Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> Another possibility: Anthropic fails to survive the next recession and the companies that did not allow their employees to become dependent on Claude will be the winners.

That seems highly unlikely, given that there are countless open-weights models available.

Its not about whether AI is available, its about whether AI is actually effective if you give control over your codebase to AI. Which, as I'm watching in my company right now, it is not, unless you have a lot of people in charge who can do first-principles thinking.

If nobody knows what your code does anymore, if it turns out that the tradeoffs AI makes metastacize over time, if it turns out that attention to detail ACTUALLY matters to the functioning of your systems (which it always has), then we are barreling for an extremely rude awakening. The water is just starting to move in the kettle - it might turn to a boil soon.

I think we're talking past each other. I never claimed a complete hands-off dark-factory approach to agentic coding were viable. But what's becoming clear, I think, is that agents do provide some value, if steered correctly. So I doubt the world would be going back to zero AI usage.
Sorry, I think I misunderstood what you meant by "dependency". Many places have completely let go of coherence of their projects with AI. I use AI all the time, but it helps build coherence, understanding and quality. This is becoming more and more difficult as more people turn their brain off in the face of pressure from management to try to ship more and more.

I am extremely afraid that are on the verge of losing coherence on all technology.

> I am extremely afraid that are on the verge of losing coherence on all technology.

I've worked for some large orgs in the past. One thing that surprised me, probably because I was so early in my career, was how there was only a few, sometimes only one, who knew how the system worked. When something went wrong and that person wasn't available we'd all gasp. Then, after swearing a lot, we'd gather round and roll up our sleeves. Debugger statements, coffee, then when it got late it was beer. Rinse and repeat. Line by line. I see no difference now. If an LLM writes something and I can't rely on the LLM to fix an issue it created guess what? I go line by line.

I guess it’s hard sometimes to discount experience and expertise down to “well, anyone can do it if they apply the right patterns”. Sometimes it takes a long time to understand all the bits and pieces to make any sort of reasonable trade off, or figure out why the trade offs there don’t make sense for the model. Sometimes solutions are imperfect but in a relative balance in terms of tradeoffs in one context, and when a piece of that context changes (goals, requirements, emphasized traits) it is tricky to fix without making things worse. Sometimes you just have a hard time pulling things apart.

LLMs seem to discourage people from building mental models a lot. I think those models are really important to keeping things working, and I think we’re better at it than AI because it can’t consider nearly as many contexts coherently.

When you don’t get to throw things at the wall and see what sticks with your customers or users data, you can’t yolo it, you have to hold a brain trust in how your things work.

loading story #50574632
Which is why I said "...dependent on Claude...," which is Anthropic's product and which would cease to exist if Anthropic went bankrupt. If you can easily switch to something else, open or otherwise, great, you are not actually dependent on Claude.

(Don't assume that switching between different coding agents will always be simple or straightforward. It is possible, and I think likely, that in the coming years code written by one agent will not be easy for another agent to work with. It is already becoming difficult for human programmers to deal with agent-generated code and people are already starting to develop best practices to try to mitigate that. We are still in the early days here and we have not yet encountered many of the problems that are going to arise.)