Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
If engineering isn't near the factory, it's not as effective.

Here's one of the most generic electronic components - a 1K resistor.[1] These sell for about US$0.0015 each. DigiKey has a list of many suppliers.

There are a few old-line US resistor makers in there, including Bourns and Ohmite. They're price competitive with Chinese companies. But when you look up their engineering job locations, none are in the US or UK.[2] Plants are in Mexico, Malaysia, Taiwan, and Hungary.

To get prices down, engineers have to be very familiar with what goes on in manufacturing. If you separate engineering from manufacturing, you get overpriced designs.

Not that many people who went to a good engineering school in a first-world country today want to spend their lives inside a big factory in a low-wage country. But that's what it takes to make stuff.

[1] https://www.digikey.com/en/products/filter/chip-resistor-sur...

[2] https://jobs.bourns.com/go/Engineering/9254400/

Being an engineer means mastering your production tool. For everything to do with physical production, you need to be close to the means of production to gather essential information on quality, capacity, operator feedback (machine and quality operators are invaluable sources of information.), etc.

Most information is not digital or hardly digitizable.

I don't completely agree with the article's classification of ARM as a hardware company. ARM produces VHDL and resells licenses, but does not produce any chips. It's closer to a software company than a TSMC.

I'd go one further and say you have to be at least a journeyman in whatever tools your process is using.

The difference between someone designing a part in cad and someone designing the tool paths for the machine that makes the part in cam is night and day.

loading story #42772228
loading story #42770172
loading story #42768414
loading story #42770828
Totally anecdotal but to your point, the engineering jobs in my hometown followed the manufacturing jobs in leaving town in the 1990s after NAFTA.

Engineering seems to be returning as domestic manufacturing increases thanks to foreign auto companies setting up shop across the state, replacing what the US companies left behind.

> spend their lives inside a big factory in a low-wage country

Some gladly would if paid handsomely by the local standards, that is, adequately by the US standards.

The bigger problem is raising children away from your native culture.

loading story #42767582
loading story #42765699
There are plenty of industries where product engineering is done at a different company or place than product manufacturing.

For example, consumer electronics, industrial machines and robotics, telecom and medical devices.

loading story #42767946
Taiwan is kinda nice though? And just a short hop to Japan for holidays or even long weekends.
loading story #42772438
loading story #42771451
Very weird comment. Article talks about hardware talent in UK. Your comment tries to prove "engineering jobs" are not in the US by providing the job listing of a single supplier, when everybody knows that there are a huge amount of hardware talent in the US working at great companies that deliver amazing products. Your comment seems to equate "manufacturing jobs" to "hardware engineering jobs" which apparently isn't correct.
Many of the legacy component vendors retain domestic US manufacturing to supply military parts. They come with a premium price and aren't usually worth using commercially but that is one of the last backstops preventing all knowledge from disappearing.