Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> spinning drives

I'm slightly surprised that these are still being manufactured, but it is obvious to me that their pricing is different from SSDs.

- 3x cheaper per byte

- can be rewritten an infinite number of times

- don't lose data just by sitting unpowered

- tells you when it's about to fail

- data recovery is possible

I have a 20TB HDD which cost me 400€ two years ago. Even at the cheapest prices SSDs have ever been, that would've cost me over 1k. So the question "why do they still make HDDs" seems crazy to me.
They’re much cheaper to produce than SSDs (and their consumer and enterprise prices reflect that), and they’re plenty good for many uses. I don’t like making predictions about the future of technology, but it seems unlikely that they’ll stop being made any time in the next 20 years. They’ll keep getting bigger and cheaper-per-GB.

I wouldn’t want to run the latest AAA video game off one, but they’re fine for most other uses. They’re significantly cheaper per GB, more reliable, and not much slower for most uses. The demand will stick around as long as SSDs don’t become cheaper than them.

Data recovery for HDDs is also generally a decent more likely to be successful.

Obviously it should be your last resort and is not a backup strategy; but the mechanicalness of a HDD makes it far more practical.

Failed heads? Replace the heads.

Failed PCB? Swap in a donor one.

While I’d never recommend it for any important data, if you’re in a pinch and don’t care (and can’t afford professional recovery), it is actually relatively DIY—able even without a clean room. I’ve done it before.

I could see a hyper-dense optical medium replacing magnetic hard drives as the preferred "spinning disk" in the next 20 years.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06980-y

Negative.

Voxel based glass mediums for non-volatile / archival storage will take the place of spinning rust and tape.

Because glass unlike all other mediums (including optical discs) is exceptionally durable and resilient. You don't need to control environmentals for humidity / oxidation. There's no "spinning" involved so there's no wear and no heat generation to worry about. Also virtually silent operations / no noise.

The only problem being the read write io is garbage. Using a single head yeilds worse speeds then USB 2.0

That said, it's just an issue of parallelization and caching. Same kind of stuff we've been doing with HDD's and other archival storage for decades. But it will mean serious capacities (anything above ~16TB) will probably only be available to data centers.

Microsoft has demonstrated nice improvements in this recording method, including higher read/write speeds, but they are still far from having a commercial product, mainly because of a chicken-and-egg problem.

This needs certain kinds of pulsed lasers and optical components that are currently too expensive, mainly because they are not mass-produced, like e.g. the optical components required to make a Blu-Ray drive. But these components are not mass-produced because for now they are not incorporated in any product with a large potential market, which cannot happen as long as they are so expensive.

You can already just go and buy a 32TB drive, although demand for them is pretty high.

LTO-10 is around $10/TB. Demand for that is also high. More data is being produced than ever before in human history.

I swear by magnetic hard drives for long-term storage. SSDs are highly volatile if you leave them unpowered for extended periods of time. Magnetism will remain stable for decades if not centuries. Worst case at least some of the data can be recovered, whilst with SSD you lose every single bit of information.
Not only are they still being manufactured, but they are continuing to see innovations. Heat assisted magnetic recording (HAMR), mentioned in the article, which will heat disk via the R/W head, allowing for higher density drives.
For consumer/business (not enterprise) level hardware, the maximum capacities are much smaller on SSDs/NVMEs (8TB vs 32TB.)
Demand is up and $/TN has gone up in price significantly.

You have to have them to do large scale outs.

I have at least nine spinning in my apartment right now.
Wait until you learn that tapes are still being produced with Fujifilm extending production by quite a lot in the last few years.
I wish tape drives weren't so expensive. Otherwise they'd be amazing for backups
Tape is slow. Around 1TB/hour, so writing a 30TB tape takes an entire day. The faster solution is to write to a couple smaller (8TB is a good compromise) HDDs.
loading story #50563374
I agree. I'd love them for my home setup.
Much bigger capacity on the spinning drives for much less - well at least until this price spike.

I can’t imagine that companies backing up locally are using ssd over hdd.