Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Signal requires disclosing a phone number to a commercial organization and agreeing to their terms.
Signal is a non profit with robust terms that forbid monetisation of data.

The data you share is minimal anyway, and can’t be used to decrypt any messages.

It’s not suitable for any industries that require any form of record keeping or auditing, the minimal tradeoffs are well worth it, given that you don’t have to stand up your own solution.

Promises don't matter if you don't have a technological guarantee. Promises can be broken and governments can make companies break promises.
There is a technical guarantee with Signal, and their ability to cooperate with governments has already been tested, when the FBI came to Signal with a court order for all information they had on a given user, and Signal turned over everything they had: the user's sign up date.
For years now, Signal has uploaded people's entire contact lists to their server, protected only by Intel SGX that is infamously vulnerable. I use Signal myself, and suppose that its chats themselves may be reliably E2EE. But it's a reasonable assumption that a nation-level actor has access to contact metadata, not just the bare facts Signal says it discloses when authorities come calling.
The threat scenario for exploiting an SGX vulnerability is not relevant in this context.
I don’t think that’s a reasonable assumption at all; have you seen what it takes for those SGX exploits to work? There is no way Signal would continue to operate if someone required them to do that.

theoretically possible and practically implementable are two entirely different things.

> have you seen what it takes for those SGX exploits to work?

It is absolutely trivial for an operator to intentionally compromise the latest generation of trusted computing from both intel and amd. See https://tee.fail/ for a nice writeup.

tl;dr Currently CPUs reuse nonces meaning the solution is unfit to defend against an operator with physical access. It can only defend against rogue neighbors (ie other guests).

loading story #50568325
loading story #50570493
Signal uses rented cloud infrastructure. No one needs to require them to do anything.
The alternative is running your own hardware, which won’t protect you from the “nation-level actor” you mentioned. They’ll just come in with a warrant and take it.
Where did I suggest one can protect themselves? Personally, I don't believe that a strong state like the US would permit in 2026 a general-public service to exist that it does not have access to for the metadata.
There is a technical guarantee that anything that is encrypted now might be decrypted in the future thanks to advancememts in technology.

While hosting your own servers do not prevent any gov from recording all your net traffic, it might just not even be aware of it while signal is an obvious target as it is known to being used by the press, gov officials and other criminal groups.

The government could force Signal to begin storing more data without disclosing it to the users.
Some people (like me) simply don't like the idea of being at the mercy of any single particular entity. No amount of convenience or practicality is going to convince those people that Signal is worth adopting. If I am going to go through the hassle of getting my friends and contacts out of WhatsApp, then I'd rather just skip Signal and go straight to a protocol that supports multiple clients and does not have its preconceived notion about how people should communicate.
> Some people (like me) simply don't like the idea of being at the mercy of any single particular entity.

Is the person hosting the Matrix instance not the single particular entity you are now at the mercy of?

I'm not trying to be glib, it's a genuine thought. I also love the idea of using self-hosted solutions for everything but more often than not it just means putting all the trust/responsibility on the one person willing to maintain the whole thing.

Valid point, and there are p2p/decentralized approaches such as White Noise that builds on Nostr and MLS (RFC 9420) [0]

[0]: https://www.whitenoise.chat/

loading story #50562481
> Is the person hosting the Matrix instance not the single particular entity you are now at the mercy of?

to some degree, but you could migrate to a different or your own instance without needing to convince your contacts to do the same.

We're also in the process of (slowly) adding account portability to Matrix - I demo'd the first ever (rather anticlimactic) migration at the matrix conf last month: https://youtu.be/U5LRRNgvTZE?list=PLFDUAtPqCX98&t=1082
You’re at the mercy of whoever is hosting your Matrix instance.

Also, every matrix instance in the world has to forward their notification pushes for every iOS user in the world to vector.im, the matrix vendor, to be relayed to Apple.

So, if you use iOS, you are at the mercy of at least 3 entities.

There are also lots of Signal clients, and they’re all free software.

> So, if you use iOS, you are at the mercy of at least 3 entities.

To be pedantic here, you can communicate without notifications.

That's an incorrect evaluation of push notifications.

Because of the way push notifications work on iOS, they are end-to-end encrypted and relayed via a push gateway operated by the person that deployed that client to the app store. For Element clients, this is Element Creations. For other clients, there are other operators with no relation at all. If you build your client from source, it's you.

As far as the server and protocol is concerned, it just sends notifications where the client tells it to.

You realize people have been arrested by the USA based on push notification timing attacks? It's quite easy if you're the omniscient government: you have one criminal's phone, you send a bunch of messages to his friends on whatever platform, you get Apple to tell you who received a push notification after you sent each message and didn't receive others. I don't remember any of the case details but this was actually done in reality.
Seems to be something that could happen with Signal as well?
loading story #50577650
Yes, vector.im (new vector ltd) changed their name to Element Creations because they still haven’t learned the lesson that having a company name different than your product name is dumb. Countless startups have re-learned this lesson.

Regardless, that’s why I said pushes and not push notifications, but they are all indeed relayed through one entity, formerly named New Vector and now named Element (and if they are successful then eventually named Matrix). They’re the publisher of the iOS app and iOS apps can only receive pushes from their publisher.

All of this handwaving about distributed this and selfhosted that and it all relies on some small VC-backed startup’s instances in realtime. If those go down the app effectively goes down because nobody on iOS gets notifications. Same goes for when some hobby sysadmin’s non-HA deployment goes offline for a day or two.

There is no "the app". For my personal usage I don't use any apps published by Element, and as such do not rely on any of their infrastructure. I develop my own server [0], my friends develop their own clients[1][2][3]. When my server went down I switched to one hosted by someone I know, and then switched back when it was up. Decentralisation and interoperability are not theoretical.

[0]: https://forgejo.ellis.link/continuwuation/continuwuity [1]: https://github.com/gomuks/gomuks [2]: https://git.sable.moe/sableclient/sable-next [3]: https://git.federated.nexus/Nexus/nexus

No, you can spin up a new container at another hoster with your backup.
loading story #50559415
loading story #50562451
The 501c3 corporation named Signal can see all metadata and can see what users messaged what other users at what time. This 501c3's centralized namespace is hosted on Amazon Web Services, which can and will also see all that metadata.

Among people competent with computers, vendor lock-in is something to avoid, not embrace ; they don't perceive someone else hosting their server instances as "convenient" but as something else.

Use Signal Desktop long enough after leaving whatever "phone" in a drawer long enough and you'll see

  Open Signal on your phone to keep your account active
The 501c3 corporation named Signal is a vendor who abuses those foolish enough to use its service.
{"deleted":true,"id":50559447,"parent":50559379,"time":1795092657,"type":"comment"}
no it doesn't require disclosing a phone number to a commercial organization
How do you register without a phone number or a mobile phone or a bank card with your name on it?
loading story #50562504
loading story #50559444
loading story #50560895