Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
The automated systems can handle when things are working and everything is fine.

Relatively frequently, things get not fine. The computers can do very dangerous things in those situations. Sometime that includes instruments giving bad readings - computer rarely can figure that out - which can cause planes to crash.

Accidents happen when even highly trained, experienced, and specialized pilots are unable to deal with those situations after the computer couldn’t deal with it.

You are missing the giant portion of ‘things got weird/bad, but pilot handled it and it didn’t cause an accident’ which the computer could not handle. Which happens a lot more than you would expect!

And we’re not even dealing with actual adversarial action - like in Europe - where things like GPS jamming are becoming common.

It’s like saying Waymo’s can handle Bay Area city streets when it’s sunny (99.9% of the time), so it’s okay to roll them out nation wide. But never bothering to consider Alaska, Michigan, etc.

Or that they often freak out and require manual intervention even in the Bay Area 1 in 1000 times. Which if millions of people are using them, will be VERY often.

Lets go back to what the original discussion point was: Even if we humans did not solve it, we accept what we currently have as good enough.

My basic statement was "whatever we as human beings do to achieve the quality we have today, is the same thing an AI could do" in sense of we have the exact same issue as RL.

How did pilots learn to fly and apparently are still better than computers? Not by some random magic. Probably due to grown knowledge between humans and experiences.

Why can't AI speedrun this the same way?

Build a virtual world, let one AI build airplanes, the next landing areas and another one challanges. Some form of RL is possible in the virtual simulated world.

Which brings me to my point I made: "With RL it will learn from all misstakes once while with humans after a generation, information might just be gone."

Every single human has to learn it anew. Always right?

What does an AI have to do? It can either retrain itself every single time if it needs to become better, which is not that efficient, but if it can clone itself and become not 1 pilot but 100.000 pilots, than its efficient.

The real numbers seem to be 350k pilots with a renewal of 20k pilots per year.

The initial learning is expensive and unclear still, but as soon as AI hits the Qquality of the avg pilot once, you don't need to teach it anymore so this cost can go away but the normal way still costs you 20k pilots per year. Alone housing 20k people costs you a min $500 = 10 million. And 350k Pilots generate a min of $50k per year (more probably but lets be cautios) that alone are 17 billion in salary cost.

Now do this calculation for every single job, start with the one which is easiest to solve with the best value of number of jobs and a little bit of number of people to train per year.

IF we find a hard ceiling soon, this AI future will not happen as I believe If we don't, we will reach this point one way or the other and in a time frame which is unclear for now

Even if