Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> It seems that the difference between intelligence and the simulation of intelligence is too subtle for many people to recognize.

Yes, it's way over the heads of Nobel Prize winners whose work helped develop the technology.

> Current tools are not smart and they do not reason. They simulate reasoning by producing a train of steps that looks like the most likely selection from the training data.

It's interesting that you seem to know how they "reason" when it's a hot research topic.

https://news.yale.edu/2026/10/08/how-do-ai-chatbots-reason-h...

> When that was the "smart" thing to do for the current request they appear to be smart. When it was not they reveal the bias induced by their training data and they look fragile and wrong. It is the uncanny valley but for reasoning.

That sounds an awful like humans.

> I would continue but I have to go back to arguing with Claude that almost every line of code that it has produced reveals an incorrect unstated assumption about the system that we are building and/or how code should be structured in general.

It's ironic that you are using a technology that isn't smart and can't reason to do your job.

The imaginary internet points that you feel that you have scored with this response are not real. If you want to engage in an actual discussion then feel free to reply with something that actually engages with what I wrote. Otherwise have a nice day.
And what did you write?

> Current tools are not smart and they do not reason. They simulate reasoning by producing a train of steps that looks like the most likely selection from the training data.

Let's start with "they're not smart". Geoffrey Hinton, who has a Turing Award and Nobel Prize in Physics to his name, and was involved in the foundational discoveries underpinning modern AI, disagrees:

https://theconversation.com/ai-pioneer-geoffrey-hinton-says-...

On "reasoning", whether what AI is doing is "reasoning" or not, and how there might be forms of "reasoning" that are different from ours, is currently a subject of intense research, as evidenced by the Yale study I referenced.

You provided absolutely no evidence for "current tools are not smart and they do not reason." If you have an evidence-based argument to make, make it. Because dismissing anything you disagree with as "not real" is about as convincing as "AI is dumb. Trust me, bro".

I've read the article that you linked. It does not back up your claim that Hinton believes they are smart. Rather, to quote directly

> While he does think AI has the capacity to become smarter than humans, he also proposes it should be thought of as an altogether different form of intelligence to our own.

The capacity (i.e. potential) to become smart is not the same as being smart. But even "Hinton believes it" is not a very convincing argument: it is an appeal to authority. This is different from a reasoned argument.

It's not so interesting to discuss what other people think, e.g. second-hand opinions. You've made the claim that LLMs are smart, and that it is ridiculous to think otherwise. Do you have an argument to support this claim, or is your support that you believe that smart people think this?