Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
It's the ratio of Google to Anthropic that is off. If Anthropic is genuinely "worth" 1.5T, then Google should be much greater. They have everything Anthropic has, and a veritable mountain of assets that Anthropic does not have. But the vibes-based market doesn't price it in.
I mostly agree with this sentiment, but to make the opposite case: what percentage of Google’s current revenue/profits gets cannibalized in an AI future? Yes, Google might have AI, but would it merely be replacing 1.5T in search value with 1.5T in AI value? Would this be a future where Google is one of 3+ AI players while it is essentially the only search player today?

I mostly agree that if AI is worth that much, Google is there and has lots of other stuff too. But I think there’s also a case to be made that AI could be challenging Google’s search monopoly and so future AI value will come at the expense of their search value.

Google also has a lot of baggage around their ability to turn their assets and capabilities into successful projects.
loading story #50575003
I've been trying to tell many people this. Their valuations can make sense, but not at the same time.
I see, I misunderstood what you meant. If I had to bet on one, I would agree with you and bet on Google over Anthropic. But I'd rather not bet at all
> They have everything Anthropic has

They also quite literally own ~13% of Anthropic.