Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
officialchicken | on: ESP32 Bit Pirate, a Hardware Hacking Tool with WebCLI That Speaks Every Protocol
I have an old v3.6 from Dangerous Prototypes that I still frequently use and works fine with a coding assistant over serial terminal for doing some wire-level debugging of firmware. I am definitely not interested in paying the Pi tax for a new one just to get improved scripting. The roughly $100 BP v6 price point means looking into a other analyzers is required. How does this ESP firmware really compare - can anyone who's used both say what's different other than wireless?
geotp | parent | next
The two projects have fairly different directions, even though they overlap on most core wired protocol features.

The original Bus Pirate relies heavily on a more complex bytecode-style syntax for many lowlevel operations. The ESP32 version replaces most of that with simple, explicit commands that perform the same tasks through a more straightforward workflow

The ESP32 version also avoids flag heavy commands and uses interactive shells where appropriate. Its main additional strength is radio support not present on the original Bus Pirate, including WiFi, RFID/NFC, SubGHz, NRF24, FM, infrared, and Bluetooth.

It can also be controlled through the Web CLI from any phone, tablet, or device with a web browser, using integrated AI assistant to help with hardware task.

So it is not simply a cheaper Bus Pirate v6 clone

rigonkulous | root | parent | next
One thing in BP v6's favor is the RP2350 - which can be put into operation as a "data-cap analyser for GPIO" - true - but it can also be programmed for use as a full protocol tap for embedded projects which will also integrate the RP2350, or something like it, in an embedded design.

The ESP32 is great - I will get a couple for my toolbox, sitting alongside my own ancient Bus Pirate and things - but the RP2350 is a bit more BOM-friendly, imho. All of these things can be used to bring-up an embedded system - I'd really want to use the BP v6 to bring up an embedded system with an IO package I could emulate/integrate with the RP2350 on both sides of the design ..

officialchicken | root | parent
Due to this obviously AI-generated response (thus codebase) - I'll pass.
geotp | root | parent
I’m French and my English isn’t very good, so please excuse me for using a translator. Feel free to take a look at the codebase
officialchicken | root | parent
Ok! Sorry, the translation is kinda rough and seems rigid and robotic.
loading story #48412034