Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit

Google Search is now less than half of Alphabet’s revenue

https://www.kadoa.com/companies/insights/google-search-below-half
I get what they're trying to say, but it still seems a bit unconventional to have a line chart where the y-axis is a share percentage.

Here's a graph with revenue in dollars by segment:

https://www.pasteboard.co/DwvXdQj2LXpk.png

This graph invites some pertinent questions. For instance, it suggests that their search revenue growth went linear sometime in 2020 and might be going asymptotic as of the last year. So I want to know what happens there over the next several quarters. Is the current quarter anomalous, or do deferred payments always make it look like that?

Second, is the geometric growth of Cloud cannibalizing their search teams, leading to less effort being put into sales. And so it’s not so much that demand is tapering off as that supply is being constrained as an opportunity cost. That $1m in salary nets more profit from Cloud than from Search.

As a power user of Google search for decades, I find myself using it less and less (maybe now 5% of my historical peak usage). There are several reasons, but the main one is because they have gradually traded search quality for ad revenue with the direct consequence being wasting my time.

If I type in the name of a company so that I can navigate to their website, and I have to scroll past my whole viewport of other companies bidding to be placed above where I'm trying to go, I learn it's faster for me to just type the website address into the bar instead of going via Google.

They designed a UX that made my life easier and caused me to form a habit, and then broke that UX for money causing me to form a new habit.

It's just one example of dozens, but the consequence is that I see 95% fewer Google ads than I used to. My guess I am on the leading edge (along with many others on this forum) of a wave of change of user behavior that spells pessimism for Google search revenue.

loading story #50296209
loading story #50293898
loading story #50294020
loading story #50293687
loading story #50293468
loading story #50293919
loading story #50294026
loading story #50293617
loading story #50293922
Everyone already uses Google, so every quarter the revenue goes up it's definitely not because of a higher market share...

Why does it even need to keep going up anyway? Is 60 billion not enough?

Depends if you invest and want your investment to grow
loading story #50295831
loading story #50297680
loading story #50293883
Somewhat impressive that search share of revenue is 5% down, but search revenue is 12% up..
loading story #50292553
loading story #50293151
loading story #50292416
loading story #50292757
loading story #50298020
A few days ago a Google found me something I was searching for, but via ads and not search. In the middle of searching raw part numbers, the ad became 100% relevant. It was a weird experience clicking on the ad; something I never ever do. So maybe this is a bit of good news? Yardinflatables.com if you're curious.
loading story #50293323
loading story #50293277
loading story #50293450
loading story #50293299
loading story #50293315
loading story #50293451
I'm wondering who published "Attention is All You Need" and brought this devastation to Google... Oh I remember, it was Google.
loading story #50293368
loading story #50293496
loading story #50293475
loading story #50293381
loading story #50293347
am i remembering correctly that "google cloud" in the earnings isn't just developer's google cloud bills (that's google cloud platform), it's also basically any product where a consumer or enterprise pays money to google for anything other than advertising - google drive storage, gemini pro, enterprise google workspace plans...
loading story #50292371
loading story #50292243
loading story #50292186
loading story #50292658
loading story #50292183
loading story #50293528
Isn't this good news because they're diversifying their streams?
loading story #50293289
loading story #50292115
loading story #50293268
loading story #50292821
loading story #50293929
loading story #50294147
So if I understand it, search numbers are down (because AI is doing what Sam Altman originally saw - AI is a better search engine)

And Google knows it, so why not squeeze the current customers, whatever model AI takes it’s unlikely to be a word matching auction, this model is dead, grab the cash and go.

loading story #50293223
loading story #50293123
loading story #50293244
loading story #50293250
loading story #50293215
loading story #50293130
loading story #50293218
loading story #50293217
loading story #50293994
Pretty remarkable (in the age of AI) that search/ad revenue actually grew 12%. Anyone have a rational explanation why is that the case?
loading story #50292623
loading story #50292889
loading story #50292485
loading story #50292592
loading story #50293805
loading story #50294924
loading story #50296070
loading story #50293565
loading story #50295711
loading story #50295635
loading story #50294232
loading story #50293411
loading story #50294103
loading story #50294974
loading story #50294004
Where is AI in this?

Search was $63.4B "Everything else" was $64.2B, out of which GCP was $30.7B

Is AI on the 33.5B remaining post GCP? or within the 30.7 of GCP?

loading story #50292663
Google cloud could've been more if they didn't drop the ball.
loading story #50293742
How would you expect search forecasts to be met if most of the time you get "are you a robot" or clanker summaries if you are lucky.

Search no longer works and you are killing your most important product with AI that nobody wants. If search worked like in 2010, no one would use AI answers.

loading story #50293522
So do you think this will be the continue trends of Google's search engine will be less portion of the company's revenue?
Cloud computing is really a money printer right now. Amazon makes more from AWS than from their retail business, it's nearly 2/3rds of their profit.
loading story #50292501
loading story #50292388
loading story #50294186
This has been the plan for a long time.

I remember 10 years ago that Google was extremely paranoid about having the whole company propped up on one revenue tent-pole.

Related:

Alphabet Announces Third Quarter 2026 Results [pdf]

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50280197

Great, now they won't mind so much when we break Search out of Alphabet, because it's a monopoly... :D
loading story #50292290
loading story #50292474
Gemini is terrible, it's trash especially after downgrading to the free version. I have to prompt it two to three times for it to understand what I am asking it. It seemed better when I was paying for it while it's free competitor models (the other 4) always answer me right away.
loading story #50292468
loading story #50292425
loading story #50294269
loading story #50295659