Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
The self-hosting crowd, Linux fans, OSS contributors, etc, are our own worst enemies.

If we care about self-hosting and open source and decentralization because we believe it leads to a better world, and not simply because we want to be control freaks and snobs, then we need to learn how to build shit that is actually convenient and usable and understandable to normal people.

I think it's possible. I think many people would want this, and care, if we could package it up in a digestible way.

Linux has been more user friendly and accessible to me for normal use than Windows for years now. I really do not understand this comment
Talk to people not in tech.

Windows never ever ever makes you open a terminal to do anything, that’s scary to non-tech people. Windows “just works” and most people just want to minimize their computer use for work and go watch tiktok on their phone.

"Windows just works" is such a lie.
Windows makes you open a terminal just to install it properly.
which scenario someone needs to open terminal if all they need is a browser and an office suite?
I'd say one of the major frictions with self-hosting is that for the most part it does always going to take a lot of tinkering around and maintaining things going. A world were we have a lot more people self-hosting would be great, but as it stands, it's an utopia, because normal users will get annoyed the fuck out of the environment the second their infra is busted because of any of the million reasons things break.
Self hosting is in pretty much the same state smartphones were in before the iPhone.

I remember trying to install apps and it was annoying for all the same reasons self hosting is these days. It was niche, only hobbyists did it, "nobody cared" and the presumption was that for normal non-nerds, phones were exclusively for calls and texting.

There are some spectacular successes in terms of the actual self hosted software (immich and home assistant) but the overall experience is still N95 not iPhone.

The part where self hosting falls down isnt the apps it's config, networking, reliability and backups.

Ollama and friends are pretty damn easy to use already. Hardware is the real barrier
let's see here, you already make a crucial mistake that a product manager wouldn't. (I say this as a senior software engineer that has worked with product managers a lot)

If I tell my mom to download and install Ollama on her Mac, do you think she's gonna have any clue which model to download from all of the 5000 models she can choose from? Do you think she understands which ones will even work well on her machine? What if she downloads one that's highly recommended online but it doesn't work on her 64 GB MacBook (hypothetical example)? Because it's too too large/slow...

and can Ollama, out of the box, do actual work on her computer, similar to the ChatGPT app with its "Work" mode, and dozens of built in connectors (google, etc)?

you call this easy to use for a normal person? You just made their point. The ChatGPT and Claude apps that my mom can download, set the standard for her. Her standard of good/easy is not what you and I as nerds find easy. you need to really put yourself in the shoes of a tech illiterate person. we haven't even touched on the fact that Claude and ChatGPT ship with easy to use iOS and Android apps that sync up perfectly with her Mac.

loading story #50562949
What percentage of techies use self-hosting for a significant part of their services?

Before that number is high, can we realistically expect non-techies to use self-hosting?

At some point there is a trade-off between those far away controlling "your" stuff and convenience. It is much easier for someone to make something convenient if they have control over it. For example, troubleshooting when you own the stack versus troubleshooting when you don't. However, if someone wants someone far away to help them troubleshoot, then it will be easier if the one far away controls the stuff. There is a trade-off there.
Its worth mentioning "normal people" take hours upon hours of classes and trainings to use typical office productivity software and other job-related software, on top of watching and learning from tutorials and family and friends to use personal software and websites and apps. And heaven knows how many support calls and tickets to just do what is supposed to be "easy" in the closed source world.

Also, none of this is intuitive and a lot of popular closed stuff is harder to use (and vastly disliked by the very same normal users) than some popular open source stuff.

I'd even mention 'normies' want self hosted Word and Excel and regularly reject the web-based versions of them. Normies don't want streaming games but a gaming PC or console. Normies may buy streaming services like Netflix but get upset when their favorite shows are removed, so they actually don't like netflix. Normies complain about censorship on twitter and reddit and discord and would love an alternative they control, but may be unaware that's an option and seem stuck on those services and hate them.

Normies want self-hosted all the time too. Their ability to understand and do this is what's lacking. So that's a conversation on its own, but normies aren't actually happy. Form what I can tell most people hate 50% of the stuff they use right now and most of those complaints revolve around the cloud-hosted/lack of control/privacy and other issues self-hosting or federated services or FOSS apps could arguably solve for them.

This is a big conversation but imho tends to boil down to who has the marketing and sway to get you to install or use something, not that typical end users are savvy judges of software and useability working purely on merit and informed facts. Does your grandma actually like Facebook, or is she just lonely and its the lowest friction way to not be lonely? Do you really like Chrome or Word or is it just easy to get and popular? Is the big mac the best burger or is just easy to get and popular?

There's a decent opportunity where AI coding agents seem good at creating a very "average" and understandable UI. Maybe not perfect, but probably better than Gimp?
The problem with open source is that it is often written by people who are fixing issues they have or making features they miss. To get to the point of contributing, you have to go through the initial setup process. Once you've done that, it's not longer a problem you care about, so you're less motivated to contribute code to make that process easier.
> shit that is actually convenient

I mean...sure...but how convenient was that Office 365 outage? How convenient is it to find that a feature you actually depended on is gone because the company that runs your software decided to get rid of it?

It is always a back-and-forth. It is not as if centralized computing is a new idea, in fact it was the original way to use computers and people found that issues of control mattered and switched to PCs; the pendulum swung back because people realized that there are advantages to centralization (e.g. not having a failed hard drive destroy high-value documents). The cycle will probably continue for a long time to come because the advantages and disadvantages of both approaches are fundamental.

That inconvenience is still less inconvenient than not being able to figure out your dns or vpn or tail scar settings or why it won’t render and why the machine isn’t reachable. When running your own services is easier than it currently is and lot of tools are built around notifications and debugging that are actually understandable, then you’ll have more adoption of open source software.
>I mean...sure...but how convenient was that Office 365 outage?

One outage in a blue moon? Bloody very convenient. People have more outage days per year on their own laptops.

This. The FOSS/etc crowd don't even try to bother with outreach on tools that the majority of people would want if they were marketed correctly instead of kept as niche projects for people to be smug about. Consider the EU rolling out Matrix in a huge way, or people moving to Mastodon. For most normies, "Use this to escape Elon Musk" is more than enough sales pitch.
> not simply because we want to be control freaks and snobs

It’s not so much about being snobs as it is about not having time and energy for a second job. The level of quality you demand simply requires a level of attention, investment and involvement that can’t be provided without working full-time on it, for profit.

Telling a bunch of hobbyists that they should provide service of a quality equivalent to that of a trillion-dollar corporation if they are serious about it is gaslighting.

I hate to say this, but Claude Code has turned my home projects and personal scripts from "I tolerate this because I need it" to "This works so nicely I might make it available to others". AI could really help here.

I'll go purify myself now.

> we want to be control freaks and snobs

That's a mirror that hurts to look at that you just held in front of my face. Guilty on both counts, even though I try to convince myself I'm not