Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> Smart people who give a shit are a liability for most companies.

I haven't found this to be true at all. When the A-team gets called in for high impact engagements, it's typically smart people who give a shit. They're respected, paid well, and go the extra mile to ensure success. Working with these people is a joy, and they're anything but a liability to their company.

> Most companies want compliant workers who shut up an do what they are told.

You can be compliant and still effect change. Nobody likes a cowboy who ignores directives, and nobody likes a sullen employee who says nothing when they see a problem. Good employees are dynamic enough to follow orders while communicating effectively about concerns.

I'm not saying this is always true across the board, some companies are toxic dumps and the good people leave, but I doubt today's reality doesn't reward the good folks who give a shit. Hiring is hard, and when you find good people, you do what you can to keep them.

> gets called in

There you have it. It is about power structures mainly. The "A team" has a mandate which the scapegoats lack.

(And yes there are exceptions and I am somewhat hyperbolic but I have never found average incompetence to be a problem.)

loading story #50559881
loading story #50558758
loading story #50569663