Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
The books can be simply alphabetized on the shelves. The computer gives you the titles based on your keyword searches.
I find these comments reductionist and dismissive. The problem of organizing information has so many dimensions, and librarians have spent hundreds of years studying them. For instance, faceted classification systems are somewhat like tagging but where you also need an overarching taxonomy. Getting classifiers who are scattered across space and time to use tags in a consistent way is another issue.
I don’t disagree with you, and sorry if what I said came across as dismissive or reductionist. It’s an incredibly difficult problem and I was more trying to make the point that physical organization and informational categorization are two distinct but intertwined and competing issues. Certainly I'm not arguing that shelves should be done away with (and if I'm at a library, I am likely there to browse). That said, automated retrieval definitely has uses in managing a much larger back catalog/book depository, like at a university, than what could be reasonably fit on browsable shelves.
loading story #50569841
loading story #50569728
Look at how imdb.com organizes movies. You can browse via searches, or via tags. You can read synopses of the movies. You can read the reviews. Even see a preview clip. You can click on related movies.

Now that we have computers, the hundreds of years of study on manual systems is obsolete.

Some libraries use fixed location systems and rely on catalogs otherwise. But browsing is important; search is not a substitute. For some reason the quality of browsing experience nowadays is abysmal. It is like browsing a garbage can.
From TFA: "The research that we did told us that the vast majority of library users are actually there to browse," says Emily O’Neal, a librarian who as technical services manager for Deschutes Public Library...
The stated goal described the article was to make (physical) browsing of books on shelves more fun for library users. Not clear that alphabetical ordering would make for fun browsing.
Alphabetical ordering by author is reasonable in those sub sections. Sometimes you want to find a specific book and then it helps a lot when you have a few full shelves.
How is that an improvement? The article is about discoverability, not organization.