Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Wishful thinking. Opposition to data centres is nowhere near universal enough to dent demand, nowhere near enough supply is coming online.
Wasn't it given as a major factor in the exit polls for the US midterms? It definitely also ties into affordability, which definitely was one, so I'd assume there is quite some mandate to start curtailing their rolll-out. But maybe it's not enough as you say.
There are lots of places where data centers could be built. If 100 towns reject data center construction and one allows it, the data center gets built. Doesn't even have to be in the US.
Practically the issue is not towns allowing it but the electricity connections, which are being blocked by state legislators.

Even Texas has paused electricity hookups which has stalled several builds and expansions.

Well given the total sum of proposed datacenter project electrical consumption exceeds that of the current generation capacity of the US, the is a reason why legislators started freaking out when they saw the numbers.
loading story #50569724
> Well given the total sum of proposed datacenter project electrical consumption exceeds that of the current generation capacity of the US, the is a reason why legislators started freaking out when they saw the numbers.

We need to get ready to start powering down homes to power AI datacenters. If we don't do it, China might win!

A lot of the push back excuses against data centers has now been unmasked as total lies - like the water story - and other negatives can maybe be addressed - and the benefits are downplayed because F billionaires and F ai, right? But as rightfully pointed out, datacenters have many places they could go, and as emotionally made decisions deprive communities of the benefits, people in other places will wake up and say "uhm we want the benefits THAT place over there got from a datacenter" .... Of course the more people push back for emotional reasons the higher the probability that many communities will have permanently missed the boat, because their pushback forced it to go overseas (much cheaper!) or even space.
What benefit do you get from a data center in your backyard that you wouldn't get from a data center a hundred miles away?
An unberable noise and a higher power bill
Electricity is already pricy enough, I don't need to pay out the ass for AI that I try to stay away from.
Given these datacenter projects appear to do the same ploy of paying off politicians to grant them those property tax breaks and other nonsense. The benefits to local communities is really hard to argue.

A modern large scale data-center may have 20 full time employees at most, this is peanuts in economic benefits to local communities compared to the impact on local resources (Water and electric). I expect the FT employee count to go down slowly in the next decade as there are various companies working overtime to even automate the servicing of server racks when equipment goes down.

> A lot of the push back excuses against data centers has now been unmasked as total lies - like the water story - and other negatives can maybe be addressed

Total lies? "The water story" isn't a total lie. And the other negatives aren't total lies either. It's ironic to dismiss opposition as total lies while not actually saying what the benefits are.

not really, if you look at the % of people citing AI + data centers as crucial or a major factor, it is far lower at 56% than for other factors (89% cost of living, 90% government corruption, 72% immigration enforcement).

Opposition is much more localized/NIMBY-like.

https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2026-elections/exit-polls

56% still sounds pretty high to me, regardless of how it sits relative to other issues.
Hard to say for certain without more extensive polling, but of the issues voters were asked about (cost of living, immigration enforcement policies, war in iran and government corruption), it was the least important one, so I'm not sure by what measure/comparison that sounds "pretty high" to you?
loading story #50574555
Uranium enrichment plants, coal mines and chemical factories have been built all over the US, despite nobody wanting to live near one
How often were such places built remotely and then the towns around them built as worker housing? There's a powerful difference between "This is how this place has always been since I moved here" vs "This new thing is changing how my long term home is".
When people are poor they will accept anything.
yeah. the opposition in the US will simply drive them abroad, where people dgaf. the cost of staffing an overseas DC with a few American overseers is nothing compared to the savings. it's been done a million times during the deindustrialization of US and Europe.