Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> Lula da Silva thing, it has been like that under Bolsonaro and his predecessors

Those predecessors were...drumroll...literally Lula (and then Lula's party member Dilma while he was in prison)

Import tax at 60% for individual buyers was created in 1995, by FHC, way before Lula's party ever came to power. In the dictatorship era it was around 50%.

It's always been high.

As much as some people want to deny it Brazil's problems started way before 2002.

> As much as some people want to deny it Brazil's problems started way before 2002.

I mean absolutely. Brazil is and was a developing country.

The correct framing is not "why has Brazil gotten so bad" (incorrect premise) but rather "why has Brazil failed to get better while others proved it was possible"

Brazil has definitely gotten better. Maybe not at the rate a handful of other countries managed but it’s been steady progress. All indicators get better decade over decade.

I also challenge the idea that there are many other similar countries that have outpaced Brazil. If you look into it they are countries with very specific advantages, or are countries Brazilians wouldn’t want to live in for many different reasons. Growth and quality of life are different things.

Sometimes people compare it to China and think “if China did it so should we”, but it’s never happened for anyone else except China. No one should compare themselves to China.

Considering the economic model of Brazil it’s impossible for it to do better without severely changing the makeup of society. Only revolutions really manage to do that.

Brazil was never going to grow 10% YoY and fix all its problems, it was just never in the cards. Slow and steady progress is unfortunately the best we can hope for, and not go backwards like some neighboring countries.

> I also challenge the idea that there are many other similar countries that have outpaced Brazil.

What would you even consider a "similar" country?

There are plenty of examples of countries that were poorer and had less resources and did much better than Brazil.

> Considering the economic model of Brazil it’s impossible for it to do better

Your comment is trying to paint an unfalsifiable position, but you do not back that up with anything of substance.

Again, plenty of counter-examples.

Similar in either size, population or development stage at the turn of the century. Nigeria, Egypt, South Africa, Mexico, Indonesia, Pakistan, Argentina, India. Former colonies which are capitalist democracies (or roughly). Are these countries so much better than Brazil today?

I do accept there are tiny countries that have done better.