoint, and an api key. It's even worse that gitlab is also tying ai integration to paid enterprise licenses
The entire point of gh copilot right now is model from all providers with ZDR already setup. If you don’t care about ZDR then no point in using it
Sure, but so is practically every other provider. Codex and Claude have it enabled by default as well.

In Openrouter/OpenCode it's a switch in the settings, might even be on by default.

Isn’t Copilot Code Review using OpenAI’s models? As in, if it’s currently not good enough, these two new models are unlikely to make any impact?
loading story #50542790
I really hope they keep writing technical reports even as their models get better.

MAI-Thinking-1 is far more in depth than anything else recent I could find, and very valuable to those outside the labs.

Yeah, I was disappointed not to see a technical report linked.
skeptical but I like they went for it and put the benchmarks against the top stuff.
loading story #50536951
loading story #50536992
Has anyone actually had good experiences with this model? I tried it twice at work today and both times it was just spinning for 20+ minutes on the most basic prompts, never producing any output at all. "Preparing..." and "Evaluating...".
What are the foundations of these models? Are they Microsoft's own or an RL of some open models?
They are comparing to Sol 6.1's API prices. With Sol 6.2, and especially if you consider subsidization from Codex subscriptions, it's probably no longer on the Pareto frontier.
Is it not available via API?
loading story #50542642
I wish they would've talked more about the visual coding. The fact that the visuals this produces is preferable to 6.1 Sol over 60% of the time is heartening, but I would've loved to see them go against Opus 5.5 which as far as I can tell is the king for UIs at this price point.
I don't put much weight on launch benchmarks for coding models anymore. I think most of us use OpenAI and Anthropic models anyway. These models will catch up sometime with the OpenAI and Anthropic and maybe then there could be a difference where we could actually reply on. For example, if we consider image generation, nano banana was better and so were image models like Qwen and Flux which provide same if not sometimes better outputs.
Whatever happened to the Microsoft Phi series?

I felt that the training data and behaviours for this at the time were very OpenAI like, due to responses similar in structure to ChatGPT (like how ChatGPT now usually has a section at the end "Why this matters")

loading story #50542620
Very cool to see these new contenders. Does anyone know how it compares in terms or performance to pricing ratio compared to deepseek flash 1017?
Seems pretty good for coding, which these days just means there isn't any meaningful difference from the SOTA for the average use case.
The claimed 20% the cost suggests that the models are 20% the size. Which means these models are flying in the face of an orthodoxy that says the only way to make a model better at coding is to make it better at everything. I think this coming year is when we'll see that orthodoxy fall, as people realize you can make a model better at coding by making it better at coding.
loading story #50537434
loading story #50537101
loading story #50537413
Probably would be a good time to rename it “Mai” (like the name) instead of the corporate “MAI” if they’re gonna be serious players. I don’t think any research has really been done into this, but in my anecdotal usage a coherent persona seems to help the models achieve more. Even Qwen seems to perform better when I talk to it as Qwen instead of generically.
loading story #50541052
loading story #50541668
loading story #50538474
loading story #50538394
loading story #50539767
I hope Anthropic goes bankrupt eventually for trying to regulate open-weight models out of existence. Absolutely disgusting. I honestly never thought I’d hate someone more than Altman and Zuckerberg but nowadays I wish Amodei that his IPO flops!
I know that this comment will fall on deaf ears here on HN, but the reason Amodei doesn’t like open-source is because he’s worried that as intelligence scales, people will be able to use future abliterated open source models to perform large scale hacking or bioterrorism. In my mind, this is a perfectly reasonable concern, and frankly I’m very worried about a future where someone can abliterate GLM 7 or whatever and then just have a swarm of world class hackers they can point at anything or anyone.

You can disagree with him, but Amodei and most of Anthropic are true believers in superintelligence and what that will mean for humanity. Everything they do makes way more sense if you look at their behavior through the lens of being genuinely concerned about AI safety.

I don't see any mention of the phi models on microsoft.ai. Have they given up on it? It was one of the only local models that could work quickly on my consumer hardware.
Alright, I'm going to say it. Microsoft, if your model's so good, can it make a genuinely good version of Windows for people who don't want all the garbage you include with Windows? Not asking to be a jerk, hoping to bait Microsoft into making Windows suck less.

Asking for everybody else who wishes Windows would return to its better days. :)

All that said, this is a very impressive line up they released today.

loading story #50541713
loading story #50549575
The promotional period lasts until May 2027. Why not just make the price lower if they'll be irrelevant by the time the "real" price kicks in?
One idea: in six months they want the compute capacity for a new thing. That time they could nerf the current models (much like people accuse Anthropic of doing), or eat the extra expenses, or apply this preannounced price hike. Seems... neat to me.
Somehow they still show Terminal Bench 2.1 as a benchmark, doesn't look good for them.
Yikes, oAI included spreadsheet and slide examples on their launch today and microsoft didn't?
loading story #50537967
Confusing. You think the people who let you rent GPUs would just give you the weights, platform, and inference code - to make it as easy as possible to run it on their platform where they can bill you for ingress/egress, etc.
It is interesting to see M$ trying to compete on price, in the most half-hearted way possible. There is a huge opportunity for a hyperscaler to offer competitive models at prices that actually compete with Luna. Google has left the field with their desire to raise prices so it is either OAI Luna or open weight models offered by neoclouds/neo-inference-providers.
Muse Ember is there too.
What annoys me a lot about MSFT releases are, that is not possible to find how to use these models and where to try them.

I didn't hear anyone in my circle using MAI models, none.

Because even on this blog post, they are talking about pricing, but there is no Pricing page on that website, neither way to create API keys, nor playground.

With this success, I can also say, I am releasing a model which costs 0.0001$ / input/output MTok with 100x cheaper cache read and write which is on part with Opus 5.5. (its your problem to find that model)

>I didn't hear anyone in my circle using MAI models, none.

I'm using MAI-Transcribe 2 via OpenRouter for captions generation: cheap, supports a lot of languages and I see great results

They're on OpenRouter, I think. And on the GitHub Copilot CLI, and I am reasonably sure you can pop over to Azure and provision an endpoint in a few hours (depending on region, I've been using it for a bit)
True. With all the criticism against Google, they at least offer the Google AI studio for Gemini models.

I haven't seen anything equivalent from Microsoft.

loading story #50538787
It's right on the page at the bottom:

"Get started

MAI Code 2 and Code 2 Flash are available in GitHub Copilot, and Code 2 Flash is in limited-access preview in Microsoft Foundry. Soon, we’ll be releasing it on Open Router, Vercel, Hermes, Open Code, and Kilo.

Learn more about customizing MAI Code 2 on our Custom Models page."

Did they finally give up on the Copilot branding? If so, good riddance. They were shoving it down our throats.
loading story #50537060
loading story #50536889
Since it's from Microsoft, I wonder if there's any chance of it not sucking ass at F# like most of the models I use.
Microsoft announces MAI Code on a vibe-coded Claude website. At this point they just openly mock us.
loading story #50536537
loading story #50538081
Oh so MAI Code is a model? What would they call the harness MAI Code Code?
This trend of American models only comparing to other American models is pretty interesting.
{"dead":true,"deleted":true,"id":50536394,"parent":50535885,"time":1794941837,"type":"comment"}
Concerning, as they might persuade an average enterprise to stop paying for proper Anthropic models and switch to them instead for cost saving...
loading story #50536507
loading story #50537111
loading story #50536356
"Concerning" for who? Anthropic? Consumers should be encouraging efforts to bring down costs
loading story #50536306
Deprecated within minutes - we're on 6.2 now. Nice try though Microsoft, keep it up.
Can someone explain to me why the headings use serif while the body uses sans (font)?
loading story #50537504
loading story #50536433
loading story #50536458
loading story #50536407