But I set "Default transcript view" to "Thinking" (not even "Verbose") and can see reasoning - is that not the thing?
Yes, it's not the thing supposedly anymore. And there are reasons to believe that because if you do watch it closely you can see that quite a bit of time the answer doesn't seem to follow the reasoning with reasoning being quite shallow or even in the wrong direction.
I never trusted the "chain of thought" to be more than a verbose response. Its a black box, all we really know is they started telling it "show your work" and the model would spit out a bunch of text that sounds reasonable enough before giving the actual answer at the end.
Those aren't the actual reasoning traces. They're highly condensed summaries. The actual thinking tokens are encrypted and invisible to the end user.