Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
I'm glad that this is bringing attention to flicker sensitivity.

Here are some other things that people are sensitive to: - CRI on white LEDs (and flourencents). CRI is how clean the spectrum is in comparison to the sun or a incandescent bulb, where the specturm is completely even. There are some CRI >=95 LEDs that are fine for most people however.

- Motion blur Motion blur on LCDs (such as ~50% of Nintendo Switch 2s) can hurt eyes trying to keep track of what is going on.

Also flicker on bad LED lighting. A lot of bad LED lighting flickers at ~60Hz. In rooms lit by that, you can wave your hand or a thin object back and forth, and if you look carefully, you can perceive a "shutter" effect where you're only seeing the snapshots of its position where the light is on.

The thing that makes that so insidious is that not everybody can easily perceive that.

(The reason why such flicker is common in cheap LED bulbs: they turn AC into DC using a half-wave rectifier, which just chops off half the AC wave. This is also why you can still see the effect in rooms lit by multiple lights, because the flicker is in sync, synchronized to the incoming AC.)

If you are building a space for other people and you are responsible for the lighting, please check for this. If you can't perceive it yourself, find someone who can.

> If you can't perceive it yourself, find someone who can.

Or just use your phone’s slo-mo feature to take a 240 FPS video (which then gets played back at 30 FPS). 60 Hz flicker becomes extremely visible. More than once I’ve noticed the strobe effect and then confirmed it this way.

That's a really good idea, thank you.
Not everybody can see this, but, if you want to help someone see PWM sources, choose a single color (e.g., red, largely in case the primaries are time separated), make a simple dot or line, and wave it around in the peripheral vision of your doubter.

Humans are very sensitive to flicker in peripheral vision. Have them look at something across the room and then blow their mind.

(Note: easier with a phone, but doable with a laptop.)

When I've had a coffee too much, I notice the 120 Hz flicker even more. But even when I'm tired and don't, my mood still noticeably increases when I leave flickery spaces. (I sometimes test my hunch with the slow-motion cam as I am leaving.) I've tried looking for studies to prove or disprove my experience. They should be easy to find, right? Humanity is replacing the entire planet's lighting with LEDs after all! Comment sections have been busy with people arguing about PWM flicker for years, probably longer. What is the best study you can find? For me, it is always the one from 1989 about pre-LED 60 Hz office lighting (that said it had adverse effects). Seriously...?

I wish I was a Bitcoin billionaire, for many reasons, but doing another study on flickery LED lighting seems like the lowest-hanging fruit of our entire civilization. I live in a country that is regulated to hell and back, and yet even our street lights flicker visibly, not to mention classrooms, children's bedrooms, and the screens that people stare at for hours every day. I don't get it.

loading story #50523266
> In rooms lit by that, you can wave your hand or a thin object back and forth, and if you look carefully, you can perceive a "shutter" effect where you're only seeing the snapshots of its position where the light is on.

Heh, this is how I test these lamps as well. Also my camera has anti-flicker shutter which can detect it to thwart it by syncing the shutter release with flicker itself. It shows a warning when it detects is, as well.

> Also my camera has anti-flicker shutter which can detect it to thwart it by syncing the shutter release with flicker itself. It shows a warning when it detects is, as well.

Nice! Which cameras do this? And I wonder, how cheaply could a sensor be made to do this, that shows on the screen "there's flicker at 60Hz / 120Hz / 480Hz", if it didn't also need to be a great camera (e.g. it only captured at 480p)?

loading story #50508878
Yes I can perceive that really well, I don't even need to wave my hand for it.
60Hz flicker is rare. Most cheap/driverless LEDs are full-wave rectified or at least alternate half-wave pixels and thus flicker at twice the mains frequency, giving 120Hz in the US.
loading story #50512643
Fair enough. 120Hz is really noticeable as well, though, with the same test (wave your hand or a thin object).
Americans being Americans. Most of the world operates on 50Hz electricity, which would result in a different flicker. Consequently, when travelling to another continent, it is worth checking camera settings and adjusting them to the local frequency.

Again: the USA is large, but other countries (usually with different systems) do exist.

There are tools that will report the flicker level of lights. Or a basic test that often works is pointing your phone camera at a light, close up, sometimes will show the flicker, or using the slow-mo setting on the camera.
{"deleted":true,"id":50508763,"parent":50508453,"time":1794763639,"type":"comment"}
{"deleted":true,"id":50511279,"parent":50508453,"time":1794779938,"type":"comment"}
The power supply is the weak point in LED room lighting. The best power supply for LEDs is switch-mode PWM, high frequency, and with thermal management designed by an engineer who understands therodynamics.

Unfortunately all those things are expensive so you rarely find such bulbs in the cheap bin at Home Depot.

loading story #50509008
It's very unfortunate that our electric codes are based primarily on incandescent lighting. If we were designing electricity from scratch, we'd probably be set up with 240v 3 phase AC for big loads (ovens, heaters etc) and 48v DC for lighting and most electronics. Requiring every device to have its own rectifier is a lot less efficient than putting a single good rectifier in a central location.
> Requiring every device to have its own rectifier is a lot less efficient than putting a single good rectifier in a central location.

Is it, though?

You'd have to deal with additional wiring losses due to the lower voltage between the central rectifier and the devices, and the various individual devices would still need their own step-down converters to turn that 48VDC into something they can actually use.

On top of that: the central rectifier would have to be sized for peak load, while in reality the vast majority of the time it would be running at only a fraction of that. That's not exactly ideal for efficient operation. Individual power supplies can be designed specifically for a single device and operate at its sweet spot most of the time.

loading story #50511504
DC mains, even at low voltage (which also means a higher current capability for the same amount of power, and thus thicker cables and/or higher resistive loss), is more dangerous than AC because it doesn't stop flowing; AC goes to 0 twice a cycle, so arcs have a chance to extinguish. DC switchgear needs special provisions for breaking arcs, such as "blowout coils".

Some early electrical installations, as in late 19th/early 20th century, used DC. Most have disappeared, with the exception of some surviving early elevators and perhaps some huge industrial motors, converted to running from a rectifier.

loading story #50517620
loading story #50517102
DC doesn't buy you that much for electronics. You still need to do DC-DC conversion to 12V or 5/3V for the electronics itself.

And to avoid ground loops, you also need fully isolated DC-DC converters. So you end up with the same power supply architecture as for AC-DC, saving only on buffer capacitors.

As an experiment, I converted my homelab to 48V DC to operate from the battery directly after my attempts at making a UPS failed. It works, but it's barely more efficient than doing a double-conversion.

I'm now redoing lighting in my house, and _there_ the DC power makes a lot of sense. I'm planning to use commercial-grade DALI, with tunable white setpoint. It uses true DC dimming, so there's no flicker whatsoever.

Manufacturers are selling DC bulb systems these days. Unfortunately, the ones I've seen sell the accompanying rectifiers (which need maybe $50-100 of power electronics inside) for multiple thousands of dollars, and they're DRM locked to the more expensive bulbs by proprietary protocols.

I find the inefficiencies of the old system more manageable.

Fine. So we've got serious 3-phase for big loads, and 48VDC for everything else.

Which circuit does the blender connect to, or the kettle? The air fryer? The coffee machine?

How do I power a space heater to warm up a chilly room for the baby on a particularly cold and windy night?

Where does the window air conditioner connect that I need because my landlord is cheap and there's an intolerable heatwave?

The audio system? The guitar amp? The gaming rig? The vacuum cleaner?

I guess we plug that stuff into 3-phase outlets, which we'll need to have everywhere -- right? Fine.

---

So we've got other stuff, too, that's a little lighter. Phones, laptops. Lights. Stuff. That can all be made to convert 48VDC down to whatever it needs internally, but that conversion requires electronics that are local to the device. We haven't eliminated that at all.

But sure: It runs on 48VDC that is sourced from some manner of manner of central power supply. Neat, I guess?

---

But why?

It sounds like all we've really accomplished here is adding more wires, and more complexity.

I'm struggling to figure out how any of this is presents any meaningful advantage.

(Oh, I know! Let's keep our existing single-phase circuits, and add both 3-phase AC and 48VDC! Whooo boy! Now we've got a real clustefuck cookin'!)

> Which circuit does the blender connect to, or the kettle? The air fryer? The coffee machine?

3-phase.

> How do I power a space heater to warm up a chilly room for the baby on a particularly cold and windy night?

3-phase, and it's not obvious why you need the additional extraneous detail to explain why you want a space heater.

> Where does the window air conditioner connect that I need because my landlord is cheap and there's an intolerable heatwave?

3-phase, and again, it's not obvious why you need the additional extraneous detail.

> The audio system? The guitar amp?

DC, and DC.

> The gaming rig?

DC or 3-phase, depends on how much power it needs. Worth noting that some PC power supplies already draw more power than most 120V circuits should be carrying. (1500W is the commonly cited limit, and there are gaming rigs with larger power supplies than that.)

> The vacuum cleaner?

Depends on how much power it needs, and whether it's recharging a battery or running a powerful motor directly.

> So we've got other stuff, too, that's a little lighter. Phones, laptops. Lights. Stuff. That can all be made to convert 48VDC down to whatever it needs internally, but that conversion requires electronics that are local to the device. We haven't eliminated that at all.

DC-to-DC can be substantially simpler and more efficient.

loading story #50516830
loading story #50511175
reading the sibling comments in this thread show how complicated we’ve collectively made it to buy something as stupid as a lightbulb.
loading story #50508095
loading story #50508540
On the other end is motion stutter on OLEDs. Because of sample-and-hold, the blur goes away but the image stutters on slow moving scenes instead. If your eyes are sensitive to PWM (mine are) it's quite annoying to watch OLED movement as well.
Is that what I'm seeing on my LG C series? Every so often when I'm watching streaming video, and the scene changes, the action seems to skip frames for maybe a quarter of a second. It happens rarely enough that I haven't narrowed it down to the TV, the attached Chromecast, the streaming app, or the content.

The only setting I recall changing on the TV is the one that stops the soap-opera effect.

loading story #50508787
loading story #50510702
I think you're seeing telecine judder. The video's framerate doesn't find the diplay's refresh rate, and the TV doesn't handle it well. This is why my old Pioreer Kuro switched to 48hz on 24fps content, and it was amazing.

OLED sample-and-hold causes blur.

loading story #50512258
This os fairly fixable with post processing in your video player. For non video things, it goes away at higher framerates.
Yes but then you introduce a soap opera effect. There's no silver bullet outside of BFI but that also causes flicker.
I was building a lego set with my son several years ago and at some point (after the sun went down) realized I could no longer distinguish between the green and grey pieces, though it had been obvious under natural light. It was a striking demonstration of CRI.
loading story #50512628
loading story #50509067
Color rendering with LEDs is so terrible. And buying proper lights is either close to illegal (e.g. halogens) for efficiency reasons, or high quality LEDs are almost impossible to buy - "call us for quote" and similar nonsense.

The absolutely worst were the default indoor lights in Australia. There must have been some giant shipment of worst possible lights that they purchased to light up every bathroom in the country.

This world wide transition to cheap LEDs stole a lot of joy from the world.

loading story #50509811
loading story #50508123