Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Outdated article post-LLMs, if you are still taking to heart what this article says you are working against the trend.

You don't need any inner working of clojure or any lower language for that matter. It's all available within your reach. Don't let the people who have built an identity over the tools that they have chosen, they can't give you any meaningful advice anymore with what we have as tools.

I'm saying this as someone who has worked with clojure for over a decade. There is no point in gate keeping things anymore. It also means that the point of clojure which is supposed to have a lot of DX built into it , is gone with LLMs.

Software is largely solved now and the only thing that matters now is distribution so start thinking about your product and how to market it.

There was a good Conj 2026 talk on points that can make Clojure a great fit for LLM-driven development, same which make it convenient for humans also.

What tipped the scales for Clojure - Brendan Foote (Clojure/Conj 2026)

https://youtube.com/watch?v=tzzg8CVkl2A

{"deleted":true,"id":50586824,"parent":50586621,"time":1795245344,"type":"comment"}
There are those who are content to have the LLM do their homework and never bother to understand the solution because "it's solved".

But they will be overtaken by those who use the LLM as a sparring partner to form their own understanding and elevate themselves.

I fear we will see a huge disparity between both groups. One ever on the rise while the other is left in the dust.

You forgot the group you clearly belong to: The one that will not adapt to new tools and innovation
I don't think you have any idea what group I belong to.
I don't understand the motivation of these people, frequently seen on HN, who burst into discussions of programming to say that programming is over. Can they really think that the people they rebuke are unaware of the technical developments in the last several years?

They sound defensive and insecure, which I suspect is not the impression they are trying to create.

> Outdated article post-LLMs

Outdated take post-slopocalypse. You still very much need to know how to program and will often get better results writing code yourself, as we have seen from the outages caused by people vibe coding shit.

> if you are still taking to heart what this article says you are working against the trend.

Being trendy is not synonymous with being correct. In this case the trend is stupid and making the profession worse, so one would be well advised to work against it.

> Software is largely solved now

If that were true, we would be getting a deluge of high quality software. Instead we are getting a deluge of crap. Software is by no means solved.

You're absolutely right! It's all in the title really, Clojure can't affect how we think about programming anymore, because we stopped both thinking and programming.
I see you think that using LLM can replace critical thinking and you reject a tool based on that flawed assumption.
Point taken—you're right to push back on that.
I feel sorry for people who feel like they have to give up on thinking about programming. That sounds so boring.
Has nothing to do with LLMs
Even if what you say is true, I prefer to own my intelligence rather than rent it. Whatever makes you happy, though.
Yeah? What have you accomplished and how do you plan on competing with LLMs ?
The question sounds rhetorical and quite offensive, to be honest. But to answer, I've accomplished loads and nothing can take that away from me. I don't plan on "competing" with LLMs, I just don't plan on losing my own intelligence and relying on AI companies for it.
While I agree "LLM" have lowered the barrier to access languages, it is fundamentally just isomorphic plagiarism of around $9Tn worth of FOSS projects.

Much like how GPU were bodged onto the monolithic von Neumann CPU architectures, we may safely assume most "LLM" will be superseded by neuromorphic computing technology sooner of later. =3

Viewing LLMS as compression is flawed because it shouldn't be possible to solve new novel problems. Zipping every single file in existence and then asking Winzip to produce a novel working zip file clearly doesn't work. Clearly LLMs are learning from data it is fed and a lot of what we do before LLMs also involved "plagirism". Even the greatest writers and artists would copy each other to master their styles and extract the dimensions. I think framing LLMs as compression is not only silly it demonstrates a poor understanding of the inner workings of LLMs
Except a statistically salient search context is in proximity to something similar, and manual content curators drop their thumb on the scales weights to boost desirable outcomes in the quantized model.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPZh9BOjkQs&list=PLZHQObOWTQ...

The encoding of the LLM is almost always lossy compression, but we agree it is not real intelligence.

As a sentient turnip, I likely wouldn't understand such things, but do recognize copyright bleed-through when it includes known obscure works. =3

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanical_Turk

loading story #50590862
> Much like how GPU were bodged onto the monolithic von Neumann CPU architectures, we may safely assume most "LLM" will be superseded by neuromorphic computing technology sooner of later. =3

perhaps this is the optimism i need today.