Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Obvious strawman: is "coin flipping tournament" a "random cognitive task?"

There is a century of data and studies that suggest cognitive ability is positively correlated across tasks. Conducting IQ tests for hiring is practically illegal in the US. Leetcode is the closest you get to an IQ test without tripping some laws.

Yes, I changed it to a better metaphor before you wrote your comment. I had originally written "pub quiz", then changed it to "coin flipping contest" to emphasize the stupidity of the task, then changed it back, anticipating the criticism. The argument does not change -- the claim that testing coding trivia is a test of intelligence is a bald assertion.

Please use your intelligence to see the argument I am making, instead of nitpicking the example.

> Conducting IQ tests for hiring is practically illegal in the US. Leetcode is the closest you get to an IQ test without tripping some laws.

No, it isn't. Disparate impact is. Any test that has a disparate impact on a protected class is de facto illegal, but there's case law surrounding IQ tests.

By the way...ironically enough, Griggs v. Duke Power established that any intelligence test must have relevance to the job responsibilities, which sort of blows a hole in your entire theory of the case that this is a "classic fallacy".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griggs_v._Duke_Power_Co.

> the claim that testing coding trivia is a test of intelligence is a bald assertion

I think you have to let this one go. SAT, LSAT, GRE, ASVAB all correlate well with IQ scores. Leetcode should too, after the interviewee does a few weeks of practice (just like all those other tests).

> Leetcode should too, after the interviewee does a few weeks of practice (just like all those other tests).

I mean, you're just making stuff up, but ok.

Not only is it not practically illegal, as the sibling commenter notes, but several household-name corporations openly IQ test candidates. General cognitive testing is presumptively lawful in white collar employment.
Your pivot from "IQ test" in your first sentence to "general cognitive testing" in second is the whole point.

Leetcode is just one step away from that (and much more litigation-proof).

IQ tests are general cognitive tests. If your entire argument is that IQ tests are fine so long as you call them something else, you're not really saying anything.

Leetcode is not a general cognitive test, obviously.

IQ tests are general cognitive tests. The opposite is not necessarily true.

The whole point of the multibillion dollar test industry is to fudge a "noisy" IQ[ish] test and make it look like it won't have disparate impact (validation "studied") and buy you some ass-covering ability.

> Leetcode...

"one step away"

loading story #50570670