Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Because safe Rust is so constrained, Rust relies on unsafe much more than Java, and their need for intrinsics is about the same (although Java lets you turn off individual intrinsics at runtime).
Tons of production Rust systems use very little unsafe. I've been writing production Rust since 2015, and in that time, I wrote maybe 30 lines of unsafe production code. (Most of it in Tokio primitives.)

Now, in web-facing systems, the biggest concern is the low-level crypto libraries, which need to be written in assembly to avoid timing attacks. These (and related libraries) have seen multiple security advisories in the past year, some related to unsafe (I think?) and some related to logic errors. But overall, those advisories have mostly been lower priority, or affected mostly niche use cases.

If you only have a small amount of unsafe code, then it's possible to audit it more aggressively. And there's only a limited amount of space for bugs. So what I would expect for Rust is a trickle of security bugs, many of them niche or low severity, that slows down with time.

Do you use core abstractions like Vec, String, Box, Arc, and Mutex? If so, those are built using unsafe code internally.
Do you run on CPUs based on the von Neumann architecture?

If so, those are built on unsafe operations internally.

Safety is a lot more complicated than "whether it is in an unsafe block of code in Rust". If you insist that an unsafe primitive can not be handled well enough to become "safe" by some definition of safe then you collapse the entire programming language hierarchy into "everything is completely unsafe". Which may, from a certain point of view, be true, but isn't a particularly useful classification scheme.

Arrays in Java (a loose equivalent of `Vec`) is a runtime primitive and implemented in a memory-unsafe language. References (loose equivalent of `Box` and `Arc`) as well. Java's `synchronized` (a loose equivalent to `Mutex`) as well. Those are not good counterexamples.
Unsafe rust is still safer than normal C.
Lets compare what's inside this Ruby bug, a C function rb_str_casemap which is 40-50 lines of C fiddling with pointers and calling into macros that presumably are familiar to Ruby developers but opaque to an outside viewer. Is it fixed? I guess so but I can't see very well to be sure, it was counting stuff before and now it is being more careful, I hope it's correct this time.

... against str::to_uppercase the Rust function which has a single line of unsafe code, with a two line rationale provided to explain why it's OK to do this. As a subject matter expert I agree with the rationale. LGTM.

Edited: We're talking about uppercase, they're basically mirrors, but we should choose the uppercase function.

This sub-thread in the conversation is about Java, so comparisons to Ruby aren't what's relevant. Here's part of the relevant GP comment.

> It's important to note that Java, like Rust, is generally seen as a memory safe language. But it has bits of assembly, just like Rust has unsafe blocks, to handle some operations.

And according to sources like CISA and the NSA [1], Java is considered memory safe. Furthermore, Rust has been found to have some memory safety issues as well [2]. I think the point to get across is that yes, Rust can help eliminate a very large set of memory safety bugs, but it's prone to issues that other generally considered memory safe languages also have: at some point to do useful work there are going to be unsafe operations. The surface area might be much smaller, so you're likely better off using a memory safe language if you can help it, but it's not a panacea for having layers of security, especially since it means any issue found is likely to affect a large swath of code written in the language because it's in a load bearing area of the language ecosystem.

[1]: https://www.nsa.gov/Press-Room/Press-Releases-Statements/Pre...

[2]: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/blog/2026/11/09/for...

loading story #50562993
I didn't say there's a lot of unsafe (by whatever measure you consider that to be). I said there's a lot more than in Java.
The JVM is written in an unsafe language. That's where these unsafe calls occur. Clients of these APIs have no control there. Java code itself is safe.
> That's where these unsafe calls occur.

No, it's not. A relatively common case for unsafe in Rust is in data structures. The data structures in the Java runtime are all written in Java and has almost no use of unsafe (there might be a few, but not becsause of language limitation, but because of initialisation order).

As for the JVM, much of it is a compiler. It doesn't matter what language it's written in, as it generates machine code. Indeed, the vulnerability disclosed yesterday was in a compiler intrinsic, but those are just as common in Rust.

Other than that, the other big piece in the JVM is memory management, and it does, indeed, use C and C++ for memory management, but Rust also uses C (the various implementations of malloc/free in whatever runtime the Rust program is using; BTW, some popular malloc/free implementations are almost as big as Java's most complicated GC).

As for native C/C++ libraries (outside the JVM itself), Java programs do use some, but generally not more than Rust programs.

loading story #50566203
loading story #50566251
Not all JVM implementations, there are multi-circular implementations in Java, starting with JikesRVM almost 20 years ago already, whose work with the MMtk memory allocator was later inspired a Rust version thereof.
>which need to be written in assembly to avoid timing attacks

Assembly provides no timing guarantees. You will want something higher level built on top of assembly that can guarantee it for a specific processor.

You don’t think there’s some intrinsic code in llvm that would be generating assembly that doesn’t match Rust’s safety rules?
loading story #50559950
Take a peek into the Rust stdlib method implementations. The lang is built on a house of "unsafe".
loading story #50566216
Rust is as vulnerable as the Java issue l, if you use simd you're in the same boat.
loading story #50566223
loading story #50559953
loading story #50564029
loading story #50567127
loading story #50561988