They might be weight/parameter count wise, but definitely not perf (this is while over indexing on coding though) or price wise.
Well... This industry moves fast. Carbon had a higher AA score than Astra and Fable when it was announced, though the other labs have updated their models since. Fable 5.2 is clearly better than Carbon; with Astra 6.2 it's a little less clear. I don't think there's much question it's meant to compete against the other labs super-big models.
It's cheaper than astra/fable, but that's likely because they know they've been out of the game for awhile and need to earn back mindshare. Also Carbon is pretty token heavy.
loading story #50557202
To me Carbon feels like it's in the same class as Fable and Astra.
For a recent prototype I used Carbon as a big-brain planner and Astra-6.2 an implementer. It cut some corners while implementing so it is somewhat Sonnet-ish if you know what I mean
People also report that Carbon solved some hard tasks which Fable and Astra could not