Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Genuinely a massive moment in human history. I'm nervous about what comes. as a SWE the gravy train is basically over in my view. they figured out how to make a program that does the job. Always thought i was set for life. difficult to grasp how much life will change in the coming years.
I came close to thinking that way a couple years ago, but I've become more optimistic. There is no shortage of problems that can be solved (in fact, wants are infinite), and LLMs may actually enable our profession to reliably deliver them better than 50% completion.

I've also seen non-technical folks in the corporate and government worlds glom onto vibe coding, only to start flailing like they were caught in a rip current when the underlying technical debt is too strong, even with strong and capable models.

For a certain type of engineer who enjoys really arcane technical problems, yeah, the gravy train may be over, or at least will involve a lot more machines than it used to, as Alan Turing predicted about "mechanical work" becoming a "drudge."[0]

And I think Big Tech is for the foreseeable future a sink for capital in the form of specialized hardware rather than human capital.

[0]https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Alan_Turing#Quotes

The arcane technical problems aspect of the job has always been changing; LLMs are just a continuation of the trend.

I'm old enough to remember when compiled languages like C were bemoaned by people because their skill at crafting assembly by hand was suddenly less important. Or similarly with people who were brilliant with arithmetic, or symbolic manipulation, or manual drafting/lettering. These skills were all paramount at one time, and it's natural that the people who excelled at them will feel a sense of loss.

The real goal, however, will always be to solve real-world problems. Engineering consists of whatever gets you there most effectively.

loading story #50568119
loading story #50568456
loading story #50568304
loading story #50566287
loading story #50570209
loading story #50567827
loading story #50568726
loading story #50571179
loading story #50570189
loading story #50569065
I'm old enough to call you on your bullshit.

The best you can find is people claiming that it would reduce the amount of assembly people write, which was true. They also predicted programmers would lose their low level understanding of the machine. That was also true. They didn't predict anything about making human thought non-viable economically. And not one C compiler vendor said their product could cause human extinction.

If AI predictions have the same level of truth as C compiler predictions, then the doomers are right.

loading story #50568348
loading story #50566921
loading story #50565225
loading story #50564704
loading story #50569982
loading story #50565739
loading story #50571510
loading story #50566584
loading story #50567156
loading story #50565313
loading story #50569466
loading story #50571858
loading story #50568448
loading story #50565211
loading story #50565239
loading story #50565368
loading story #50568511
Its pretty clear that software services companies will need to pivot to offer "slop fix" services. We offer Great Deals to Maintain AI Generated Software! Clean up your Code! Delete your Technical Debt! Cheap Contracts!
loading story #50569457
loading story #50564973
I strongly disagree with your optimism about the extent to which our profession will continue to exist --much less offer the best effort/reward ratio for the top ~10% performers of any major profession by far-- but I do love and appreciate you for quoting Mr. Turing. I have an another, far more relevant quote to offer in response though, from an under-appreciated essay:

  Let us now assume, for the sake of argument, that these machines are a genuine possibility, and look at the consequences of constructing them.
  To do so would of course meet with great opposition, unless we have advanced greatly in religious toleration from the days of Galileo.
  
  There would be great opposition from the intellectuals who were afraid of being put out of a job.
  
  It is probable though that the intellectuals would be mistaken about this.
  There would be plenty to do in trying, say, to keep one's intelligence up to the standard set by the machines, for it seems probable that once the machine thinking method had started, it would not take long to outstrip our feeble powers.
  There would be no question of the machines dying, and they would be able to converse with each other to sharpen their wits.
  
  At some stage therefore we should have to expect the machines to take control, in the way that is mentioned in Samuel Butler's *Erewhon*.
In case it's not obvious: things do not work out in Erewhon :(
loading story #50566735
loading story #50565768
loading story #50565045
loading story #50564787
loading story #50565381
loading story #50565989
loading story #50564999
loading story #50564286
contrarian opinion. I think all we’ve learned is SWEs are still very much needed. gas town failed, it failed quietly, but no one doing real work talks about software factories anymore.

Most companies that are running the “how many SWEs can we fire before it all breaks” experiment have learned it’s a failed experiment - this validated by every single major company/product outage where their uptime went below 90% this year.

I can’t help but think this anxiety and fear is just marketing. chill out everyone

It is strange this is the contrarian opinion when most of the evidence points to it being the case. Everyone working is busier than ever, more prs but no end in sight to the backlog still and fires to put out every day. PMs and designers who have deeper idea of product then most can put up some automatic prs for quick fixes, everyone with a bit of time can build siloed dashboards on their own but actually doing the day to day eng work to keep things running or design a new service to integrate with the product…I’m not seeing it
loading story #50564274
loading story #50564481
loading story #50570459
I think there's a spectrum of being a SWE and what we're seeing is the ones essentially just writing boilerplate code most of their day have a very different view than those who are solving problems with software that require careful thinking and execution.

A lot of people seem to think they can pick up an LLM and suddenly write software solutions as good as a seasoned SWE. But it turns into this terrible mess that's thrown out all engineering fundamentals, solving the symptoms instead of the cause.

If I were just writing boilerplate code with an LLM all day I'd be very scared for my job too.

loading story #50566017
loading story #50564538
>gas town failed quietly

This is a big problem. When this kind of thing gets launched, its all fanfare, this is the future, get on the boat or die.

But then it fails miserably and its like it never existed

loading story #50564295
> I can’t help but think this anxiety and fear is just marketing. chill out everyone

Here are few anecdotes:

1. I've a friend who owns a PT (physical therapy) business. He's not even a tech guy, but uses claude to manage most of the business aspects, and he has told me repeatedly that he would've to spend thousands of dollars to get things done, and instead he pays 250 per year.

2. Another friend is smart, and is a jack-of-all-trades type in the software/hardware/firmware business. He is solo bootstrapping by doing all the things from pcb to webapp. He doesn't see hiring anyone for the niche business.

3. A 65 year old friend of mine who never in any tech career was able to build website for his side business (that website looks really good btw) and he now talks about json and ocr.

You are the one who is out of touch with reality.

loading story #50579616
loading story #50564542
loading story #50565464
loading story #50564416
loading story #50564728
loading story #50564419
loading story #50564962
loading story #50568869
loading story #50566420
I agree, but to the extent I’m worried about the future of the profession, it’s because I don’t know how much more the models are going to improve. Today’s models desperately need a real SWE in the loop to do most serious engineering. Will that still be the case in 5 years? I really don’t know
loading story #50564256
I feel like once it doesn't need an engineer in the loop, does it need ANYBODY in the loop? at that point the whole company can probably be autonomous.

That seems like it would be such a paradigm shift that the second and third order effects are so crazy and nobody can predict what that world will actually look like

loading story #50564276
loading story #50565353
loading story #50566409
loading story #50564099
> it’s a failed experiment - this validated by every single major company/product outage where their uptime went below 90% this year.

This is engineering thinking, not business thinking. The question is, did the uptime drops cost the company more money than the firings saved? If the answer is no (which for megacorps like Microsoft it is) then the experiment was a success.

loading story #50565366
I didn't know gas town failed. What happened? Did Steve yegge say as much?
Most developers built their own framework /harness anyway
projects like gas town are failures if they don't become a standard practice or a truism in the tech scene. thought leaders are never going to announce their ideas as failures so they can maintain relevance, as well as plausible deniability about it's success/failure
> I didn't know gas town failed. What happened? Did Steve yegge say as much?

He wrote a series of blog posts in which he talked about how Gas Town failed and blamed it on Opus 4.7 changes causing all his workflows to fail. Then he announced Gas City as a rewrite.

At some point after that he seemed to give up on the whole idea and instead just started working on reviving an old graphical MUD style game he made where I guess now he spends $10,000 a month on agents to build a game that currently has 0 concurrent players (4 concurrent 24 hour peak) on Steam:

https://steamdb.info/app/1541710/charts/

The game is available from other platforms than Steam so maybe he's got a bit more users than that across the platforms, and his stated plan is to bilk "whales", so maybe that's working out for him? But it still seems like he's lighting massive amounts of money on fire in what appears to be a prolonged state of ai psychosis.

Must be nice to be that financially secure.

loading story #50565899
Failures are nearly dead silent aside the million words of hype. There is no accountability for "gassing" up so many people and taunting them that if they don't get on board a failing idea then they will be left behind. A lot of grifters get off freely.
Gastown was too early and focused on the angle that having agents cosplaying a mini org chart was the way to get better results.
this is the only reasonable opinion. people saying "they made a thing which does the job" just fell to the hype mindlessly. someone still needs to input stuff into a thing which does the job, this someone is SWE or systems analyst. not everyone is a good systems analyst and can turn business goals into a clear specification to implement.

if the hype was all true, i could just prompt the llm to make me money and it would be able to do it, but it's not possible

Are they bringing their employees back in the same numbers and for the same wages though? Or are they outsourcing to Indian humans-in-the-loop for 1% of the cost?
loading story #50564111
loading story #50564092
I think it has changed everything and in all honesty it has been the biggest change since the introduction of high level languages (As in from Assembly to C and Algo).

but at the same time I think the companies are pumping this idea that SWE is over and stoking anxiety and we have yet to see how bad things get when everyone can write software without thinking about it, we will see what insecure slop gets produced and it's going to be huge.

The issues with AI security are quite big as well, people who will rely on just an LLM to be the intelligence will get burnt I am sure especially in operations, prompt injection is still an issue, would someone running LLM's notice an provider endpoint getting hijacked and acting maliciously and inserting malware into production servers.

The future is going to be a strange one for sure but being able to turn your brain of and get your LLM to run you servers write you servers is not going to work alone.

I have also yet it write a good fairly novel program without babysitting (quite trivial babysitting sometimes) but stuff that is bread and butter for us, for those who don't have those skills, will they really know how to explain the issues they may run into that requires creativity, for example telling it to hack something together with curl and jq, knowing why a certain thing with the sandbox is not working.

I think these issues are not as easy to resolve with just better tooling and they will soon get annoyed at prompting.

Additionally I think Gas Town shows the sort of almost mentally ill mentality that is baked into some of these tools and ideas, Everything I read of Gas Town was so strange and the amount of tokens used to anthropomorphize agents.

Some of these staff reductions are also due to the ENORMOUS pull of the US IT sector. There are not many companies with as many SWE as Microsoft and Meta, so some reduction isn't that surprising.
Software is needed, not SWEs. I can now run a company without having to hire any pesky humans doing so called "software" work. No need to worry about their health insurance, 401k, PTO, 1:1, "how are you feeling" and all such nonsense.
> but no one doing real work talks about software factories anymore

My friends at FAANG companies would disagree here. If anything, it seems to be the exact opposite.

Sure, it's not a end-to-end 0 touch factory, but a majority of folks I talk to these days that I consider good engineers aren't writing _any_ code anymore. They do that as a hobby outside of work.

loading story #50564694
loading story #50565240
loading story #50564818
loading story #50563820
loading story #50564689
loading story #50564679
loading story #50565573
loading story #50566045
loading story #50573093
loading story #50564072
loading story #50563936
loading story #50568856
loading story #50570702
loading story #50568451
loading story #50564898
loading story #50563711
loading story #50568482
loading story #50568034
loading story #50567935
loading story #50572030
loading story #50564887
loading story #50565146
loading story #50564148
loading story #50565524
loading story #50564466
loading story #50568576
loading story #50564138
loading story #50565949
loading story #50566762
loading story #50566732
loading story #50566169
loading story #50568952
loading story #50563959
loading story #50564774
loading story #50568358
loading story #50569861
loading story #50564258
loading story #50565034
loading story #50570409
loading story #50566010
loading story #50565305
loading story #50564829
loading story #50564875
loading story #50565089
loading story #50568340
loading story #50564188
loading story #50564997
loading story #50565742
loading story #50563831
loading story #50565709
loading story #50567653
loading story #50568321
loading story #50564397
loading story #50565253
loading story #50576611
loading story #50566214
loading story #50570361
loading story #50568615
loading story #50566456
loading story #50564996
loading story #50569148
loading story #50565981
loading story #50568080
loading story #50565654
loading story #50566496
loading story #50564974
loading story #50564956
loading story #50564418
loading story #50563917
loading story #50580285
loading story #50563818
loading story #50564758
loading story #50575354
loading story #50565720
loading story #50568311
loading story #50565808
loading story #50565511
loading story #50565587
loading story #50566381
loading story #50566024
loading story #50565764
loading story #50569514
loading story #50569046
loading story #50568892
loading story #50568870
loading story #50568700
loading story #50570719
loading story #50566736
loading story #50565976
loading story #50565847
loading story #50565377
loading story #50565016
loading story #50563874
loading story #50567101
loading story #50564387
loading story #50566861
loading story #50566016
loading story #50565722
loading story #50564809
loading story #50565084
loading story #50564544
loading story #50564388
loading story #50563727
loading story #50568734
loading story #50564963
I started programming 50 years ago. At one stage early in my career this mysterious new language C was the thing, and I went on an all expenses paid 2 week course in Singapore where they flew attendees in from around the world to learn this language. Software has been good to me.

Now it seems like it's the sunset of this way of making a living. I think people who manage to move up the food chain a bit will succeed but its hard to advise any junior in the industry exactly what that looks like.

loading story #50564490
It's not just software. It's everything that can be transformed into bits. And that's a lot of stuff.
Some jobs require more than just intelligence--for example, nurses, chefs, judges, reporters, teachers, caregivers, therapists, social workers, hair stylists, coaches, paramedics, firefighters, police officers, electricians, plumbers, mechanics, clergy, trial lawyers and diplomats.

What is the common thread?

These jobs depend on some combination of physical skill, human connection, trust, judgment and accountability, and such jobs are out of reach of AI.

Oooh it won't be black and white: It will start with 1 helper robot per nurse, yo help her in the repetitive or heavy tasks.

Then they will be able to do more and more, and 1 nurse will be able to do the job of 4-5 2020 nurses.

Until that nurse is a dude from Mexico [where im from/based] giving instructions to all the robots.

loading story #50565741
Automation and robotics are also surging rather silently in the shadows as AI is the lead that’s getting attention. And AI happens to be congruent with those 2.
Doctors, nurses, therapists, coaches and reporters will definitely see impact. AI is already being used for all of these things, although probably not very effectively/safely. In the near future, better tools will come out that fix the worst drawbacks. All of these will still have use-cases for a human, for example in very difficult cases, or of course when a human is needed for the actual treatment, but at the margins, AI will chip away at them.

If predictions about robotics are accurate, things will get even more difficult in the next ten years as humanoid robots mature.

loading story #50566733
The other common thread for most of what you've listed is, unfortunately, comparably lower pay.

Arguably, software has times that require physical presence, human connection, trust, judgment, and accountability.

loading story #50564472
loading story #50564587
I think ultimately this is a flawed understanding of the incentives at play.

None of these end up really being out of reach of AI if Anthropic can justify this valuation. They're just slower to roll out.

It won't be tomorrow, but I'm not so sure blue collar technicians (plumbers, mechanics, electricians) are far behind: once parts become modular enough, with sufficient sensor data, a cloud system at the manufacturer for your car, boiler, or home lighting system will be able to give you step by step instructions for how to replace and repair items, and will ship you the replacements and tools needed.

Of course the elderly and frail and people too afraid to touch something lest they break it will still call an expert, and original build and installations will need those trained, but I could see vast swaths of less technically skilled people opting for a go at routine repairs which could really hollow out the demand.

loading story #50566366
loading story #50564984
If say 30% of the white collar workforce is laid off, many of those professions would likely be severely impacted by the resulting deflation. We're all connected.
loading story #50571784
Is software engineering really that different? The most effective devs are those who don't just have a vision but can work across the org to generate buy-in and enthusiasm to make that vision a reality. This very human process, driven by relationships etc.
loading story #50565194
AI is already replacing some reporters, therapists, and lawyers. One might argue that it shouldn't (an AI therapist is a bit of a scary concept) but it does. And they're only getting better.
I think this is not right.

LLMs are hugely suited to code because it's token heavy and the compiler is the RLHF verifier.

The LLMs are still very bad at concepts.

What we see in code does not translate to other, arbitrary domains.

Legal - yes, due to text heavy content with tons of great examples as well.

Everything else ... not really. At least not LLMs as we understand them today.

Like two or three generations of frontier ago (in the long long ago of last year), I had ChatGPT design a PCB, then Claude a case, then I had China manufacture it on demand and turned it into a real product that shipped to real users. Those chinese factories were mostly staffed by machines, I suspect.

I'm not the only one that had that idea, they're advertising these things as features now.

I don't know what's next, but keep in mind that today's LLM's are the worst they'll ever be.

loading story #50565783
loading story #50565928
loading story #50565697
An LLM by itself is quirky and prone to error, but that's not where the next wave of innovation is happening. Look at harnesses instead. A harness like a coding agent is an incredible productivity multiplier. Coding agents are just the first type of harness. We should expect businesses everywhere to create other kinds of harnesses, thereby transforming every domain where money can be made from increased efficiency. All one has to do is ask a coding agent to build a different kind of harness.
loading story #50565939
That just means those systems are not yet sufficiently formalized. I think LLMs are pretty bad at math too but with Lean they are churning out results.
This honestly just sounds like you haven’t really explored the capabilities of the current bleeding edge
loading story #50566715
It’s not even just everything that can be transformed into bits.

Nearly everything will (eventually) be impacted.

Therapists? People are using LLMs for “free” help.

Physical trainers? Just upload a video of your workout to an LLM for tuning advice and other exercises you can focus on.

Appliance/vehicle repair? Just DIY it with an LLM.

Teachers? Just teach yourself with an LLM.

I could go on.

To be clear, I’m not saying LLMs are better at this. But just saying LLMs are impacting nearly every field.

EDIT: just to clarify some of the responses talking about full replacement -- that's not my point here. I'm talking about impacting, not replacing. Software engineering likely won't get fully replaced (anytime soon), either -- but it's definitely being impacted.

My top priority today is raising my kids, which LLMs have been stupendously unhelpful with, although they were pretty useful in setting up a home server and Jellyfin so I could give them a curated, parent-vetted set of TV shows to watch.

I think this is a very good template for what sort of skills will survive the LLM-apocalypse and what won't. LLMs are the great homogenizer. Any type of knowledge work where there is a broadly-accepted set of best practices for how to do it is gonna get outsourced to an AI.

But AI is terrible at doing anything unique, personalized, and based on your own desires, because it doesn't have your desires. It's building on a corpus of shared knowledge, but there is a large set of knowledge that is unshared, and it can't do anything for that. A large portion of business, for example, is secrets and lies, and an LLM isn't going to be able to help you much with that. At its best it can set up the frameworks and tools to help you keep secrets and tell lies.

And then a large portion of life is personal preferences, the things that make you unique and distinct from every other human, and an LLM can't help you with that either. There is a reason I don't have a nanny raise my kids, even though we could afford it. If I did that, it would be the nanny raising my kids, which defeats a lot of the point of having kids in the first place. LLMs have the same problem.

That tracks with my experience trying to get "deep"/obscure recommendations for TV shows from the 70s/80s/90s and niche books from either Claude/Gemini/ChatGPT.

I keep trying to nudge them to be relevant with specific examples of a few shows I had watched that were very popular at the time but now considered "old/boring/not remastered" so don't make it into the Best X Shows of XXs lists that emphasize modern tastes. But the recommendations were either the same things I already knew about, or were just wrong/irrelevant for various reasons.

Recently I stumbled onto a Reddit post from years ago with a similar request to mine, and both the question itself and top answers were a goldmine of suggestions that were never recommended and I hadn't heard of. I knew within seconds of looking at the IMDB that they would be exactly what I wanted, so it's not like the AI recs are failing just because of idiosyncratic taste. They just don't seem to search from a deep enough info source, have been RLed into conformity, or some other disconnect between intent and execution.

Also, what happens when the set of best practices starts to shift beyond the bounds of the LLM training corpus?

Or — more disturbingly — what if LLMs lock us into our current state of development forever? This is all we will ever be; nothing will fundamentally change from here on out.

It feels a bit like cryptocurrency and LLMs were dropshipped alien technologies specifically designed to bind us and drain our resources by leveraging our own greed.

The last two aren't knowledge-constrained. You could find anything you could ever need on these topics even before LLMs. The reason so many people don't DIY their repairs is because they lack the tools, time, desire to do the dirty work or are afraid they'll mess it up. For teaching, you could already teach yourself any degree, the point in education is the structure that forces you to go through with it (most people don't have the determination on their own) and to have an accreditation that someone has actually ensured you acquired the knowledge you say you did.
Proving that someone has acquired knowledge is something an LLM could do better than a human institution. Stick the human in a room which detects foreign electronics, and have the LLM run a highly interactive and unpredictable set of challenges for the human to solve. Have the LLM weight its grade on an understanding of the underlying principles.

Done right, that accreditation could be objectively superior to brand names like Harvard, etc.

loading story #50564195
loading story #50565823
loading story #50564115
loading story #50564121
loading story #50564895
If everyone could teach themselves with an LLM they would have already been doing this with the Internet, television, or books. Plenty of people can, but those who don’t find it easier to learn in school.

The real danger for teachers is society deciding people don’t need to be educated. Although that would be a problem for all of us actually.

Classic doomer vibes. If we were to quantify the impact of LLM's on teaching, auto maintenance, therapy, and trainers / PT, I don't think your thesis would hold up substantially.
loading story #50564589
loading story #50564009
loading story #50564410
loading story #50564702
And it will not be limited to LLMs. In just a few years, they will likely figure out robotics and continual learning. Then all jobs are affected. I'm very worried about what's coming for all people who rely on wages to survive.
All jobs will be affected before robotics. When there are less white collar jobs there will be more people competing for blue collar jobs.

More workers competing means lower pay. Less good paying jobs means less customers. Less customers means less jobs. This is an over simplification, but is one possible future.

I'd be happier if my prediction turns out wrong.

loading story #50565245
loading story #50569944
Worry instead about what the people relying on wages will do to the people who broke the world.
loading story #50568927
loading story #50564805
{"deleted":true,"id":50563982,"parent":50563824,"time":1795112706,"type":"comment"}
loading story #50563814
loading story #50570035
loading story #50563859
loading story #50566651
loading story #50564463
loading story #50569834
loading story #50570591
loading story #50563992
loading story #50566021
loading story #50564022
loading story #50564287
loading story #50564664
loading story #50564731
loading story #50565914
loading story #50568056
loading story #50567599
loading story #50565529
loading story #50564012
loading story #50580813
loading story #50564657
loading story #50563610
loading story #50569147
loading story #50565182
loading story #50569579
loading story #50563761
loading story #50567414
loading story #50570814
loading story #50566200
loading story #50563601
loading story #50563815
loading story #50563844
loading story #50564952
loading story #50570374
loading story #50567638
loading story #50566106
loading story #50566685
loading story #50570342
loading story #50568935
loading story #50563682
loading story #50563452
loading story #50563518
loading story #50572047
loading story #50567152
loading story #50570403
loading story #50566846
loading story #50568463
loading story #50563557
loading story #50566384
loading story #50564231
loading story #50563736
loading story #50564736
loading story #50565060
people says it's bubble, can anyone just suggest i should invest in anthropic or openai?
loading story #50566359
loading story #50567641
loading story #50566342
loading story #50570926
loading story #50566408
loading story #50566340
loading story #50565261
loading story #50563587
loading story #50563571
loading story #50563489
loading story #50565054
loading story #50571316
loading story #50564141
loading story #50565494
loading story #50563592
loading story #50567533
loading story #50563809
loading story #50565549
loading story #50568174
loading story #50563420
loading story #50564578
loading story #50563596
loading story #50564305
loading story #50564903
loading story #50565192
loading story #50569990
loading story #50565128
loading story #50568998
loading story #50566079
loading story #50570708
loading story #50570468
loading story #50567010
loading story #50573343
loading story #50566403
loading story #50564602
loading story #50565298
loading story #50568780
loading story #50570009
loading story #50570364
loading story #50563879
loading story #50567269
loading story #50565853
loading story #50565328
loading story #50563880
loading story #50563602
loading story #50564123
loading story #50565274
loading story #50564661
loading story #50564928
loading story #50570377
loading story #50568971
loading story #50569595
loading story #50565975
loading story #50564615
loading story #50564543
loading story #50562805
loading story #50568860
loading story #50565303
loading story #50578942
loading story #50572196
loading story #50573640
loading story #50569597
loading story #50569554
loading story #50567396
loading story #50565966
loading story #50566462
loading story #50564803
loading story #50566091
loading story #50566458
loading story #50564843
loading story #50563789
loading story #50570007
loading story #50568361
loading story #50563910
loading story #50563805
Major moment in the revolution of how we work and the ripples across society
loading story #50565510
loading story #50564342
loading story #50563891
loading story #50563754